A interview is out today by former North Carolina basketball star Rashad McCants who said that while at UNC, and especially during their championship run in 2005, he took sham paper-classes where the papers were written by tutors and rarely (if ever) he actually went to class. According to McCants, his job as a collegian was to simply "show up and play (basketball)."
Accusations of academic misconduct at North Carolina have been brewing for a few months, and this report is just the latest in a series of accusations ranging from fraudulent classes to cheating tutors.
The union boys over at Northwestern might be onto something.
As I've already articulated here at the blog a few months ago, if the concept of amateurism is not already dead, it is on life support with somebody ready to pull the plug. Who would have thought even 5 years ago, let alone 10, 20, or 30, that college athletes would even consider joining a labor union? Who would have even thought that they would be considered "employees" of an academic institution? However, accusations such as these at UNC, if verified to be true, certainly would lend some weight to their arguments.
Now I have said numerous times that I am all for fairness toward athletes, although this does not mean paying them. What really needs to get reformed is the entire culture of college athletics. In an ideal world, college athletics would be more like the Division III model where everyone is a walk-on. Nevertheless, the whole concept of a scholarship is to afford college and all its benefits on students who otherwise would not be able to afford it. College tuition being what it is, athletic scholarship is really the only way several kids nationwide can have a crack at college. However, thanks to the ever flowing money coming from rich booster clubs and alumni who just want to thump their chests about their alma maters' football teams (not to mention all the gambling riches), more and more emphasis has been placed on the athletic success instead of the life success that college is really supposed to be preparing its students.
In this latest UNC scandal, McCants recounted that since coach Roy Williams took the helm in 2003, his "grades" dramatically improved. As a freshman, with coach Matt Doherty, his GPA was in the proverbial tank, thus jeopardizing his NCAA eligibility. However, when this issue was brought to the attention of the new coach, Williams took advantage of some creative course selection and tutorship so that McCants' "grades" skyrocketed to straight A's and a Dean's List in 2005. All the while, McCants saw the inside of a classroom less than half of that semester. What he was doing the rest of the time is anybody's guess, but thanks to the so-called "paper-courses," the only thing necessary for a grade was a single "paper," which according to McCants, was written by the tutors, and let's just say that some of the other papers written by UNC's finest...were not of the finest quality.
All this does is support the wide ranging accusations that players are nothing more than pawns in a grand scheme to raise the school money exploiting their athletic talents. Meanwhile, to call what these players are receiving in return an "education" is insulting, and that is the biggest travesty of all. If these players do not make professional rosters (which if you believe statistics is a better than average chance), their chances of succeeding in the real world is practically zero, and there will be no players union to support them.
How can this be fixed without having to concede that players are employees and a union is their only way of getting the support they need? It really is simple. Make sure that student-athletes are STUDENTS first, and ATHLETES second. The mission of every college in the world is to prepare all of their students for success in the world. Athletic careers are fleeting, with even the best professional players of our generation retiring in their 40s. People need skills to survive, especially in a down economy where employers are looking now more than ever for workers with highly specialized skill sets. For any athlete who receives a college scholarship, constant checks on classroom attendance should be mandatory, as well as (legitimate) mandatory tutoring. Self-directed and "paper-classes" should not be an option, due to the obvious opportunities for fraud. Academic eligibility requirements do not need to be tinkered, they just need to be enforced, and coaches need to be educated on them more than they already are. To wit, coaches' performances should not just be measured by on-field and on-court success, but by classroom success as well. If the 6-year graduation rates for an athletic program fall below certain thresholds, coaches can be at risk for loss of salary or even termination. Does that sound extreme? Perhaps, but you have to remember the goal here is ultimately going to be life success, and that goes way beyond sports. College coaches are not professional coaches. They coach kids, and they are teachers just as much as they are coaches, and if their students are not ready for what awaits them after their eligibility expires, then they have not done their jobs.
For those that say that the money is the problem, they have a point. Now I am not going to say that Division I has to become Division III, not by any stretch. Division I schools and athletic departments do have an obligation to support their athletes as they are ambassadors for the school in addition to students. I am all for supporting the full cost of attendance (honestly...I thought scholarships already did that. I was wrong). However, that should be ALL the support they need. Since most of these Power 5 schools are just dripping with cash as it is, there is going to be a surplus. Colleges are not-for-profit enterprises. How much of that money gets spent on new science department equipment? Or the arts? These are other ways that schools can support the full cost of attendance, by exposing athletes to other areas of expertise beyond their athletic talents. Let them know that there are other careers available to them that they will (at some point) need to explore. Not everyone can just fit into an ESPN analyst chair when they retire. Thus, some revenue sharing between fat athletic departments and the rest of the school is an excellent idea. This would also allow some of the smaller schools who do not have quite as rich an athletic budget to at least maintain a somewhat more level playing field.
I'm not saying that coaches like Nick Saban (who I like to pick on here granted) need a pay cut either. However, with great wealth comes great responsibility. Yes, he wins football games, but are his players ready for life as well as the game? I don't care how many national titles you win, if your players are not prepared for what will come after their eligibility has expired, you have not done your job.
Message to presidents, ADs, coaches, and administrators all across the NCAA fruited plain. Do your job. Do right by this kids. Make sure they are STUDENTS first, and take your TEACHER responsibilities seriously. If you do that, you will never have to hear about the College Athletic Players Association ever again.
Showing posts with label education. Show all posts
Showing posts with label education. Show all posts
Friday, June 6, 2014
Tuesday, May 27, 2014
Get Yer' Shots!
An issue I discussed a few posts ago dealt with the concept of "settled science." Thanks to ever improving experimental techniques, and more and more data from a variety of sources, it is very hard to call any science settled. However, tonight I would like to discuss another topic that has been in the news a lot lately (although not as much as the first issue), which is a lot closer to "settled science" than anything in the first issue.
Certain people in the pop culture world (aka NOT scientists) are trying to push the idea that vaccines are merely power plays by "Big Pharmaceutical" to steal your money. Oh yeah, and they give your kids autism. Probably the most vocal pretty person who has been on that bandwagon lately is Jenny McCarthy (who is NOT a scientist...and apparently not anti-vaccine either...yeah right). As a result of this scare campaign, several parents are refusing to give their kids their vaccine regime at an early age. This is allowing diseases that had previously been on a major decline (such as measles and chicken pox) or nearly eradicated (such as polio) to start making comebacks which could lead to major health emergencies. Most of these diseases are starting to return to the USA due to unvaccinated individuals going overseas to countries where the disease has not been controlled, contracting the illness, and returning it home, potentially spreading it to other unprotected individuals.
The push to possibly do away with vaccines is another case study in bad science with a capital BS, and an excellent cautionary tale of what can happen when you jump to conclusions based on faulty information without doing your homework. May I remind you that there is no causal link between vaccines and autism! The efficacy of vaccines in eliminating potentially fatal diseases has never been questioned for hundreds of years. Let me give you a brief history of one such disease that vaccines have saved us from: smallpox.
Edward Jenner (yes I linked the Wikipedia page...it's accurate as of this posting) is considered the father of the modern vaccine. He lived in a day and age when infectious diseases such as smallpox were the top killers in the world. He discovered, however, that milkmaids that had contracted a non-fatal relative of smallpox (cowpox) had amazingly come into contact with smallpox victims, yet never actually got sick. This got Jenner to thinking that perhaps the virus that causes cowpox, upon successful recovery, allows the body to become immune from similar diseases such as smallpox. Both diseases had similar outward symptoms: high fever, itchy rash, chills, etc. Yet, the milkmaids who had cowpox always got better, and did not get sick again. So, in 1796, Jenner conducted what at the time was one of the riskiest biological experiments ever. He intentionally injected an 8-year old boy with a serum containing cowpox virus. As you might expect, the boy got sick, and then he recovered. Upon recovery, he intentionally injected a serum containing the lethal smallpox virus into that same boy. Even after repeated exposures, the boy never once showed symptoms of the disease that had killed millions of people before him. He was officially immune. Fast forward nearly 200 years later, in 1980, thanks to a worldwide vaccination effort, and smallpox was officially declared eradicated by the World Health Organization. It was impossible to contract smallpox anywhere in the world.
Vaccines and other medications to cure bacterial infections (see Jonas Salk and Sir Alexander Fleming) have allowed humans to extend their lives more than ever possible back in the 18th and 19th Centuries and prior. Unfortunately, there are some individuals who have taken it upon themselves to challenge this institution, putting several lives at risk, especially in the developing world where the WHO does continue to sponsor major vaccination drives to get people inoculated. There are some people who sadly, truly, are unable to receive the vaccine. The most common reason is an allergy (egg mostly, which is used to culture the virus to prepare it for the vaccine), and receiving the vaccine could cause anaphylaxis. These people are protected through the "herd immunity" concept which is really quite simple. If everyone else is vaccinated against the disease, they cannot catch the disease and give it to somebody who is not protected. However, if fewer people are receiving vaccines, the number of people in the herd goes down, and the community protection is weakened.
The evidence is there, hundreds of years of it. Attempts to prove a causal link between vaccines and other disorders and syndromes have thus far failed to produce anything. Is this to say that vaccine research is finished (i.e. "settled science")? Absolutely not. Any time a potential problem is revealed, work should be done to explore potential causality. Until diseases are eradicated like smallpox, there are always ways to improve vaccines. However, there is absolutely nothing to suggest that vaccines cause anything other than better health for anyone receiving one, and for people surrounding them. The rewards of vaccination tremendously far outweigh the risk of not getting them, and these rewards have been seen since 1796. Perhaps further research can be done into how allergic people can receive the vaccines without having to solely rely on herd immunity and become personally protected. Nevertheless, comparing where humanity was when Edward Jenner infected a small boy with cow pus, and where we are now, I think it is safe to say that we are so much healthier and happier.
Certain people in the pop culture world (aka NOT scientists) are trying to push the idea that vaccines are merely power plays by "Big Pharmaceutical" to steal your money. Oh yeah, and they give your kids autism. Probably the most vocal pretty person who has been on that bandwagon lately is Jenny McCarthy (who is NOT a scientist...and apparently not anti-vaccine either...yeah right). As a result of this scare campaign, several parents are refusing to give their kids their vaccine regime at an early age. This is allowing diseases that had previously been on a major decline (such as measles and chicken pox) or nearly eradicated (such as polio) to start making comebacks which could lead to major health emergencies. Most of these diseases are starting to return to the USA due to unvaccinated individuals going overseas to countries where the disease has not been controlled, contracting the illness, and returning it home, potentially spreading it to other unprotected individuals.
The push to possibly do away with vaccines is another case study in bad science with a capital BS, and an excellent cautionary tale of what can happen when you jump to conclusions based on faulty information without doing your homework. May I remind you that there is no causal link between vaccines and autism! The efficacy of vaccines in eliminating potentially fatal diseases has never been questioned for hundreds of years. Let me give you a brief history of one such disease that vaccines have saved us from: smallpox.
![]() |
| Could Old Bessie have saved humanity from one of it's biggest killers? |
Vaccines and other medications to cure bacterial infections (see Jonas Salk and Sir Alexander Fleming) have allowed humans to extend their lives more than ever possible back in the 18th and 19th Centuries and prior. Unfortunately, there are some individuals who have taken it upon themselves to challenge this institution, putting several lives at risk, especially in the developing world where the WHO does continue to sponsor major vaccination drives to get people inoculated. There are some people who sadly, truly, are unable to receive the vaccine. The most common reason is an allergy (egg mostly, which is used to culture the virus to prepare it for the vaccine), and receiving the vaccine could cause anaphylaxis. These people are protected through the "herd immunity" concept which is really quite simple. If everyone else is vaccinated against the disease, they cannot catch the disease and give it to somebody who is not protected. However, if fewer people are receiving vaccines, the number of people in the herd goes down, and the community protection is weakened.
The evidence is there, hundreds of years of it. Attempts to prove a causal link between vaccines and other disorders and syndromes have thus far failed to produce anything. Is this to say that vaccine research is finished (i.e. "settled science")? Absolutely not. Any time a potential problem is revealed, work should be done to explore potential causality. Until diseases are eradicated like smallpox, there are always ways to improve vaccines. However, there is absolutely nothing to suggest that vaccines cause anything other than better health for anyone receiving one, and for people surrounding them. The rewards of vaccination tremendously far outweigh the risk of not getting them, and these rewards have been seen since 1796. Perhaps further research can be done into how allergic people can receive the vaccines without having to solely rely on herd immunity and become personally protected. Nevertheless, comparing where humanity was when Edward Jenner infected a small boy with cow pus, and where we are now, I think it is safe to say that we are so much healthier and happier.
Wednesday, May 21, 2014
On Grammar...and Twitter
Even science guys know grammar...or do they?
Honestly, that guy I had for Biochemistry I had the absolute worst handwriting ever...but in any event....
Recently, I've been having some "discussions" with my students on the importance of having good grammar, syntax, and overall usage of the English language in both their spoken and written word. Naturally their reaction is something along the lines of "You're a science teacher though!" True, my first inclinations were always with numbers and calculators, but as you hopefully are noticing with my blog posts, I can construct a complete thought! In addition, I have been noticing some mild grievances being aired on social media as well.
You may or may not agree with it, but I don't think anyone can argue that my thoughts are complete.
Why is that? We are up against what I call the "Twitterazi:" the mortal enemy of good grammar, and yes, I did just make up that word. It should not be too hard to tell that it is a portmanteau of "Twitter" and "Paparazzi," and I believe that this evolution is just the latest step in a progression that has been ongoing since the advent of news media.
Think about it. The ultimate sign of success for a news outlet is getting the "scoop," being the first one to report on a big story. If you get to the story first, then everyone else is citing YOU as a source instead of the other way around. Historically, print media was king. If it didn't make the New York Times, then it wasn't worth your time. Then, radio and television supplanted print media. If Walter Cronkite didn't report on it, then it wasn't worth your time either. Broadcast media eventually gave way to cable news. At first it was just CNN, but then MSNBC and Fox News got into the business. This was right around the time the Internet and World Wide Web was starting to become a viable outlet for news.
Then came social media, and that wonderful tool that is Twitter. Now, as most of you know, I am not on Twitter, but have a relatively strong presence on Facebook (which is probably how most of you accessed this page). While I have certainly toyed with the idea of starting a Twitter handle, I have always decided against it. My reasoning is two-fold. First, one social media account is more than enough for me. Second, if I were to start a Twitter, I probably would just be followed by the same people with whom I am already friends on Facebook, so it would be redundant. Nevertheless, anybody who is anybody in the pop culture world is on Twitter, and that's where most of the news-consuming public goes for their big scoops.
It does have its advantages. It is fast, it is to the point. However, that 140-character limit can be a bit of a drag. If a big story is about to break, it is a race among the news outlets to get their 140-character scoop out there first. Long-form articles can wait, once it's on Twitter, then the whole world knows. Since usually a lot of information has to be packed in that 140-character window, normal words of the English language become bastardized, and you need an acronym decryption kit in order to read it. On top of that, even in 140 characters, people have been known to...ahem...put their foot in their mouth using the service. Nevertheless, Twitter is what all the kids are on nowadays, so this influence rubs off on them. As a result, priorities in writing are no longer can you construct a complete thought, with proper syntax, spelling, pronunciation, and punctuation. It's now how much information can you cram into 140 characters or less, and hope that the reader can make sense of it.
I see it all the time on my writing assignments, particularly lab reports. The lost art of proofreading has escaped everyone. "You" is now just "u," and "great" is now just "gr8." I could continue, but you get the point. As you know, I cannot constrict myself to a 140-character limit, yet another reason why I do not get on Twitter. In education, kids have to understand that Twitter is not going to be the be-all end-all of communication. There will come a time eventually, regardless of their feelings toward my lab reports, when they will have to construct research papers where Twitter-speak is highly discouraged. College essays are another example. The writing sample may be gone from the SAT, but once you get to college, writing will be essential, and let me tell you, in English 101 at the University of Maryland, they take NO prisoners when it comes to grammar. By the time you get there, you have to get it.
I try to do my part by being as complete and thorough as possible with my writing, and I pass that on to my students. Just because I teach science and math does not mean I am incapable of teaching them good writing skills and good grammar.
Full disclosure...if I made ANY grammatical mistakes in this piece, please do bring them to my attention, and they will be corrected at once.
Thank you,
Management
Honestly, that guy I had for Biochemistry I had the absolute worst handwriting ever...but in any event....
Recently, I've been having some "discussions" with my students on the importance of having good grammar, syntax, and overall usage of the English language in both their spoken and written word. Naturally their reaction is something along the lines of "You're a science teacher though!" True, my first inclinations were always with numbers and calculators, but as you hopefully are noticing with my blog posts, I can construct a complete thought! In addition, I have been noticing some mild grievances being aired on social media as well.
You may or may not agree with it, but I don't think anyone can argue that my thoughts are complete.
Why is that? We are up against what I call the "Twitterazi:" the mortal enemy of good grammar, and yes, I did just make up that word. It should not be too hard to tell that it is a portmanteau of "Twitter" and "Paparazzi," and I believe that this evolution is just the latest step in a progression that has been ongoing since the advent of news media.
Think about it. The ultimate sign of success for a news outlet is getting the "scoop," being the first one to report on a big story. If you get to the story first, then everyone else is citing YOU as a source instead of the other way around. Historically, print media was king. If it didn't make the New York Times, then it wasn't worth your time. Then, radio and television supplanted print media. If Walter Cronkite didn't report on it, then it wasn't worth your time either. Broadcast media eventually gave way to cable news. At first it was just CNN, but then MSNBC and Fox News got into the business. This was right around the time the Internet and World Wide Web was starting to become a viable outlet for news.
Then came social media, and that wonderful tool that is Twitter. Now, as most of you know, I am not on Twitter, but have a relatively strong presence on Facebook (which is probably how most of you accessed this page). While I have certainly toyed with the idea of starting a Twitter handle, I have always decided against it. My reasoning is two-fold. First, one social media account is more than enough for me. Second, if I were to start a Twitter, I probably would just be followed by the same people with whom I am already friends on Facebook, so it would be redundant. Nevertheless, anybody who is anybody in the pop culture world is on Twitter, and that's where most of the news-consuming public goes for their big scoops.
It does have its advantages. It is fast, it is to the point. However, that 140-character limit can be a bit of a drag. If a big story is about to break, it is a race among the news outlets to get their 140-character scoop out there first. Long-form articles can wait, once it's on Twitter, then the whole world knows. Since usually a lot of information has to be packed in that 140-character window, normal words of the English language become bastardized, and you need an acronym decryption kit in order to read it. On top of that, even in 140 characters, people have been known to...ahem...put their foot in their mouth using the service. Nevertheless, Twitter is what all the kids are on nowadays, so this influence rubs off on them. As a result, priorities in writing are no longer can you construct a complete thought, with proper syntax, spelling, pronunciation, and punctuation. It's now how much information can you cram into 140 characters or less, and hope that the reader can make sense of it.
I see it all the time on my writing assignments, particularly lab reports. The lost art of proofreading has escaped everyone. "You" is now just "u," and "great" is now just "gr8." I could continue, but you get the point. As you know, I cannot constrict myself to a 140-character limit, yet another reason why I do not get on Twitter. In education, kids have to understand that Twitter is not going to be the be-all end-all of communication. There will come a time eventually, regardless of their feelings toward my lab reports, when they will have to construct research papers where Twitter-speak is highly discouraged. College essays are another example. The writing sample may be gone from the SAT, but once you get to college, writing will be essential, and let me tell you, in English 101 at the University of Maryland, they take NO prisoners when it comes to grammar. By the time you get there, you have to get it.
I try to do my part by being as complete and thorough as possible with my writing, and I pass that on to my students. Just because I teach science and math does not mean I am incapable of teaching them good writing skills and good grammar.
Full disclosure...if I made ANY grammatical mistakes in this piece, please do bring them to my attention, and they will be corrected at once.
Thank you,
Management
Thursday, May 15, 2014
Letters to the Editor: Common Core
Here is a letter to the editor from a concerned Caputo's Corner reader:
http://www.theblaze.com/ stories/2014/03/24/youve-just- got-to-see-what-a-frustrated- parent-wrote-on-their-childs- common-core-math-assignment/
http://www.theblaze.com/
do you guys have to use this crap? or do you get a pass cuz youre a private school ...
Thank you!
This is an important question. Here was my reply.
The short answer is yes we do use that crap, and we have had our fair share of "frustrated parents." We could get a pass, but the Archdiocese is adamant that we implement best practices.
The short answer is yes we do use that crap, and we have had our fair share of "frustrated parents." We could get a pass, but the Archdiocese is adamant that we implement best practices.
2 things, 1-I understand this dude's plight. It's not how they learned it in school. And he's absolutely right, simplification over complication works in the real world. So when he's trying to help his kid with his homework, he's using methods that he learned in grade school, which may or may not compute with his kids.
2-Common Core's (stated) purpose is (in essence) to get kids to really understand what it is in fact they are doing mathematically. Thus the skip counting, which really is it's most prominent feature, is designed to really have kids understand the operation, as opposed to simply doing it by rote. It makes sense if what you're trying to do is encourage all kids to think critically and become "college and career ready" as the administrators are advertising.
However, the fundamental problem with Common Core is the same as what No Child Left Behind was. It attempts to pigeonhole student learning into one model that can be universally applied to all students. That doesn't work though because as I'm sure you know, all kids learn at different paces. Some kids just get it quick, and it's not fair to them to waste time learning how to skip count a subtraction problem if they just get it by doing it the old fashioned way. On the other hand, the skip counting could be a great way for a slower learner to pick up the subtraction if the older algorithm makes no senses. The problem is universal application. Sorry, not everyone is supposed to be an electrical engineer, or a doctor for that matter. Some people are, and they get the math. Challenges for those kids are just not the same.
That was the end of my reply to the reader's question, but something else that Common Core and NCLB have in common is the emphasis on high stakes testing. The powers that be insist that standardized assessment is the best way to ensure that everyone is on the same playing field. Unfortunately, what that does to teachers is forces them to teach to the test, since the test is the more important thing. No teacher takes the job to just teach to the test, and I have heard more than my fair share of burnout stories for just that reason. Teachers want to enlighten students, make them think, and make them become life-long learners (count me in that crowd). If all we were meant to do was prepare kids for tests that are the ultimate judgement of college and career readiness, then we would all be replaced by robots...and nobody wants that...right?
Tuesday, May 13, 2014
Antarctic Ice Sheet Going Bye Bye?
So the doomists are now using terms like "unstoppable" to describe rapidly melting sea ice in Antarctica. It's unstoppable, eh? There is enough sea ice in this particular ice sheet to raise global sea levels by as much as 4 feet if it were to melt completely. In this century alone (by 2100) we could expect sea levels to rise by as much as 1-3 feet, and most scientists are erring on the high side of that. Global warming is "partly" to blame because shifting winds have brought more warm water currents underneath the glaciers which is causing them to melt faster than anticipated.
However, the article does concede that Antarctic sea ice has recently reached record levels. Yet, these findings "don't clash" with that information.
Huh?
It's either melting like the Wicked Witch of the West, or it's freezing. Which is it?
YOU GLOBAL WARMING DENIER, HOW DARE YOU SHOW ANY SKEPTICISM FOR THE 97% CONSENSUS! 97%!!!!!!!!
Look, I have never considered myself among the despicable 3% of vermin who dare say that man-made global warming is not true. Climate is changing, it always does. It could at least even be partly a result of man-made greenhouse gas emissions, I just personally feel like we do not have enough data to draw any sort of reasonable, objective conclusion on the subject. So I'm not in the 3%, but I'm not in the 97% either. I'm just not sold, and speculation is not nearly enough for me to throw my hat in with the people that think this is the biggest crisis in human history...and that drastic steps need to be taken and forced upon us RIGHT NOW.
Climate, ocean, and sea ice data only go back about 100 years (and the further back you go the less reliable it becomes), which in geologic terms is not even the blink of an eye. Thousands of ice ages and other climatic cataclysms have occurred in Earth's history, through no fault of any human. Human impact on the planet has been minimal geologically speaking, and even less if we just go back to the start of the Industrial Revolution. The biggest problem I have always had with this issue is absolutist nature of the way the argument is presented. It goes against everything I teach in my classes about kids being able to think critically and show healthy skepticism for such topics. This ability to question appropriately is something that the National Science Education Standards emphasize. However, when it comes to global warming and climate change, the term "settled science" is used. What exactly does "settled science" mean? It means that there is no debate, there is no opposition, you are not allowed to challenge it because this is scientific fact, and shame on anyone for trying. As I tell my students, that's just bad science with a capital BS...
Science is supposed to be about questioning and skepticism. That's the very first step of the scientific method! Without questioning, there can be no experiment. So by calling the anthropogenic global warming issue "settled science," it is telling anyone with a critical eye that there is no point to experiment, so don't even try. Fortunately, that attitude didn't stop people like Einstein after his relativity theory lay waste to Newton's Laws of Motion, something that had been considered "settled science" for hundreds of years. This is in contradiction to just about everything a good scientist should believe. We are taught to question and criticize, but on this particular issue, not so much. Why could that be?
I don't have a good answer, but conservatives have always railed that global warming/climate change fear mongering has always been an excuse for liberals to force more government regulation down our throats at the expense of economic progress. The liberal argument is that if we do not do anything to save the planet NOW, there won't be much of a planet left, ergo, government must do something. Herein lies the fundamental disagreement between who should be responsible for doing the something (the government or the private sector), and the level of severity of the problem (doing something drastic NOW versus a more gradual approach). I personally don't put much stock in the fear mongering because the doomists over the years have set several deadlines for when the ice caps will have completely melted in the Summer...all of which have come and gone with no ice-free Arctic. Also, Hollywood makes pretty good disaster flicks (See The Day after Tomorrow).
Besides, if the terminology being used today is now "unstoppable," and the rapid melting of sea ice is in fact unstoppable, what could a major governmental regulation possibly do at this point to save it? Wouldn't using the term "unstoppable" mean at this point that saving the sea ice is a lost cause, no matter what anybody does?
Both sides have a fundamental distrust of the other, but right now it's the liberals who are in charge, and thus can have their way. However, one day, much to their chagrin, conservatives will return to positions of authority. That's just how politics works. Both sides will eventually have an opportunity to solve the problem the way they see fit, and we will see who is right. Good science always wins in the end.
![]() |
| I'M MELTING!!! Is this what's happening to Antarctica??!! |
However, the article does concede that Antarctic sea ice has recently reached record levels. Yet, these findings "don't clash" with that information.
Huh?
It's either melting like the Wicked Witch of the West, or it's freezing. Which is it?
YOU GLOBAL WARMING DENIER, HOW DARE YOU SHOW ANY SKEPTICISM FOR THE 97% CONSENSUS! 97%!!!!!!!!
Look, I have never considered myself among the despicable 3% of vermin who dare say that man-made global warming is not true. Climate is changing, it always does. It could at least even be partly a result of man-made greenhouse gas emissions, I just personally feel like we do not have enough data to draw any sort of reasonable, objective conclusion on the subject. So I'm not in the 3%, but I'm not in the 97% either. I'm just not sold, and speculation is not nearly enough for me to throw my hat in with the people that think this is the biggest crisis in human history...and that drastic steps need to be taken and forced upon us RIGHT NOW.
Climate, ocean, and sea ice data only go back about 100 years (and the further back you go the less reliable it becomes), which in geologic terms is not even the blink of an eye. Thousands of ice ages and other climatic cataclysms have occurred in Earth's history, through no fault of any human. Human impact on the planet has been minimal geologically speaking, and even less if we just go back to the start of the Industrial Revolution. The biggest problem I have always had with this issue is absolutist nature of the way the argument is presented. It goes against everything I teach in my classes about kids being able to think critically and show healthy skepticism for such topics. This ability to question appropriately is something that the National Science Education Standards emphasize. However, when it comes to global warming and climate change, the term "settled science" is used. What exactly does "settled science" mean? It means that there is no debate, there is no opposition, you are not allowed to challenge it because this is scientific fact, and shame on anyone for trying. As I tell my students, that's just bad science with a capital BS...
Science is supposed to be about questioning and skepticism. That's the very first step of the scientific method! Without questioning, there can be no experiment. So by calling the anthropogenic global warming issue "settled science," it is telling anyone with a critical eye that there is no point to experiment, so don't even try. Fortunately, that attitude didn't stop people like Einstein after his relativity theory lay waste to Newton's Laws of Motion, something that had been considered "settled science" for hundreds of years. This is in contradiction to just about everything a good scientist should believe. We are taught to question and criticize, but on this particular issue, not so much. Why could that be?
I don't have a good answer, but conservatives have always railed that global warming/climate change fear mongering has always been an excuse for liberals to force more government regulation down our throats at the expense of economic progress. The liberal argument is that if we do not do anything to save the planet NOW, there won't be much of a planet left, ergo, government must do something. Herein lies the fundamental disagreement between who should be responsible for doing the something (the government or the private sector), and the level of severity of the problem (doing something drastic NOW versus a more gradual approach). I personally don't put much stock in the fear mongering because the doomists over the years have set several deadlines for when the ice caps will have completely melted in the Summer...all of which have come and gone with no ice-free Arctic. Also, Hollywood makes pretty good disaster flicks (See The Day after Tomorrow).
Besides, if the terminology being used today is now "unstoppable," and the rapid melting of sea ice is in fact unstoppable, what could a major governmental regulation possibly do at this point to save it? Wouldn't using the term "unstoppable" mean at this point that saving the sea ice is a lost cause, no matter what anybody does?
Both sides have a fundamental distrust of the other, but right now it's the liberals who are in charge, and thus can have their way. However, one day, much to their chagrin, conservatives will return to positions of authority. That's just how politics works. Both sides will eventually have an opportunity to solve the problem the way they see fit, and we will see who is right. Good science always wins in the end.
Thursday, November 10, 2011
Some Thoughts on Penn State
I have been closely paying attention to this story coming out of State College, PA regarding former Penn State defensive coordinator Jerry Sandusky and an alleged sex abuse scandal stemming from 2002. Yesterday was a whirlwind 24 hours for Nittany Lions faithful. It started with a love/hate relationship for and against head football coach Joe Paterno (the same Joe Pa who has been there for the last 46 years). Paterno was never a target of the criminal investigation because he "fulfilled his legal obligation" by reporting to his superior, president Graham Spanier. A graduate assistant informed Paterno that he had alledgedly observed improper acts in a locker room by Sandusky towards a child. Paterno claimed that the graduate assistant (now identified to be current wide receivers coach Mike McQueary) was "distraught" and failed to provide specifics about what he saw. However, no authorities were notified. Yesterday morning, we find out that Paterno decided to retire at the end of the season, which still has 4 games left and potentially more. Paterno decided to retire so that the Penn State Board of Trustees would not have to worry about his status as they decided what to do going forward. However, the Board ignored Paterno's preemptive strike. Last night at around 10PM, after informing Paterno via phone call, the Board announced that both Paterno and Spanier were relieved of their duties "in the best interests of the university as a whole."
Even before the announcement, there was a very sharp divide on how Paterno should be viewed in all of this. Many felt that the best thing to happen was for Paterno to retire as he said he would. It would look really bad for him and the university if they did nothing and Paterno would be allowed to continue as head coach (in spite of calls for him to retire based on age alone, he is 84). Therefore, with Paterno retiring, the university would save face as it were. Students flocked toward his home to show their support, and he even came out and addressed them during the night. Paternoville was full of tents as usual in advance of this Saturday's home finale and Senior Day. It seemed as if Paterno would be able to go out the way he wanted to, albeit under somewhat dubious circumstances. However, he would later find out that this would not be the case, and the venom coming from the students is nasty (they're trying to make the University of Maryland look good apparently).
Here's the bottom line. Here we are talking about the legacy of Joe Paterno and a football program...yet again. For the last couple of years, the culprits have been improper benefits and academic issues at big schools. However, Penn State has been mostly isolated from these things, and Paterno had been revered for always running a squeaky clean program. Unfortunately, we are all missing the big issue here. Children have been affected. This happened 10 years ago and they are now all adults, but who knows how many lives were alledgedly ruined because of Jerry Sandusky? I know it's all allegations at this point and innocent until proven guilty, but right now at least the circumstantial evidence right now is very damning. ***
***Lest we forget, the Duke lacrosse sex scandal. Now, as far as we know, there are no politicians with axes to grind in State College like there was at Duke with Mike Nifong. As heinous as the allegations are (and they are pretty heinous), Jerry Sandusky is afforded the right of due process in a court of law. He can be smeared in the court of public opinion, and with 40 counts coming from the Grand Jury, there is definitely more than enough evidence to put him away for good, but like those lacrosse players, he will get his day in court***
Back to my original point, we are once again talking about the legacy of a coach and a football program, when we really should be talking about the victims and how their lives have been destroyed because of the whims of a madman. For pretty much the entire time I have run this blog, since January, I have argued that college athletics, although an important part of the higher education system, should not be given a higher level of importance over academics and education. After all, this is (and ought to be) the primary goal of any college institution. Penn State may have been squeaky clean for 46 years under Paterno (we think...). However, as they say, the higher they go, the harder they fall. The Board of Trustees doesn't need to give Joe Paterno or Graham Spanier any due process. They have to act on behalf of the best interests of the Pennsylvania State University. They know that as long as Joe Paterno is the head coach, even if it is only for 4 more games, the only press the University would be getting would be about this scandal and how no action is being taken, just like no action was taken in 2002. Their primary objective has to be to enhance the university as an educational institution. In the best interests of the university, an academic institution, the course of action for them was to make a very tough decision and fire the legendary football coach whose name still graces the university library. I applaud the Board for making a very difficult decision, but I have to say that it is the right one, in addition to canning Spanier.
History will look at Penn State football and Penn State University with pride. 409 wins, 2 national championships, 37 bowl apperances, and 24 bowl wins without the slightest hint of impropriety will earn you several well-deserved plaudits. However, in light of recent events, fairly or unfairly, the pride of Penn State football will always be looked at with an asterisk. What was going on in those locker rooms that we did not know about? How could anybody be informed of any sense of impropriety and not make the responsible decision to inform authorities, no matter how "vague" the information was? I know that it's easy for me to say because I was not there, but Joe Paterno has always had that reputation of putting kids first. The children affected by this scandal had their entire lives in front of them, and they were not put first. They have to be first and foremost on everyone's mind. Just like the Board had to make a tough decision they felt was in the best interest of their university, so did Paterno. Paterno (and Penn State in general) is now suffering the consequences of his decision.
I have to say that I do applaud Paterno for coming forward and saying that even though his legal obligation was fufilled, he wishes he could have done more for the victims affected. I am in no way saying that Paterno should be completely disassociated with Penn State. He should still be held in high regard, as long as he really dedicates himself now for advocating for the victims, and for the victims of any similar crimes.
Jess over at Just Call me Janks (a proud Penn State alum) provides another perspective on this issue. She argues in favor of letting Paterno stay the rest of the season, taking into consideration his entire body of work (referencing the library).
Even before the announcement, there was a very sharp divide on how Paterno should be viewed in all of this. Many felt that the best thing to happen was for Paterno to retire as he said he would. It would look really bad for him and the university if they did nothing and Paterno would be allowed to continue as head coach (in spite of calls for him to retire based on age alone, he is 84). Therefore, with Paterno retiring, the university would save face as it were. Students flocked toward his home to show their support, and he even came out and addressed them during the night. Paternoville was full of tents as usual in advance of this Saturday's home finale and Senior Day. It seemed as if Paterno would be able to go out the way he wanted to, albeit under somewhat dubious circumstances. However, he would later find out that this would not be the case, and the venom coming from the students is nasty (they're trying to make the University of Maryland look good apparently).
![]() |
| Joe Paterno |
***Lest we forget, the Duke lacrosse sex scandal. Now, as far as we know, there are no politicians with axes to grind in State College like there was at Duke with Mike Nifong. As heinous as the allegations are (and they are pretty heinous), Jerry Sandusky is afforded the right of due process in a court of law. He can be smeared in the court of public opinion, and with 40 counts coming from the Grand Jury, there is definitely more than enough evidence to put him away for good, but like those lacrosse players, he will get his day in court***
Back to my original point, we are once again talking about the legacy of a coach and a football program, when we really should be talking about the victims and how their lives have been destroyed because of the whims of a madman. For pretty much the entire time I have run this blog, since January, I have argued that college athletics, although an important part of the higher education system, should not be given a higher level of importance over academics and education. After all, this is (and ought to be) the primary goal of any college institution. Penn State may have been squeaky clean for 46 years under Paterno (we think...). However, as they say, the higher they go, the harder they fall. The Board of Trustees doesn't need to give Joe Paterno or Graham Spanier any due process. They have to act on behalf of the best interests of the Pennsylvania State University. They know that as long as Joe Paterno is the head coach, even if it is only for 4 more games, the only press the University would be getting would be about this scandal and how no action is being taken, just like no action was taken in 2002. Their primary objective has to be to enhance the university as an educational institution. In the best interests of the university, an academic institution, the course of action for them was to make a very tough decision and fire the legendary football coach whose name still graces the university library. I applaud the Board for making a very difficult decision, but I have to say that it is the right one, in addition to canning Spanier.
History will look at Penn State football and Penn State University with pride. 409 wins, 2 national championships, 37 bowl apperances, and 24 bowl wins without the slightest hint of impropriety will earn you several well-deserved plaudits. However, in light of recent events, fairly or unfairly, the pride of Penn State football will always be looked at with an asterisk. What was going on in those locker rooms that we did not know about? How could anybody be informed of any sense of impropriety and not make the responsible decision to inform authorities, no matter how "vague" the information was? I know that it's easy for me to say because I was not there, but Joe Paterno has always had that reputation of putting kids first. The children affected by this scandal had their entire lives in front of them, and they were not put first. They have to be first and foremost on everyone's mind. Just like the Board had to make a tough decision they felt was in the best interest of their university, so did Paterno. Paterno (and Penn State in general) is now suffering the consequences of his decision.
I have to say that I do applaud Paterno for coming forward and saying that even though his legal obligation was fufilled, he wishes he could have done more for the victims affected. I am in no way saying that Paterno should be completely disassociated with Penn State. He should still be held in high regard, as long as he really dedicates himself now for advocating for the victims, and for the victims of any similar crimes.
Jess over at Just Call me Janks (a proud Penn State alum) provides another perspective on this issue. She argues in favor of letting Paterno stay the rest of the season, taking into consideration his entire body of work (referencing the library).
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)


