I won't officially post my next Millennial essay for a couple of days, but I had to make note of this because I think it ties in quite well. This is shocking. In a regional NLRB ruling, college football players at Northwestern University are now allowed to vote to be represented by the CAPA, a players' union for college football players.
To say this opens a can of worms is the understatement of the year.
For an entire century almost, colleges have offered athletic scholarships to provide students an opportunity to attend college. Scholarships are offered in dozens of sports, not just football. According to the arbitrator's opinion, football players are not in fact students, but rather employees of the private university (public universities are not affected by the ruling). They are employees due to the fact that they receive compensation (in the form of a scholarship) and have to adhere to a strict 52 week, 168 hour per week schedule under the supervision of coaches.
At best, the concept of amateurism was on life support. With this ruling, it is now officially deceased (I chose 1896 as the birth year due to that being the first year of the modern Olympics).
The rationale went on to include the economic windfall football provides universities with both good and bad teams. This windfall can be in the hundreds of millions of dollars, which players and their advocates for years have complained that see very little of that money if anything at all. This has led to all kinds of theories and proposals about pay for play schedules and other compensation for student-athletes. I agreed with some concepts but not for others. Some ideas I agreed with begrudgingly, other not so much. As an educator, my main goal for students, athletes or otherwise, is to prepare them for a world where skills that transcend fields and courts will be far more useful to them than the ability to dunk a basketball...or a football.
Athletic scholarships are a major way several students can get that college education they otherwise might not be able to sniff. However, as athletics, and football in particular, began to just explode in popularity, universities started to rake in millions of dollars. As soon as millions of dollars entered the equation, of course that changes the whole game.
30, 20, 10, even 5 years ago, would the concept of college players forming a union even be contemplated, let alone a reality?
As Ivan Maisel notes, there are now so many other questions this ruling begs to be answered. Do athletes in non-revenue sports get the same treatment as football players? They get athletic scholarships and have to adhere to strict schedules as well, but their sports may not generate a tenth of the revenue that football does. What about academic requirements? If athletes are no-longer student-athletes, can we just kiss the idea of grade point average goodbye too?
There is one simple solution that universities (and the NCAA) can adopt that can take this ruling and render it meaningless, but you know it will never happen.
Drop football as an interscholastic sport.
You heard me. Drop football. It sounds just as weird as it looks.
Or at the very least, place more of an emphasis on the academic part of being a student-athlete, instead of having Nick Saban run Alabama players' lives in the weight room. If big-time Division I-A schools placed half the emphasis on academics that other institutions do, make the kids succeed in the classroom just as much as if not more than on the field, we probably are not having this debate. Unfortunately, the 1% of student-athletes who advance to the NFL are dictating what the 99% of student-athletes who do not can and cannot do. Enforce academic eligibility requirements...really enforce them. If you can't maintain a 2.5, your priorities need to be elsewhere, not on the football field. Academic scholarships are directly tied to GPA, why not athletic? Universities love to boast about high GPAs of incoming and outgoing classes. Why can't football players be a part of that? College is supposed to prepare you for far more than a fleeting career in professional sports leagues. If colleges can get back to that emphasis (and less on Nick Saban winning more championships), I think you will see just as exciting games, and better people who play and coach them.
If that is just not possible, drop football. At least that way I can guarantee there will be no picket lines, just ticket lines.
Thursday, March 27, 2014
Monday, March 24, 2014
3 Pillars of the American Dream: Home Ownership vs. Seeing the World
I don’t
mean to turn this into an economics 101 lecture, but indulge me for a
minute. How much did a gallon of gas
cost in 1978 (at the time of Jimmy Carter’s oil embargo)? That
would be 62 cents. Today, anywhere
from $3.50 to $4.00 depending on where you are in the country…can we go back to
1978??? Obviously, as the government
prints more money its value becomes less.
As population grows, demand increases for certain commodities. As the currency supply increases so does
inflation. All of these factor into why
prices for goods and services naturally tend to increase over time. Salaries and wages naturally increase over
time to account for these increases in basic expenses (cost of living adjustments
or COLAs). Businesses ordinarily can
afford these wage increases due to increasing costs passed onto consumers. Combine that with businesses increasing their
prices to respond to the higher money supply, not to mention shrewd marketing, and
business should not be hurt in the long term.
Everybody wins.
Housing and
real estate, like any other good that is bought and sold, has generally
followed this pattern. In fact, housing
historically has virtually GUARANTEED a safe return on investment from the time
the house is purchased. It was almost a
certainty that a homeowner would sell their house for more than what they paid
for it.
We can have
a debate about what caused housing prices to collapse. Most attribute it to the availability of
cheap or interest free home loans that “ballooned” after a certain time
(ARMs). When the balloon triggered, most
people could not afford the sudden increase (often blindsiding them), thus
forcing them to default on the loans and banks to foreclose the property. We still see lots of this now. The result is that banks own what amount to
hundreds of dead assets that are just collecting dust, instead of
interest. To call this a buyer’s market
when it comes to home ownership is quite the understatement. It has been that way for quite some time.
Yet, the
20-something crowd who you would think would be jumping at the chance for
getting into real estate on the ground floor, are instead looking for the top
floor downtown with a view…and they renew the lease on a year to year
basis.
So why are
the Millennials avoiding home ownership like the plague? As discussed in my first essay, most of them
cannot afford it. One of the main
culprits is mounting student debt. Why
are student debts so high? It is a
combination of the dramatic increases in college education and the lack of
parental support.
I work in a
profession where helicopter parents are an occupational hazard. They are so afraid that their little darlings
will get hurt that they will do whatever it takes to make them happy (which
kind of leads into the subject of essay #4, but I will avoid the tangent for
now). When I was a child, and I would
play my mother in games, she would NEVER let me or my siblings win. It did not matter if we were playing Go Fish,
Monopoly, Scrabble, or even Tic Tac Toe.
I would always lose and it made me hoppin’ mad! However, as time wore on, and I learned the
different tricks of each game (not to mention more of a mastery of the English
language), the tide started to turn and as you might have guessed, I became the
winner and Mommy dearest started to rack up the L’s. The whole point was that I had experienced
FAILURE, and from that failure I learned how to win.
Now if I
can only translate that onto the softball field…I digress again.
What did that
last stream of consciousness have to do with home ownership? By the time Millennials end up out of
college, despite the helicopter parent syndrome, Mommy and Daddy might not have
footed the bill because THEY themselves could not afford it for whatever
reason, so the kids took out loans not really thinking at the time that
eventually they would have to be paid back…with interest. If they wanted a degree, they had no
choice. “No problem, right? I’ll just put in my 4 years, get my degree,
and I’ll have a job waiting for me.”
In the
words of the great philosophizer Scooby Doo, “RUH ROH!”
Not
everybody can get a job at Google. Not
everybody can get a job that pays a 6 figure salary upon graduation. Quite simply, college graduates just cannot
get the jobs that they truly want. They
cannot have them because A) they just are not there or B) employers cannot
afford to hire them. Why would a
business owner want to hire someone with a college degree and pay them more
when they can hire someone who only has a GED to do the same work and pay them
significantly less? Now this is not to
say that high school kids are stealing all the jobs, they are definitely not,
but cheap labor is the best way to keep down the costs of business. Skilled labor costs more. As a result, extremely well-qualified
Millenials are getting the shaft. So
when they do not get the job they want, they have to settle for something
else. They settle, they don’t make as
much money as they would have liked, and combine that with the already-present
student debt, there is no way for them to start building savings. Thus, a down payment is out of the
question. 401(k)? Forget about it. They need to make sure today’s bills get
paid.
At the
start of this piece, I noted that the pillar has shifted from Home Ownership to
Seeing the World. How do you make that
kind of a leap? How do you explain that
if kids are unable to afford anything but a 1-bedroom rental, how can they
afford to see the world? Before we
answer this question, let us take a look at how social media and instant
gratification play into this. Facebook
is notorious for promoting people’s “life events.” Often times they have several photo galleries
to that effect.
Now think about that. For somebody who is desperately trying to save for a home purchase (like I was), $3,000 can go a long way toward a down payment. Heck, that itself is probably an entire good faith deposit! However, from the Millennials’ perspective, you are just adding zeroes. A 3 bedroom townhouse costs $200,000 (give or take). A trip to the Eternal City costs only a tenth of that.
Now, of
course, if such a huge trip is well-planned, there is nothing that says you
cannot both own a home and travel.
Again, I do not want anyone to think that I am suggesting travel is a
bad idea, not in the slightest! I love traveling just as much as the next guy!
Source
Material:
Monday, March 17, 2014
3 Pillars of the American Dream: An Introduction
I
read an article last week as I perused my usual news cycle
(while enjoying my Dunkin Donuts special of course), and I came across this
piece from Time
Magazine: “Costco is Facing a Looming Bulk Sized
Problem.” When I read that headline I at
first was puzzled. While I myself am not
a frequenter of Costco (what am I going to do with that much stuff???), I never
would have imagined that Costco would be in any sort of financial danger. After all, I hear about it all the time at
work and other places, either Costco or BJs, people swearing by their
memberships.
As I read the piece, my
thinking started to shift. Perhaps
Costco isn’t as healthy as I thought.
After all, my first thought before I read it was that I myself am not a
Costco shopper.
And that is exactly
the point.
We are entering, or
have already entered, a severe demographic shift in not only the USA but the whole
world, and what is happening at Costco is just a microcosm of that shift. What is happening at Costco is indicative of
a shift in priorities and values among the populace, and the “Millennials” in
particular.
Who are the Millennials? Those of you reading this might even be
considered Millennials. I, being born in
1983, am a borderline Millennial. You
hear that word being used a lot today in all kinds of media. Millennials are defined as people who are
coming of age in the new millennium, the 21st Century. Often times you will hear it used with almost
a jingoistic tone to it: something along the lines of “We are the Millennials! This is OUR generation!” Or you could hear that Millenials “need to be
listened to” and “they are who are driving the nation” or something like
that. Why do the Millennials
matter? In an era of rapid population
growth, and the Baby Boomers on the verge of retirement, Millennials are now
taking over cityscapes, and more importantly, social media. They live in an era of instant gratification
thanks to technology and ever-shifting social norms.
I grew up in a
household that emphasized traditional values, and for the most part those
values have stuck with me as I entered adulthood. However, if you ask people my age and
especially younger what their values are, I would bet more than a few nickels
that their answers might be a little different from mine.
Here’s what I
mean. All throughout the 20th
Century (and even today) we hear about living the “American Dream.” What exactly is the “American Dream?” Historically, from what I have read and what
I have experienced, the traditional American Dream can be summarized in three
basic concepts:
1. Home ownership
2. Starting and raising a family
3. Securing retirement
These concepts pretty much summarize what America was like when the Baby Boomers and Generation X crowd were growing up. Everyone wants the generation that follows them to be more successful than them, or so one would think. Owning a home is considered one of the pinnacles of personal success. I can proudly say that one of my proudest moments is when I received the keys to my first home nearly 3 years ago. What do you do after you buy a home? That is when the family dynamics enter: Mom, Dad, 2.8 kids, a dog, and maybe a white picket fence. You want the next generation to be better off than you, right? This is where the next generation is traditionally conceived (both literally and figuratively). Once the kids are in the picture, then it is up to Mom and Dad to secure their nest egg so that when they are gone their kids and grandkids will be safe and secure, so that they can repeat the cycle for their kids and grandkids, and the beat goes on. Meanwhile, maybe, just maybe, Mom and Dad can save up during that time just enough for that second honeymoon they never got to have.
That is the American Dream…or is it?
How many Millennials (ages 18-35) do you think are all that concerned right now with retirement, with having kids, with even owning their own home? Be honest.
Where do most Millennials live? Thanks to rampant gentrification, which I have experienced first-hand in cities like Washington, Baltimore, and New York, more and more young people are returning to high-rise rentals in the city cores and evacuating the ‘burbs. Population density is skyrocketing in these areas. Millenials are not as likely to own cars, let alone homes, than their Baby Boomer and Gen X counterparts.
Why? They can’t afford it!
Thanks to mounting and mounting student debt (not to mention national debt) due to the ever-increasing cost of a college education, rising unemployment due to a lack of quality jobs, and fewer and fewer incentives for people to start businesses and hire (legal) workers, you have Millennials living far different lives now than their parents. Entrepreneurship is well on the decline. A major driving force in the way Millennials live has to do with incurring as little debt as possible, which leads to what I feel is a complete shift of the American Dream. What do Millennials now view as the American Dream? Here is what I have concluded it is:
1. Seeing the World
2. Having as many friends as possible
3. Doing whatever makes you happy
Notice that these concepts present a stark contrast to the conservative Baby Boomer view of the American Dream. If you can’t comfortably afford a home, kids, or a nest egg, why should that be part of the American Dream? Instead, Millennials believe that their American Dream ought to be more personal to them. Live life now while you can. It’s the old “Carpe Diem” mentality we learned about in Brit Lit class in high school.
My parents instilled in me and my siblings the mentality that you have to think for the future. You have to think 5, 10, 20, even 40 years ahead. The assumption is that we live longer, but can’t work forever, and you have to be prepared. However, Millennials don’t share that attitude. “Why think about what life will be like when I’m 65 when right now I’m only 25?” A lot of this attitude is fostered by social media. As soon as somebody does something interesting…BANG!...there it is on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, whatever, and people naturally want to be copycats. Thanks to social media, we live in a society that thrives on instant gratification. Living in a constantly interconnected society also allows everyone to know what everyone else is doing at all times…all the good and the bad. People are naturally empathetic, so they do what they can to help and make a difference…in a completely different way than their parents did.
This is just the first in a series of essays that I would like to write on this topic, because I feel like it is an important topic, especially for people my age and younger (and to think…it all started with reading an article about Costco). For each essay in the rest of this series, I will focus on a different aspect of this shift in the American Dream. Each pillar gets its own piece. The first will focus on the dynamic between wanting to own a home, and wanting to see the world. The second will be on the friends and family comparison. And the third will be on retirement versus “Carpe Diem.”
Of course, I invite all kinds of commentary and debate. I feel like this is an important discussion to have. But please no snarky remarks.
Source material:
http://time.com/18671/costco-is-facing-a-looming-bulk-sized-problem/
http://business.time.com/2013/08/09/the-great-debate-do-millennials-really-want-cars-or-not/ http://time.com/5074/millennials-put-their-surprising-stamp-on-the-american-dream/ http://rooseveltinstitute.org/new-roosevelt/american-dream-dead-millennials http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/11/10/are-millennials-turning-their-backs-on-the-american-dream.html
http://www.policymic.com/articles/69375/what-the-american-dream-means-for-millennials http://www.foxbusiness.com/personal-finance/2013/09/10/changing-american-dream-what-it-means-for-future-generations/
http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2013/08/the-outsiders-how-can-millennials-change-washington-if-they-hate-it/278920/
http://www.iop.harvard.edu/institute-politics-spring-2013-pollutm_source=email&utm_medium=pressrelease&utm_campaign=SpringPoll2013
1. Home ownership
2. Starting and raising a family
3. Securing retirement
These concepts pretty much summarize what America was like when the Baby Boomers and Generation X crowd were growing up. Everyone wants the generation that follows them to be more successful than them, or so one would think. Owning a home is considered one of the pinnacles of personal success. I can proudly say that one of my proudest moments is when I received the keys to my first home nearly 3 years ago. What do you do after you buy a home? That is when the family dynamics enter: Mom, Dad, 2.8 kids, a dog, and maybe a white picket fence. You want the next generation to be better off than you, right? This is where the next generation is traditionally conceived (both literally and figuratively). Once the kids are in the picture, then it is up to Mom and Dad to secure their nest egg so that when they are gone their kids and grandkids will be safe and secure, so that they can repeat the cycle for their kids and grandkids, and the beat goes on. Meanwhile, maybe, just maybe, Mom and Dad can save up during that time just enough for that second honeymoon they never got to have.
That is the American Dream…or is it?
How many Millennials (ages 18-35) do you think are all that concerned right now with retirement, with having kids, with even owning their own home? Be honest.
Where do most Millennials live? Thanks to rampant gentrification, which I have experienced first-hand in cities like Washington, Baltimore, and New York, more and more young people are returning to high-rise rentals in the city cores and evacuating the ‘burbs. Population density is skyrocketing in these areas. Millenials are not as likely to own cars, let alone homes, than their Baby Boomer and Gen X counterparts.
Why? They can’t afford it!
Thanks to mounting and mounting student debt (not to mention national debt) due to the ever-increasing cost of a college education, rising unemployment due to a lack of quality jobs, and fewer and fewer incentives for people to start businesses and hire (legal) workers, you have Millennials living far different lives now than their parents. Entrepreneurship is well on the decline. A major driving force in the way Millennials live has to do with incurring as little debt as possible, which leads to what I feel is a complete shift of the American Dream. What do Millennials now view as the American Dream? Here is what I have concluded it is:
1. Seeing the World
2. Having as many friends as possible
3. Doing whatever makes you happy
Notice that these concepts present a stark contrast to the conservative Baby Boomer view of the American Dream. If you can’t comfortably afford a home, kids, or a nest egg, why should that be part of the American Dream? Instead, Millennials believe that their American Dream ought to be more personal to them. Live life now while you can. It’s the old “Carpe Diem” mentality we learned about in Brit Lit class in high school.
My parents instilled in me and my siblings the mentality that you have to think for the future. You have to think 5, 10, 20, even 40 years ahead. The assumption is that we live longer, but can’t work forever, and you have to be prepared. However, Millennials don’t share that attitude. “Why think about what life will be like when I’m 65 when right now I’m only 25?” A lot of this attitude is fostered by social media. As soon as somebody does something interesting…BANG!...there it is on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, whatever, and people naturally want to be copycats. Thanks to social media, we live in a society that thrives on instant gratification. Living in a constantly interconnected society also allows everyone to know what everyone else is doing at all times…all the good and the bad. People are naturally empathetic, so they do what they can to help and make a difference…in a completely different way than their parents did.
This is just the first in a series of essays that I would like to write on this topic, because I feel like it is an important topic, especially for people my age and younger (and to think…it all started with reading an article about Costco). For each essay in the rest of this series, I will focus on a different aspect of this shift in the American Dream. Each pillar gets its own piece. The first will focus on the dynamic between wanting to own a home, and wanting to see the world. The second will be on the friends and family comparison. And the third will be on retirement versus “Carpe Diem.”
Of course, I invite all kinds of commentary and debate. I feel like this is an important discussion to have. But please no snarky remarks.
Source material:
http://time.com/18671/costco-is-facing-a-looming-bulk-sized-problem/
http://business.time.com/2013/08/09/the-great-debate-do-millennials-really-want-cars-or-not/ http://time.com/5074/millennials-put-their-surprising-stamp-on-the-american-dream/ http://rooseveltinstitute.org/new-roosevelt/american-dream-dead-millennials http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2013/11/10/are-millennials-turning-their-backs-on-the-american-dream.html
http://www.policymic.com/articles/69375/what-the-american-dream-means-for-millennials http://www.foxbusiness.com/personal-finance/2013/09/10/changing-american-dream-what-it-means-for-future-generations/
http://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2013/08/the-outsiders-how-can-millennials-change-washington-if-they-hate-it/278920/
http://www.iop.harvard.edu/institute-politics-spring-2013-pollutm_source=email&utm_medium=pressrelease&utm_campaign=SpringPoll2013
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)