A interview is out today by former North Carolina basketball star Rashad McCants who said that while at UNC, and especially during their championship run in 2005, he took sham paper-classes where the papers were written by tutors and rarely (if ever) he actually went to class. According to McCants, his job as a collegian was to simply "show up and play (basketball)."
Accusations of academic misconduct at North Carolina have been brewing for a few months, and this report is just the latest in a series of accusations ranging from fraudulent classes to cheating tutors.
The union boys over at Northwestern might be onto something.
As I've already articulated here at the blog a few months ago, if the concept of amateurism is not already dead, it is on life support with somebody ready to pull the plug. Who would have thought even 5 years ago, let alone 10, 20, or 30, that college athletes would even consider joining a labor union? Who would have even thought that they would be considered "employees" of an academic institution? However, accusations such as these at UNC, if verified to be true, certainly would lend some weight to their arguments.
Now I have said numerous times that I am all for fairness toward athletes, although this does not mean paying them. What really needs to get reformed is the entire culture of college athletics. In an ideal world, college athletics would be more like the Division III model where everyone is a walk-on. Nevertheless, the whole concept of a scholarship is to afford college and all its benefits on students who otherwise would not be able to afford it. College tuition being what it is, athletic scholarship is really the only way several kids nationwide can have a crack at college. However, thanks to the ever flowing money coming from rich booster clubs and alumni who just want to thump their chests about their alma maters' football teams (not to mention all the gambling riches), more and more emphasis has been placed on the athletic success instead of the life success that college is really supposed to be preparing its students.
In this latest UNC scandal, McCants recounted that since coach Roy Williams took the helm in 2003, his "grades" dramatically improved. As a freshman, with coach Matt Doherty, his GPA was in the proverbial tank, thus jeopardizing his NCAA eligibility. However, when this issue was brought to the attention of the new coach, Williams took advantage of some creative course selection and tutorship so that McCants' "grades" skyrocketed to straight A's and a Dean's List in 2005. All the while, McCants saw the inside of a classroom less than half of that semester. What he was doing the rest of the time is anybody's guess, but thanks to the so-called "paper-courses," the only thing necessary for a grade was a single "paper," which according to McCants, was written by the tutors, and let's just say that some of the other papers written by UNC's finest...were not of the finest quality.
All this does is support the wide ranging accusations that players are nothing more than pawns in a grand scheme to raise the school money exploiting their athletic talents. Meanwhile, to call what these players are receiving in return an "education" is insulting, and that is the biggest travesty of all. If these players do not make professional rosters (which if you believe statistics is a better than average chance), their chances of succeeding in the real world is practically zero, and there will be no players union to support them.
How can this be fixed without having to concede that players are employees and a union is their only way of getting the support they need? It really is simple. Make sure that student-athletes are STUDENTS first, and ATHLETES second. The mission of every college in the world is to prepare all of their students for success in the world. Athletic careers are fleeting, with even the best professional players of our generation retiring in their 40s. People need skills to survive, especially in a down economy where employers are looking now more than ever for workers with highly specialized skill sets. For any athlete who receives a college scholarship, constant checks on classroom attendance should be mandatory, as well as (legitimate) mandatory tutoring. Self-directed and "paper-classes" should not be an option, due to the obvious opportunities for fraud. Academic eligibility requirements do not need to be tinkered, they just need to be enforced, and coaches need to be educated on them more than they already are. To wit, coaches' performances should not just be measured by on-field and on-court success, but by classroom success as well. If the 6-year graduation rates for an athletic program fall below certain thresholds, coaches can be at risk for loss of salary or even termination. Does that sound extreme? Perhaps, but you have to remember the goal here is ultimately going to be life success, and that goes way beyond sports. College coaches are not professional coaches. They coach kids, and they are teachers just as much as they are coaches, and if their students are not ready for what awaits them after their eligibility expires, then they have not done their jobs.
For those that say that the money is the problem, they have a point. Now I am not going to say that Division I has to become Division III, not by any stretch. Division I schools and athletic departments do have an obligation to support their athletes as they are ambassadors for the school in addition to students. I am all for supporting the full cost of attendance (honestly...I thought scholarships already did that. I was wrong). However, that should be ALL the support they need. Since most of these Power 5 schools are just dripping with cash as it is, there is going to be a surplus. Colleges are not-for-profit enterprises. How much of that money gets spent on new science department equipment? Or the arts? These are other ways that schools can support the full cost of attendance, by exposing athletes to other areas of expertise beyond their athletic talents. Let them know that there are other careers available to them that they will (at some point) need to explore. Not everyone can just fit into an ESPN analyst chair when they retire. Thus, some revenue sharing between fat athletic departments and the rest of the school is an excellent idea. This would also allow some of the smaller schools who do not have quite as rich an athletic budget to at least maintain a somewhat more level playing field.
I'm not saying that coaches like Nick Saban (who I like to pick on here granted) need a pay cut either. However, with great wealth comes great responsibility. Yes, he wins football games, but are his players ready for life as well as the game? I don't care how many national titles you win, if your players are not prepared for what will come after their eligibility has expired, you have not done your job.
Message to presidents, ADs, coaches, and administrators all across the NCAA fruited plain. Do your job. Do right by this kids. Make sure they are STUDENTS first, and take your TEACHER responsibilities seriously. If you do that, you will never have to hear about the College Athletic Players Association ever again.
Showing posts with label college football. Show all posts
Showing posts with label college football. Show all posts
Friday, June 6, 2014
Thursday, March 27, 2014
Amateurism: 1896-2014
I won't officially post my next Millennial essay for a couple of days, but I had to make note of this because I think it ties in quite well. This is shocking. In a regional NLRB ruling, college football players at Northwestern University are now allowed to vote to be represented by the CAPA, a players' union for college football players.
To say this opens a can of worms is the understatement of the year.
For an entire century almost, colleges have offered athletic scholarships to provide students an opportunity to attend college. Scholarships are offered in dozens of sports, not just football. According to the arbitrator's opinion, football players are not in fact students, but rather employees of the private university (public universities are not affected by the ruling). They are employees due to the fact that they receive compensation (in the form of a scholarship) and have to adhere to a strict 52 week, 168 hour per week schedule under the supervision of coaches.
At best, the concept of amateurism was on life support. With this ruling, it is now officially deceased (I chose 1896 as the birth year due to that being the first year of the modern Olympics).
The rationale went on to include the economic windfall football provides universities with both good and bad teams. This windfall can be in the hundreds of millions of dollars, which players and their advocates for years have complained that see very little of that money if anything at all. This has led to all kinds of theories and proposals about pay for play schedules and other compensation for student-athletes. I agreed with some concepts but not for others. Some ideas I agreed with begrudgingly, other not so much. As an educator, my main goal for students, athletes or otherwise, is to prepare them for a world where skills that transcend fields and courts will be far more useful to them than the ability to dunk a basketball...or a football.
Athletic scholarships are a major way several students can get that college education they otherwise might not be able to sniff. However, as athletics, and football in particular, began to just explode in popularity, universities started to rake in millions of dollars. As soon as millions of dollars entered the equation, of course that changes the whole game.
30, 20, 10, even 5 years ago, would the concept of college players forming a union even be contemplated, let alone a reality?
As Ivan Maisel notes, there are now so many other questions this ruling begs to be answered. Do athletes in non-revenue sports get the same treatment as football players? They get athletic scholarships and have to adhere to strict schedules as well, but their sports may not generate a tenth of the revenue that football does. What about academic requirements? If athletes are no-longer student-athletes, can we just kiss the idea of grade point average goodbye too?
There is one simple solution that universities (and the NCAA) can adopt that can take this ruling and render it meaningless, but you know it will never happen.
Drop football as an interscholastic sport.
You heard me. Drop football. It sounds just as weird as it looks.
Or at the very least, place more of an emphasis on the academic part of being a student-athlete, instead of having Nick Saban run Alabama players' lives in the weight room. If big-time Division I-A schools placed half the emphasis on academics that other institutions do, make the kids succeed in the classroom just as much as if not more than on the field, we probably are not having this debate. Unfortunately, the 1% of student-athletes who advance to the NFL are dictating what the 99% of student-athletes who do not can and cannot do. Enforce academic eligibility requirements...really enforce them. If you can't maintain a 2.5, your priorities need to be elsewhere, not on the football field. Academic scholarships are directly tied to GPA, why not athletic? Universities love to boast about high GPAs of incoming and outgoing classes. Why can't football players be a part of that? College is supposed to prepare you for far more than a fleeting career in professional sports leagues. If colleges can get back to that emphasis (and less on Nick Saban winning more championships), I think you will see just as exciting games, and better people who play and coach them.
If that is just not possible, drop football. At least that way I can guarantee there will be no picket lines, just ticket lines.
To say this opens a can of worms is the understatement of the year.
For an entire century almost, colleges have offered athletic scholarships to provide students an opportunity to attend college. Scholarships are offered in dozens of sports, not just football. According to the arbitrator's opinion, football players are not in fact students, but rather employees of the private university (public universities are not affected by the ruling). They are employees due to the fact that they receive compensation (in the form of a scholarship) and have to adhere to a strict 52 week, 168 hour per week schedule under the supervision of coaches.
At best, the concept of amateurism was on life support. With this ruling, it is now officially deceased (I chose 1896 as the birth year due to that being the first year of the modern Olympics).
The rationale went on to include the economic windfall football provides universities with both good and bad teams. This windfall can be in the hundreds of millions of dollars, which players and their advocates for years have complained that see very little of that money if anything at all. This has led to all kinds of theories and proposals about pay for play schedules and other compensation for student-athletes. I agreed with some concepts but not for others. Some ideas I agreed with begrudgingly, other not so much. As an educator, my main goal for students, athletes or otherwise, is to prepare them for a world where skills that transcend fields and courts will be far more useful to them than the ability to dunk a basketball...or a football.
Athletic scholarships are a major way several students can get that college education they otherwise might not be able to sniff. However, as athletics, and football in particular, began to just explode in popularity, universities started to rake in millions of dollars. As soon as millions of dollars entered the equation, of course that changes the whole game.
30, 20, 10, even 5 years ago, would the concept of college players forming a union even be contemplated, let alone a reality?
As Ivan Maisel notes, there are now so many other questions this ruling begs to be answered. Do athletes in non-revenue sports get the same treatment as football players? They get athletic scholarships and have to adhere to strict schedules as well, but their sports may not generate a tenth of the revenue that football does. What about academic requirements? If athletes are no-longer student-athletes, can we just kiss the idea of grade point average goodbye too?
There is one simple solution that universities (and the NCAA) can adopt that can take this ruling and render it meaningless, but you know it will never happen.
Drop football as an interscholastic sport.
You heard me. Drop football. It sounds just as weird as it looks.
Or at the very least, place more of an emphasis on the academic part of being a student-athlete, instead of having Nick Saban run Alabama players' lives in the weight room. If big-time Division I-A schools placed half the emphasis on academics that other institutions do, make the kids succeed in the classroom just as much as if not more than on the field, we probably are not having this debate. Unfortunately, the 1% of student-athletes who advance to the NFL are dictating what the 99% of student-athletes who do not can and cannot do. Enforce academic eligibility requirements...really enforce them. If you can't maintain a 2.5, your priorities need to be elsewhere, not on the football field. Academic scholarships are directly tied to GPA, why not athletic? Universities love to boast about high GPAs of incoming and outgoing classes. Why can't football players be a part of that? College is supposed to prepare you for far more than a fleeting career in professional sports leagues. If colleges can get back to that emphasis (and less on Nick Saban winning more championships), I think you will see just as exciting games, and better people who play and coach them.
If that is just not possible, drop football. At least that way I can guarantee there will be no picket lines, just ticket lines.
Thursday, December 1, 2011
Caputo's Takes on the Sports World
Lots to talk about in the Sports World here at Caputo's Corner. December is shaping up to be quite an active month as we come down the stretch in the NFL season (not like my team will have any say in the outcome) and coaches are getting canned left and right in the NHL, including in Washington. Things are getting awfully creepy on college campuses in the wake of the Penn State fiasco, just ask Syracuse. Caputo's Corner takes a look at the goings on.
-So now Syracuse is under the pedophile coach spotlight. Syracuse basketball is very much like Penn State football when it comes to prominence in the sport, and Jim Boeheim is about as iconic a basketball coach as Joe Paterno was a football coach, and now they can share something else in common...albeit a litte more grotesque. Longtime basketball assistant Bernard Fine was fired this week after an individual who is now 29 years old came forward and accused Fine of abusing him while he was a Syracuse ballboy several years ago. In the immediate aftermath of the accusation, Boeheim immediately came to the defense of his assistant in a very angry manner, essentially dismissing the accusation as false. Now, as the facts start to trickle in, namely a tape recording on which Fine's wife admits to the deviant behavior, Boeheim appears moreso to have egg on his face. These allegations are not new, but the University did its own investigation in 2005 and found no hard evidence of wrongdoing, thus leaving Fine on the payroll at the time. Boeheim claims to have no knowledge of the alleged misbehavior, and thus will not receive the same treatment that Paterno received at Penn State (where things are just getting worse for Jerry Sandusky...as the civil suits are now starting and he's now considering just copping a plea). All of these episodes are simply pathetic. What has college sports devolved into? College sports used to be about pride, sportsmanship, and fun. Now they are all about improper benefits, academic fraud, and sexual abuse of minors. Meanwhile, the University of Maryland just whacked 8 varsity sports starting at the end of the academic year. Now, let me ask you, who involved with those programs are involved in any of the deviant activities mentioned before? The answer: nobody. And why again are their programs getting the ax? I'm not saying to cut football and basketball. It just seems weird to me that swimming and diving are "unsustainable" while football and basketball rake in more money than they can count...in spite of all of the bad behavior going on.
-Ndamukong Suh was suspended for two games by the NFL for this act of savagry on Thanksgiving Day...I didn't know Thanksgiving was a day where stomping on somebody was a valid sign of affection. Suh was ejected for that play and his run of personal fouls over the course of his short career has quickly attained him the label of a "dirty player." Whether or not he intends to play dirty is really nobody's guess, but the bottom line is that this guy is extremely talented. He was nominated for just about every award a defensive lineman can receive while at Nebraska, the Outland, the Lombardi, the Bednarik, the list goes on and on. However, ever since the Lions chose him with the #2 pick in the 2010 draft, he has developed some kind of mean streak. Now his trophies are being replaced with yellow flags, steep fines, and now suspensions and ejections. I am kind of surprised that after this latest episode that the league is not mandating that Suh receive anger management or some other kind of therapy. Once is a mistake, twice is a trend, and three times is a problem. In Suh's case, this is far more than just three times. This may have been the first time he had been ejected, but there have been several severe penalties that ejection could have been warranted, but the refs chose not to do so. Getting ejected in this league is hard to do and Suh pulled it off with style. I really think some anger management would do him some good. Since the league won't step up to the plate and make him get some help, perhaps the Lions will step in and make him do it. Perhaps pressure from esteemed bloggers like myself will make him do it. No sir, not the NFL, they'll just take their fine check, give him a token suspension, and call it a day.
-The NBA lockout is over, we think. After several failed proposals, the league and union seem to have finally come to an accord that will allow the season to start on Christmas Day with a tripleheader. The season has been reduced to 66 games. And that's all I have to say about that.
![]() |
| Boeheim (from rumorsandrants.com) |
-So now Syracuse is under the pedophile coach spotlight. Syracuse basketball is very much like Penn State football when it comes to prominence in the sport, and Jim Boeheim is about as iconic a basketball coach as Joe Paterno was a football coach, and now they can share something else in common...albeit a litte more grotesque. Longtime basketball assistant Bernard Fine was fired this week after an individual who is now 29 years old came forward and accused Fine of abusing him while he was a Syracuse ballboy several years ago. In the immediate aftermath of the accusation, Boeheim immediately came to the defense of his assistant in a very angry manner, essentially dismissing the accusation as false. Now, as the facts start to trickle in, namely a tape recording on which Fine's wife admits to the deviant behavior, Boeheim appears moreso to have egg on his face. These allegations are not new, but the University did its own investigation in 2005 and found no hard evidence of wrongdoing, thus leaving Fine on the payroll at the time. Boeheim claims to have no knowledge of the alleged misbehavior, and thus will not receive the same treatment that Paterno received at Penn State (where things are just getting worse for Jerry Sandusky...as the civil suits are now starting and he's now considering just copping a plea). All of these episodes are simply pathetic. What has college sports devolved into? College sports used to be about pride, sportsmanship, and fun. Now they are all about improper benefits, academic fraud, and sexual abuse of minors. Meanwhile, the University of Maryland just whacked 8 varsity sports starting at the end of the academic year. Now, let me ask you, who involved with those programs are involved in any of the deviant activities mentioned before? The answer: nobody. And why again are their programs getting the ax? I'm not saying to cut football and basketball. It just seems weird to me that swimming and diving are "unsustainable" while football and basketball rake in more money than they can count...in spite of all of the bad behavior going on.
![]() |
| Suh (from askmen.com) |
-The NBA lockout is over, we think. After several failed proposals, the league and union seem to have finally come to an accord that will allow the season to start on Christmas Day with a tripleheader. The season has been reduced to 66 games. And that's all I have to say about that.
Thursday, November 10, 2011
Thursday Night Pick and Riot Watch
Our latest edition of riot watch continues to follow the aftermath of the episode last night in State College, PA when a herd of unruly students quickly turned a peaceful gathering into one of the more regretful riots of the year. I found it quite ironic that the reason they were rioting was in support of Joe Paterno. It's ironic in that Paterno built his reputation on adhering to a moral code, something I don't think anybody in State College had last night. Say what you want about whether or not you think Paterno should have been canned, but do you really think that the best way to get yout point across is to tip over a news van?
The real sickening part of this story is to hear students say they were part of the riot because they "didn't want to miss it." They sound like Maryland students, rioting for no good reason other than to say you were part of a riot. For the ones who were there because they were just venting their frustration over their beloved coach, how do they think anyone will take any of you seriously by attacking police? The only thing that will take them seriously is that cloud of mace that's entering their eyes. Police finally was able to disperse the crowd at about 1:30 in the morning when they lined up side by side and maced anyone who dared get in their way. Why they didn't do that 2 hours sooner is beyond me.
In other news, there's an NFL game tonight. For the rest of the season it's Thursday night football, so here's my pick:
Oakland @ San Diego-San Diego has a lot more riding on this game than Oakland does. Darren McFadden is still hurt, and Michael Bush is not quite the best replacement. I see the Chargers going arial on a depleted Oakland secondary and winning this one by at least two scores. San Diego 28 Oakland 10
The real sickening part of this story is to hear students say they were part of the riot because they "didn't want to miss it." They sound like Maryland students, rioting for no good reason other than to say you were part of a riot. For the ones who were there because they were just venting their frustration over their beloved coach, how do they think anyone will take any of you seriously by attacking police? The only thing that will take them seriously is that cloud of mace that's entering their eyes. Police finally was able to disperse the crowd at about 1:30 in the morning when they lined up side by side and maced anyone who dared get in their way. Why they didn't do that 2 hours sooner is beyond me.
In other news, there's an NFL game tonight. For the rest of the season it's Thursday night football, so here's my pick:
Oakland @ San Diego-San Diego has a lot more riding on this game than Oakland does. Darren McFadden is still hurt, and Michael Bush is not quite the best replacement. I see the Chargers going arial on a depleted Oakland secondary and winning this one by at least two scores. San Diego 28 Oakland 10
Some Thoughts on Penn State
I have been closely paying attention to this story coming out of State College, PA regarding former Penn State defensive coordinator Jerry Sandusky and an alleged sex abuse scandal stemming from 2002. Yesterday was a whirlwind 24 hours for Nittany Lions faithful. It started with a love/hate relationship for and against head football coach Joe Paterno (the same Joe Pa who has been there for the last 46 years). Paterno was never a target of the criminal investigation because he "fulfilled his legal obligation" by reporting to his superior, president Graham Spanier. A graduate assistant informed Paterno that he had alledgedly observed improper acts in a locker room by Sandusky towards a child. Paterno claimed that the graduate assistant (now identified to be current wide receivers coach Mike McQueary) was "distraught" and failed to provide specifics about what he saw. However, no authorities were notified. Yesterday morning, we find out that Paterno decided to retire at the end of the season, which still has 4 games left and potentially more. Paterno decided to retire so that the Penn State Board of Trustees would not have to worry about his status as they decided what to do going forward. However, the Board ignored Paterno's preemptive strike. Last night at around 10PM, after informing Paterno via phone call, the Board announced that both Paterno and Spanier were relieved of their duties "in the best interests of the university as a whole."
Even before the announcement, there was a very sharp divide on how Paterno should be viewed in all of this. Many felt that the best thing to happen was for Paterno to retire as he said he would. It would look really bad for him and the university if they did nothing and Paterno would be allowed to continue as head coach (in spite of calls for him to retire based on age alone, he is 84). Therefore, with Paterno retiring, the university would save face as it were. Students flocked toward his home to show their support, and he even came out and addressed them during the night. Paternoville was full of tents as usual in advance of this Saturday's home finale and Senior Day. It seemed as if Paterno would be able to go out the way he wanted to, albeit under somewhat dubious circumstances. However, he would later find out that this would not be the case, and the venom coming from the students is nasty (they're trying to make the University of Maryland look good apparently).
Here's the bottom line. Here we are talking about the legacy of Joe Paterno and a football program...yet again. For the last couple of years, the culprits have been improper benefits and academic issues at big schools. However, Penn State has been mostly isolated from these things, and Paterno had been revered for always running a squeaky clean program. Unfortunately, we are all missing the big issue here. Children have been affected. This happened 10 years ago and they are now all adults, but who knows how many lives were alledgedly ruined because of Jerry Sandusky? I know it's all allegations at this point and innocent until proven guilty, but right now at least the circumstantial evidence right now is very damning. ***
***Lest we forget, the Duke lacrosse sex scandal. Now, as far as we know, there are no politicians with axes to grind in State College like there was at Duke with Mike Nifong. As heinous as the allegations are (and they are pretty heinous), Jerry Sandusky is afforded the right of due process in a court of law. He can be smeared in the court of public opinion, and with 40 counts coming from the Grand Jury, there is definitely more than enough evidence to put him away for good, but like those lacrosse players, he will get his day in court***
Back to my original point, we are once again talking about the legacy of a coach and a football program, when we really should be talking about the victims and how their lives have been destroyed because of the whims of a madman. For pretty much the entire time I have run this blog, since January, I have argued that college athletics, although an important part of the higher education system, should not be given a higher level of importance over academics and education. After all, this is (and ought to be) the primary goal of any college institution. Penn State may have been squeaky clean for 46 years under Paterno (we think...). However, as they say, the higher they go, the harder they fall. The Board of Trustees doesn't need to give Joe Paterno or Graham Spanier any due process. They have to act on behalf of the best interests of the Pennsylvania State University. They know that as long as Joe Paterno is the head coach, even if it is only for 4 more games, the only press the University would be getting would be about this scandal and how no action is being taken, just like no action was taken in 2002. Their primary objective has to be to enhance the university as an educational institution. In the best interests of the university, an academic institution, the course of action for them was to make a very tough decision and fire the legendary football coach whose name still graces the university library. I applaud the Board for making a very difficult decision, but I have to say that it is the right one, in addition to canning Spanier.
History will look at Penn State football and Penn State University with pride. 409 wins, 2 national championships, 37 bowl apperances, and 24 bowl wins without the slightest hint of impropriety will earn you several well-deserved plaudits. However, in light of recent events, fairly or unfairly, the pride of Penn State football will always be looked at with an asterisk. What was going on in those locker rooms that we did not know about? How could anybody be informed of any sense of impropriety and not make the responsible decision to inform authorities, no matter how "vague" the information was? I know that it's easy for me to say because I was not there, but Joe Paterno has always had that reputation of putting kids first. The children affected by this scandal had their entire lives in front of them, and they were not put first. They have to be first and foremost on everyone's mind. Just like the Board had to make a tough decision they felt was in the best interest of their university, so did Paterno. Paterno (and Penn State in general) is now suffering the consequences of his decision.
I have to say that I do applaud Paterno for coming forward and saying that even though his legal obligation was fufilled, he wishes he could have done more for the victims affected. I am in no way saying that Paterno should be completely disassociated with Penn State. He should still be held in high regard, as long as he really dedicates himself now for advocating for the victims, and for the victims of any similar crimes.
Jess over at Just Call me Janks (a proud Penn State alum) provides another perspective on this issue. She argues in favor of letting Paterno stay the rest of the season, taking into consideration his entire body of work (referencing the library).
Even before the announcement, there was a very sharp divide on how Paterno should be viewed in all of this. Many felt that the best thing to happen was for Paterno to retire as he said he would. It would look really bad for him and the university if they did nothing and Paterno would be allowed to continue as head coach (in spite of calls for him to retire based on age alone, he is 84). Therefore, with Paterno retiring, the university would save face as it were. Students flocked toward his home to show their support, and he even came out and addressed them during the night. Paternoville was full of tents as usual in advance of this Saturday's home finale and Senior Day. It seemed as if Paterno would be able to go out the way he wanted to, albeit under somewhat dubious circumstances. However, he would later find out that this would not be the case, and the venom coming from the students is nasty (they're trying to make the University of Maryland look good apparently).
![]() |
| Joe Paterno |
***Lest we forget, the Duke lacrosse sex scandal. Now, as far as we know, there are no politicians with axes to grind in State College like there was at Duke with Mike Nifong. As heinous as the allegations are (and they are pretty heinous), Jerry Sandusky is afforded the right of due process in a court of law. He can be smeared in the court of public opinion, and with 40 counts coming from the Grand Jury, there is definitely more than enough evidence to put him away for good, but like those lacrosse players, he will get his day in court***
Back to my original point, we are once again talking about the legacy of a coach and a football program, when we really should be talking about the victims and how their lives have been destroyed because of the whims of a madman. For pretty much the entire time I have run this blog, since January, I have argued that college athletics, although an important part of the higher education system, should not be given a higher level of importance over academics and education. After all, this is (and ought to be) the primary goal of any college institution. Penn State may have been squeaky clean for 46 years under Paterno (we think...). However, as they say, the higher they go, the harder they fall. The Board of Trustees doesn't need to give Joe Paterno or Graham Spanier any due process. They have to act on behalf of the best interests of the Pennsylvania State University. They know that as long as Joe Paterno is the head coach, even if it is only for 4 more games, the only press the University would be getting would be about this scandal and how no action is being taken, just like no action was taken in 2002. Their primary objective has to be to enhance the university as an educational institution. In the best interests of the university, an academic institution, the course of action for them was to make a very tough decision and fire the legendary football coach whose name still graces the university library. I applaud the Board for making a very difficult decision, but I have to say that it is the right one, in addition to canning Spanier.
History will look at Penn State football and Penn State University with pride. 409 wins, 2 national championships, 37 bowl apperances, and 24 bowl wins without the slightest hint of impropriety will earn you several well-deserved plaudits. However, in light of recent events, fairly or unfairly, the pride of Penn State football will always be looked at with an asterisk. What was going on in those locker rooms that we did not know about? How could anybody be informed of any sense of impropriety and not make the responsible decision to inform authorities, no matter how "vague" the information was? I know that it's easy for me to say because I was not there, but Joe Paterno has always had that reputation of putting kids first. The children affected by this scandal had their entire lives in front of them, and they were not put first. They have to be first and foremost on everyone's mind. Just like the Board had to make a tough decision they felt was in the best interest of their university, so did Paterno. Paterno (and Penn State in general) is now suffering the consequences of his decision.
I have to say that I do applaud Paterno for coming forward and saying that even though his legal obligation was fufilled, he wishes he could have done more for the victims affected. I am in no way saying that Paterno should be completely disassociated with Penn State. He should still be held in high regard, as long as he really dedicates himself now for advocating for the victims, and for the victims of any similar crimes.
Jess over at Just Call me Janks (a proud Penn State alum) provides another perspective on this issue. She argues in favor of letting Paterno stay the rest of the season, taking into consideration his entire body of work (referencing the library).
Tuesday, September 20, 2011
More Realignment in College Football?
Earlier in the summer, the big news concerned Texas A&M and a potential move to the SEC. A&M eventually denied a move was in the works, but did not rule out the possibility of one in the future. This week, we learn that Syracuse and Pitt will be admitted into the ACC, the date of which is yet to be determined. We may not be done, though. Now UConn and Rutgers are on the ACC wish list. When is this madness going to stop? Nobody would have imagined the ACC being the first team to get to the 16 team football "superconference." I would like to emphasize the word "football" in that last line. What's the first thing you think of when you hear ACC? Duke and North Carolina, right? Yeah, me too. Now, adding Syracuse and Pitt certainly contributes to an already strong basketball profile, but let's be real, this was purely a football driven move. Lest we forget, it was the ACC that initiated this decade of constant realignment starting in 2004 with the additions of Miami and Virginia Tech (and eventually Boston College). If UConn and Pitt end up joining the ACC, and West Virginia joins the SEC with A&M (as has been reported is under consideration), the Big East is finished, which is a shame because the Big East (next to the ACC in my opinion) is the best basketball conference in the country.
What is the motivation in all of this realignment? The easy answer is dollars associated with big time football and championship games. The era of the BCS (and the lack of a playoff in Division I-A) has forced football factory schools to constantly reposition themselves in conferences that will give them A) the most possible exposure and B) more of a chance to win enough games through scheduling to reach BCS bowls and potentially a national championship. College presidents love the BCS bowl system because it rakes in the dough. Now, somebody try to explain to me why a 4 or even 8 team Division I-A tournament would not achieve the same money-making goals. In any event, at the very heart of this realingment is unfortunately money.
One of my favorite columnists is Gregg Easterbrook, AKA the Tuesday Morning Quarterback. I love reading his column on Tuesdays (duh). He provides insightful commentary into not only football, but a variety of other subjects that interest me, specifically science and astronomy. I don't necessarily agree with him on politics, but that's another issue entirely. Why do I mention this? TMQ for years has railed against the notion that so-called football factory schools A) do not use the money from football for purely educational purposes or B) exploit the players as essentially "wards of the state:" making money for the schools yet not seeing any of the benefits themselves lest the school feel the wrath of the NCAA. Now, as an educator, I am firmly against paying student athletes anything more than the quarter of a million dollar scholarship they already receive. However, I understand the hypocrisy in what is going on. Colleges' first (and really only) priority should be in the education and future of all of their students. Athletics play an important role, and I love college football as much as the next guy, but more and more and more we are seeing the degradation of college football into nothing more than a minor league of the NFL. This is the biggest shame of all.
College football makes money. Everybody knows that. However, if schools (especially the football factory ones) place as much of an emphasis on the education of their student athletes as they do winning football championships, what you will see are healthier young men and women better prepared for a society beyond the field or the court. During the NCAA Tournament in March, the NCAA runs ads emphasizing that their student athletes mostly go pro in things other than sports. While that may be true, nobody really cares about field hockey or water polo (apologies to all the field hockey and water polo players who may be reading this blog). The emphasis is on football and basketball. These are the big money makers, and unfortunately, the two sports with the worst graduation rates. Players in these sports place more of an emphasis on becoming pro athletes than they do on graduating, and coaches don't help. TMQ proposed an excellent (although I must admit far-fetched) idea on how to rectify this. As part of the BCS formula, add in an element counting either GPA or graduation rates. That would force coaches to make sure their players not only go to class, but stay there and study hard. Coaches need to emphasize to players that there is life beyond football. Millions of dollars can be earned and lost in a very short period of time.
Stay in school
What is the motivation in all of this realignment? The easy answer is dollars associated with big time football and championship games. The era of the BCS (and the lack of a playoff in Division I-A) has forced football factory schools to constantly reposition themselves in conferences that will give them A) the most possible exposure and B) more of a chance to win enough games through scheduling to reach BCS bowls and potentially a national championship. College presidents love the BCS bowl system because it rakes in the dough. Now, somebody try to explain to me why a 4 or even 8 team Division I-A tournament would not achieve the same money-making goals. In any event, at the very heart of this realingment is unfortunately money.
One of my favorite columnists is Gregg Easterbrook, AKA the Tuesday Morning Quarterback. I love reading his column on Tuesdays (duh). He provides insightful commentary into not only football, but a variety of other subjects that interest me, specifically science and astronomy. I don't necessarily agree with him on politics, but that's another issue entirely. Why do I mention this? TMQ for years has railed against the notion that so-called football factory schools A) do not use the money from football for purely educational purposes or B) exploit the players as essentially "wards of the state:" making money for the schools yet not seeing any of the benefits themselves lest the school feel the wrath of the NCAA. Now, as an educator, I am firmly against paying student athletes anything more than the quarter of a million dollar scholarship they already receive. However, I understand the hypocrisy in what is going on. Colleges' first (and really only) priority should be in the education and future of all of their students. Athletics play an important role, and I love college football as much as the next guy, but more and more and more we are seeing the degradation of college football into nothing more than a minor league of the NFL. This is the biggest shame of all.
College football makes money. Everybody knows that. However, if schools (especially the football factory ones) place as much of an emphasis on the education of their student athletes as they do winning football championships, what you will see are healthier young men and women better prepared for a society beyond the field or the court. During the NCAA Tournament in March, the NCAA runs ads emphasizing that their student athletes mostly go pro in things other than sports. While that may be true, nobody really cares about field hockey or water polo (apologies to all the field hockey and water polo players who may be reading this blog). The emphasis is on football and basketball. These are the big money makers, and unfortunately, the two sports with the worst graduation rates. Players in these sports place more of an emphasis on becoming pro athletes than they do on graduating, and coaches don't help. TMQ proposed an excellent (although I must admit far-fetched) idea on how to rectify this. As part of the BCS formula, add in an element counting either GPA or graduation rates. That would force coaches to make sure their players not only go to class, but stay there and study hard. Coaches need to emphasize to players that there is life beyond football. Millions of dollars can be earned and lost in a very short period of time.
Stay in school
Friday, September 16, 2011
The Death of Defense
There is a very interesting piece on ESPN this morning from Michael Wilbon of PTI fame. He discusses the radical shift in football offensive philosophy from a run-oriented game to the pass-wacky game of the present day and how defenses have had to cope with it. New rules designed to protect the quarterbacks have given the field generals more freedom than ever to dictate the flow of a game. Case in point: Tom Brady throws for 517 yards in Week 1, 3 quarterbacks throw for over 400 yards, and 14 quarterbacks throw for over 300 yards. At over 7,800 yards, more yards were gained passing in week 1 than ever before. As a result, defenses are left dazed and confused, without really anything they can do about it.
Why is this happening? In discussions with Darren Woodson and Herm Edwards, Wilbon argues that new research into concussions and head injuries have made the game softer than it 20th century counterpart. Throw on top of that rules such as the 5-yard chuck rule on receivers, as well as rules protecting defenseless receivers, the NFL is a league ripe for huge amounts of yards to be gained and points to be scored. Defenses are not allowed to hit hard anymore, and the days of big-hitting defenses are, in fact, over. Quarterback is the most important (and highest paid) position on the field. Teams just cannot afford big time quarterbacks to get injured. Look at Indianapolis today without Peyton Manning. New England had to go a season without Tom Brady and missed the playoffs (granted, they were still 11-5 that year). Bill Parcells has declared the end of the era of the strong safety. Running offenses allow 11 guys to possibly tackle the ball carrier, whereas passing offenses make a ball carrier worry about only 3 or 4. You are seeing a domino effect as well in lower levels (college and high school). Even schools like Notre Dame, Alabama, and Penn State have dramatically shifted from option and run-oriented offenses to more shotgun spread, 4-wide receiver sets.
Do I think that the defense has died in football? No I don't. However, it is licking its wounds as it were. Like all sports, there are certain periods of time that favor offense, and certain periods of time that favor defense. Think about in baseball, you have the dead ball era and the live ball era (and the steroid era...). In football, we have entered the era of spread formations and the over-protection of the quarterback, and offenses are taking advantage. However, coaches in football are smart. They will learn to adjust. Wilbon makes an excellent point in saying that the way to stop premier quarterbacks like Manning is to let them get inside the 20, and exploit the shrunken field. These teams make their hay on spreading the field out, and big fields are exactly what they want to see. Shrink the field, and that takes a very key weapon away. Unfortunately, the days of true big-hitting defenses are in fact over, as I don't see the league relaxing on the rules any time soon (and rightfully so). This just means that teams are going to have to get smarter on defense, and I feel like they will. Instead of the mantra of "kill the quarterback," the mantra will become "take the ball away" or "get to the spot before he does" or something like that. Football is a game built on speed moreso than power in the 21st century, and you're already starting to see that with guys like Revis and Reed patrolling the secondary. Defense will be fine, and so will quarterbacks. So they will enjoy their 500 yard passing games now, but eventually everyone will come back down to Earth...or just back to under center.
Why is this happening? In discussions with Darren Woodson and Herm Edwards, Wilbon argues that new research into concussions and head injuries have made the game softer than it 20th century counterpart. Throw on top of that rules such as the 5-yard chuck rule on receivers, as well as rules protecting defenseless receivers, the NFL is a league ripe for huge amounts of yards to be gained and points to be scored. Defenses are not allowed to hit hard anymore, and the days of big-hitting defenses are, in fact, over. Quarterback is the most important (and highest paid) position on the field. Teams just cannot afford big time quarterbacks to get injured. Look at Indianapolis today without Peyton Manning. New England had to go a season without Tom Brady and missed the playoffs (granted, they were still 11-5 that year). Bill Parcells has declared the end of the era of the strong safety. Running offenses allow 11 guys to possibly tackle the ball carrier, whereas passing offenses make a ball carrier worry about only 3 or 4. You are seeing a domino effect as well in lower levels (college and high school). Even schools like Notre Dame, Alabama, and Penn State have dramatically shifted from option and run-oriented offenses to more shotgun spread, 4-wide receiver sets.
Do I think that the defense has died in football? No I don't. However, it is licking its wounds as it were. Like all sports, there are certain periods of time that favor offense, and certain periods of time that favor defense. Think about in baseball, you have the dead ball era and the live ball era (and the steroid era...). In football, we have entered the era of spread formations and the over-protection of the quarterback, and offenses are taking advantage. However, coaches in football are smart. They will learn to adjust. Wilbon makes an excellent point in saying that the way to stop premier quarterbacks like Manning is to let them get inside the 20, and exploit the shrunken field. These teams make their hay on spreading the field out, and big fields are exactly what they want to see. Shrink the field, and that takes a very key weapon away. Unfortunately, the days of true big-hitting defenses are in fact over, as I don't see the league relaxing on the rules any time soon (and rightfully so). This just means that teams are going to have to get smarter on defense, and I feel like they will. Instead of the mantra of "kill the quarterback," the mantra will become "take the ball away" or "get to the spot before he does" or something like that. Football is a game built on speed moreso than power in the 21st century, and you're already starting to see that with guys like Revis and Reed patrolling the secondary. Defense will be fine, and so will quarterbacks. So they will enjoy their 500 yard passing games now, but eventually everyone will come back down to Earth...or just back to under center.
Wednesday, August 17, 2011
Scandals in College Football
There has been lots of news recently regarding scandals and improper behavior both at Ohio State and the University of Miami. The issue at Ohio State regards the status of former quarterback Terrell Pryor in regards to the NFL Supplemental Draft, which had originally be scheduled for today, but has been postponed. The postponement is most likely due to the NFL needing more time to consider Pryor's status. He declared himself ineligbile to play college football in June, well after the regular NFL Draft in April. According to NFL rules, a player is eligible for the supplemental draft if his collegiate eligibility changes between the regular draft and the time of the supplemental draft. A variety of reasons can allow a player to become eligible for the supplemental draft such as conduct and academics. However, there is debate as to whether or not Pryor's status actually changed.
This who scenario stems from a scandal at Ohio State which forced not only Pryor but former head coach Jim Tressel to resign becuase of players receiving improper benefits from boosters, and Tressel knowing about it. Originially, Pryor and seven other players were forced to sign a document promising that they would return for their senior seasons and serve a 5-game suspension at the start of the season. This was in return for being able to play in the Sugar Bowl on January 4th. This all occured before the January 15th deadline for underclassmen to declare themselves eligible for the NFL Draft. The argument against Pryor is that his status did not change, but rather he has been ineligible since he was suspended. Therefore, since there was not status change, Pryor declaring himself ineligible in June is meaningless.
Ultimately, I feel like Pryor will be allowed to enter the supplemental draft, but I feel like he would be better off just waiting until April. If he is drafted now in the supplemental draft, the best he probably would be able to do is a team spending a 6th or 7th round pick on him. This is becuase he will have had virtually no chances (mostly because of the lockout) to impress teams. He had scheduled a pro day for last Friday, with several teams planning on attending, but since there was no guarantee that he would be able to get into the supplemental draft, he cancelled that pro day. This means that even if he does get a chance to work out in front of teams, he will have had a grand total of one chance to impress somebody. If a team decides to take a chance on him, like I said, it would not be with anything higher than a late round pick. If he decides to wait until April, yes he will miss out on a year of salary, but the payoff will be much better in my opinion. He will have had an entire offseason to work out and impress coaches. He will (most likely) attend the scouting combine and maybe even impress somebody enough to get up into the first half of the draft. This rush to get drafted might send him the way of Mike Williams, who skipped school after his sophomore season at USC following Maurice Clarett (great role model...) into the NFL. Williams is still in the league, but he's nothing more than a journeyman. Pryor has a chance, especially at the quarterback position, to do some great things in pro football. Wait until April.
The other big news in college football today comes from the University of Miami, no stranger to the NCAA doghouse. This latest issue deals with allegations from former booster Nevin Shapiro, who claims to have given improper benefits (including cash, trips, cars, VIP access to clubs, prostitutes, bounties, and even time on Shapiro's private yacht) to over 70 Miami football and basketball players during the last decade. This includes several current NFL players who went to the U. Now, Shapiro is currently serving 20 years in federal-pound-me-in-the-[expletive deleted] prison (ever seen Office Space?) for running a nearly $1 billion ponzi scheme. I wonder where some of that $1 billion went... In any event, Shapiro is naming names and the big debate right now is (assuming the allegations to be true) whether or not Miami will get the so-called "death penalty."
For those of you who might not be totally familar with the NCAA "death penalty" concept, it has only been enforced one time in history: 1986 for SMU football. It involves taking away the right of a school to play a certain sport. In the 1980s, SMU was a football powerhouse, but for pretty much the entire decade of the 1980s, including after being banned from bowls and numerous probations, the NCAA cancelled their 1987 season after it had been revealed that several players had received improper benefits, including cash simply for signing a letter of intent with the school. The repeated violations forced the NCAA to strip the university of football for that season, and SMU has never been the same since. Several schools have come close to receiving the death penalty for numerous violations (including USC, Alabama, and even Maryland basketball in 1989), but SMU was the only confirmed instance when the death penalty was invoked.
Will Miami actually receive the death penalty for these allegations? Hard to say. It would be easier to say no if there were no current players implicated. Unfortunately for the U, current quarterback Jacory Harris and other players have been implicated in the scandal (and one of the names dropped by Shapiro). Since current players are involved, and since Miami is a repeat offender, the death penalty cannot be ruled out, especially considering the seriousness of the allegations. Now, at the same time, the individual making the accusations is a convicted felon serving hard time. How trustworthy is he? However, what does he have to lose? What incentive does he have to lie? Shapiro claims to have all kinds of evidence backing up his claims. All of this needs to be investigated thoroughly.
All of this nonsense ultimately comes back to one very important question the answer to which we should know, but really do not. What is the value of a college education. These athletes going to school are receiving over a quarter of a million dollars worth of free education over a 4-year period. There are kids who work their entire lives to pay off loans so that they can get the same education these kids are getting for absolutely free. Where is the equity? Now, we can talk about paying players all we want (that's another issue entirely), but the bottom line is that the kids who are receiving these athletic scholarships in the big money sports (football and basketball) are in essence abusing what they have been given. Are the players entirely at fault? They're not, bums like Nevin Shapiro and Ed Martin (from the fab 5 days at Michigan) are so bent out of shape to see "their team" win a national championship that they are not ashame of bending and breaking rules to make sure "their team" gets premier prep talent. A national championhip in football is more important than an education that will be valuable for the rest of a person's life. That's what this has come to, and it's a travesty. As a teacher, I am a bit more sensitive to these kinds of issues than others might be, and don't get me wrong, I love college and pro football and I want to see my team win. However, I understand that the vast majority of collegiate athletes on scholarship are aware that the eduation they are getting is really priceless, and I just wish that these so-called boosters would remind the players of that instead of giving them trips on a yacht.
I'll be back later with the conclusion of our latest countdown featuring the top 10 running backs in NFL history.
![]() |
| Pryor and Tressel (from thesportsbank.net) |
Ultimately, I feel like Pryor will be allowed to enter the supplemental draft, but I feel like he would be better off just waiting until April. If he is drafted now in the supplemental draft, the best he probably would be able to do is a team spending a 6th or 7th round pick on him. This is becuase he will have had virtually no chances (mostly because of the lockout) to impress teams. He had scheduled a pro day for last Friday, with several teams planning on attending, but since there was no guarantee that he would be able to get into the supplemental draft, he cancelled that pro day. This means that even if he does get a chance to work out in front of teams, he will have had a grand total of one chance to impress somebody. If a team decides to take a chance on him, like I said, it would not be with anything higher than a late round pick. If he decides to wait until April, yes he will miss out on a year of salary, but the payoff will be much better in my opinion. He will have had an entire offseason to work out and impress coaches. He will (most likely) attend the scouting combine and maybe even impress somebody enough to get up into the first half of the draft. This rush to get drafted might send him the way of Mike Williams, who skipped school after his sophomore season at USC following Maurice Clarett (great role model...) into the NFL. Williams is still in the league, but he's nothing more than a journeyman. Pryor has a chance, especially at the quarterback position, to do some great things in pro football. Wait until April.
The other big news in college football today comes from the University of Miami, no stranger to the NCAA doghouse. This latest issue deals with allegations from former booster Nevin Shapiro, who claims to have given improper benefits (including cash, trips, cars, VIP access to clubs, prostitutes, bounties, and even time on Shapiro's private yacht) to over 70 Miami football and basketball players during the last decade. This includes several current NFL players who went to the U. Now, Shapiro is currently serving 20 years in federal-pound-me-in-the-[expletive deleted] prison (ever seen Office Space?) for running a nearly $1 billion ponzi scheme. I wonder where some of that $1 billion went... In any event, Shapiro is naming names and the big debate right now is (assuming the allegations to be true) whether or not Miami will get the so-called "death penalty."
For those of you who might not be totally familar with the NCAA "death penalty" concept, it has only been enforced one time in history: 1986 for SMU football. It involves taking away the right of a school to play a certain sport. In the 1980s, SMU was a football powerhouse, but for pretty much the entire decade of the 1980s, including after being banned from bowls and numerous probations, the NCAA cancelled their 1987 season after it had been revealed that several players had received improper benefits, including cash simply for signing a letter of intent with the school. The repeated violations forced the NCAA to strip the university of football for that season, and SMU has never been the same since. Several schools have come close to receiving the death penalty for numerous violations (including USC, Alabama, and even Maryland basketball in 1989), but SMU was the only confirmed instance when the death penalty was invoked.
![]() |
| Jacory Harris has been implicated in the latest scandal at the University of Miami (from deadspin.com) |
All of this nonsense ultimately comes back to one very important question the answer to which we should know, but really do not. What is the value of a college education. These athletes going to school are receiving over a quarter of a million dollars worth of free education over a 4-year period. There are kids who work their entire lives to pay off loans so that they can get the same education these kids are getting for absolutely free. Where is the equity? Now, we can talk about paying players all we want (that's another issue entirely), but the bottom line is that the kids who are receiving these athletic scholarships in the big money sports (football and basketball) are in essence abusing what they have been given. Are the players entirely at fault? They're not, bums like Nevin Shapiro and Ed Martin (from the fab 5 days at Michigan) are so bent out of shape to see "their team" win a national championship that they are not ashame of bending and breaking rules to make sure "their team" gets premier prep talent. A national championhip in football is more important than an education that will be valuable for the rest of a person's life. That's what this has come to, and it's a travesty. As a teacher, I am a bit more sensitive to these kinds of issues than others might be, and don't get me wrong, I love college and pro football and I want to see my team win. However, I understand that the vast majority of collegiate athletes on scholarship are aware that the eduation they are getting is really priceless, and I just wish that these so-called boosters would remind the players of that instead of giving them trips on a yacht.
I'll be back later with the conclusion of our latest countdown featuring the top 10 running backs in NFL history.
Sunday, January 23, 2011
Maryland Terps Updates
There has been a lot of activity in College Park lately, and we here at Caputo's Corner have certainly taken notice, but our list of topics to address has been long and extensive. However, we have not forgotten the turtleheads. This first post today is dedicated to the goings on at both Byrd Stadium and Comcast Center. As a football season ticket holder, I have a vested interest in the football team's success. My die-hard interest in the basketball team has admittedly waned a bit in the past few years. I feel like the program does not have as much of an emphasis on academics as it should. Nevertheless, we will be giving just about equal time to the college football and basketball scene today. We'll start with the football team and then take a look at the basketball squad.
Later today, we'll have an instant analysis of the NFC and AFC Championships as well as any updates during the game should the need arise.
Later today, we'll have an instant analysis of the NFC and AFC Championships as well as any updates during the game should the need arise.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)





