Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Punting PATs?

The latest musings from his eminence, Commissioner Roger Goodell, is that the point after touchdown (PAT) is becoming an old relic of a bygone year of football.  It's not exciting since teams convert it at a 99.6% clip.  It's essentially an "automatic point."  And of course since Mr. Goodell wants all aspects of football to be "exciting," he therefore has entertained some "proposals" for how it can be banished like the fumblerooski. 

Let's examine what might happen if in fact the PAT is in fact punted:

One option would have touchdowns going from 6 to 7 points at which point the scoring team would have the option of keeping the 7 or going for an extra point by running a 2-point conversion play.  If the conversion fails, you would "lose" the 7th point and go back down to 6.  What is this, the SAT?  Is that the "guessing penalty?"  I never in my wildest would have ever seen a competitive sport have teams lose points in a game...not to mention losing a point after they HAD JUST SCORED. 

The other option would be to move the PAT kick back about 10 yards so that it's not as "automatic" as a scrimmage kick from the 2 yard line.  However, a 2-point play would still be from the 2.  Welp, that effectively takes the 2-point fake out of the playbook.  You don't see it often, but I tell you when it does happen, it is quite effective.  If a team elects to line up for a PAT in this format, there would virtually be no risk for a fake (not a guarantee of course...but 1 play from the 2 or a fake field goal from the 12?  You be the judge.)

Goodell's rationale for this brilliant idea is that the PAT is "automatic."  Yes, PATs are missed about as often as referees get calls right, but let's turn on the wayback machine, shall we?  You don't want to be the team to be in that 0.4% of misses...

Example 1: Super Bowl XVIII.  A dark day indeed for Redskins fans, it could've been different.  The Raiders led at halftime 21-3.  The Redskins took the 2nd half kickoff and marched all the way for a TD to make it 21-9.  However, Mark Mosely (who was having a terrible playoffs) had the PAT blocked.  This miss killed just about any momentum the Redskins might have had following the TD.  Alas, they never scored again yet watched helplessly as Marcus Allen did a do-si-do and the Raiders cruised 38-9

Example 2: From 2005, observe.


The Saints had just completed a wacky Stanford-band type play with triple zeros on the clock to bring themselves within 20-19 with no time left.  Obviously the option here is to either kick the PAT and go to overtime, or go for broke and win with the deuce try.  The odds certainly favor the PAT as discussed, so Haslett decided to kick.  Carney was wide right and the cat-calls and paper bags were out yet again in what would be a lost season for the 'Aints.  But if Carney had made it, who knows?

Those were just a couple well-known examples of how games turned on PATs, or missed ones in these cases.  Misses of that magnitude are even rarer than misses period, but the point is that the PAT may not be quite as automatic as Mr. Goodell thinks.  As I said, do you want to be THAT team that happens to miss one in critical situations such as these?  That being said, that should be enough of a reason to keep the PAT as is. 

Finally, if the idea behind getting rid of PATs is to make the game more "exciting," he is sorely mistaken.  Football is by its very nature an exciting game.  With all the talk of concussion safety and hard hits, one does not need to follow football to know that it by its very nature is an exciting game.  You want to keep the game exciting?  Don't do something stupid like eliminate kickoffs, but that's another issue. 

Sunday, January 12, 2014

Absolutely Below Zero

Shouldn't I be devoting my full attention to NFL playoff games?  I am, but in the background in case you were wondering.

Found this interesting piece from Nature on Rob's twitter feed.  Anybody who took chemistry or physics in high school should remember the 3 Laws of Thermodynamics.  Let's review, class.

1) Energy in a system is always conserved
2) The entropy (disorder) in the universe is constantly increasing
3) Entropy is zero at the absolute zero temperature.

The last of those 3 laws is the focus of this article.  Absolute zero (approx. -273 degrees Celsius or -460 degrees Fahrenheit) is the theoretical temperature at which all kinetic energy in matter ceases.  Note the word theoretical in that last sentence.  You see, it has never even been achieved.  That is a practical impossibility.  However, if you read this piece from Nature you would see that this group of scientists from Germany are using mathematical models to compare the relative energies of molecules to their actual temperature (temperature itself is defined as the measure of kinetic energy of molecules of matter).  This group is basing their research that the energy of molecules is not necessarily uniform.  In any group of particles, a few particles (but not the majority) will have more energy than others. 

What this group did was use a magnetic field to revert the energies of these particles (potassium atoms at temperatures near absolute zero) so that the majority of them now have HIGHER energy than the rest.  This worked because under normal circumstances, the electron clouds of atoms repel (like charges repel right?).  This close to absolute zero, however, the atoms have such little energy to begin with that this magnetic inversion would in fact cause the atoms to ATTRACT instead of repel.  This attraction would lower their entropy beyond what absolute zero would predict, and thus would make the temperature go below 0 K. 

While this is fascinating research to be sure (and I'm just an armchair scientist), I have a very simple question.  Does this work now mean we have to redefine temperature?  In all my years of science education, I've been taught that absolute zero is it.  No kinetic energy, no temperature, no exceptions.  Well, now we have an exception.  Granted, this exception is just billionths of a degree below absolute zero, it was always just assumed it would be impossible to simply REACH absolute zero let alone go below it.  What does this mean for the Laws of Thermodynamics?  Now I'm not foolish enough to think that these laws will NEVER be broken.  Newton's Laws of Motion were proven technically invalid thanks to Einstein's relativity theory.  Science is always about disproving "laws" and "theories."  As I teach my students, it is so much easier to prove something invalid than it is to prove it correct.  That being said, since we have broken the absolute zero barrier, I'd be curious to see where this goes.  Essentially, how low can you go? 

All the way to the floor?

But what is the floor?

There is no floor...........(try pondering that one)

Monday, January 6, 2014

Remember that time when the world was getting too hot?

BRRRRRRRRR!!!! (from weather.com)
Guys who watch the weather in the DC area all know the name Bob Ryan (NOT the sports journalist from Boston).  He was the chief weather guy at Channel 4 for a number of years.  I used to generally like the way he presented the weather.  While he never came out and publicly said it, I feel like he was a believer in the man-made global warming idea based on the way he presented the weather and his reasoning behind the forecasts.  Didn't really care either way, he usually was fairly accurate in his forecasts, and I didn't watch him for his takes on climatology.  Where am I going with this?  He was the first one to introduce me to the following statement:

Climate is what you expect.  Weather is what you get. 

Amen.

For all this talk about how the ice caps are melting faster than we can possibly imagine, may I present to you exhibit A: the coldest weather we have experienced in over 20 years.  Naturally, since this weather is a point-blank kidney punch to the global warming idea, the climatological sensationalists attempt to explain it by saying that the polar vortex is "weakening" because temperatures at the North Pole are getting too warm. 

Ummm...could it just be that we're having a nasty cold snap, the same way we get the occasional heat wave in July?  It happens, people. 

Climate is what you expect.  Weather is what you get.

Every year we have extremes in temperatures in either direction.  Records are meant to be broken, both on the high end and the low end.  Just because we have some sort of extreme does not mean we need to go Chicken Little and say the world is coming to an end because of global warming...and it's ALL OUR FAULT!  A little common sense would tell you that extremes in weather happen all the time, and it's the AVERAGE of all these events that lead to the climatological norms that we dare deviate from. 

We all remember the Snowmageddon from 2009-2010.  That winter all sorts of records for snowfall were set.  The following winters were relatively mild, and now it looks like we're in for another doozy.  You average it all out, and that's how we get the norms for each day during the year.  In fact, it would be more strange (at least to me anyway) to see a climatological pattern that DOESN'T deviate from the norms all that much.  Bottom line, weather is what weather is.  Trying to pigeon hole it into some all-encompassing theory because it's what everyone else believes (or worse...to forward some political agenda), just like I tell my students, is bad science with a capital BS. 

Finally tonight, in a fitting moment of irony, I present to you this.  These fellas were on their way to an exotic Antarctic expedition to study how the Antarctic sea ice is quickly melting.  They proceeded to get stuck...............in the ice.  I'm happy to report that in spite of Australian and Chinese efforts, the US Coast Guard is currently sending one of its finest icebreakers to rescue the poor scientists.  They do have plenty of food and water and are in no danger.

(Quietly laughing under my breath...because they're perfectly OK.)