Showing posts with label quarterbacks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label quarterbacks. Show all posts

Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Peyton Manning and more NFL Talk

So much for "Tebow Mania."

I guess John Elway was never in Tim Tebow's camp to begin with, as sources say that the Broncos are in contract negotiations now with Peyton Manning.  The Manning camp has reportedly informed his other suitors that he is no longer interested.  The contract being negotiated is somewhere in the 5 years $90 million range.  How did Peyton arrive at this decision?  First off, at 36, even if he was completely healthy (which he is not), he would only have about 3 or 4 years left (and at most 2 good ones).  His window for winnning championships is closing.  Therefore, he needs a team that in his opinion is very close to winning now.  He doesn't want to do it in the NFC due to the increased likelihood of playing his brother, so that eliminated teams like San Francisco.  Miami is not close to winning a title (far from it actually) and they do not have any of the key parts to go around Manning, so they are out.  Finally, a team like Tennessee might have been a good fit, but that would also mean playing the Colts twice a year, something Peyton will not go on the record and admit, but you know he does NOT want to do that.  Therefore, by process of elimination, the Broncos were the team for him. 

Now, what does all of this mean for Tim Tebow?  Tebow led the Broncos to the division title last year, resurrecting them after a 1-5 start to finish 8-8 (although that did include 3 straight losses to end the year) as well as win a playoff game over the defending conference champion Steelers.  However, John Elway is somebody who knows quarterbacks, and he also knows how to talk out of both sides of his mouth.  He is originally from the West Coast, after all.  Sure, at the end of the season he will say that Tebow is his guy, even going so far as to say that he will work "personally" with Tebow to improve his game.  So when a premium quarterback like Peyton Manning goes on the market, he quickly abandons any and all plans he has for Tebow to go all in on the Manning express.  Tebow in all likelihood will be traded (for what I heard on the radio to be the equivalent of a ham sandwich) or just cut (if the ham sandwich happens to be rotten). 

There are a couple of options here.  The Broncos did pick Tebow in the 1st round, so they do owe him some guaranteed money.  Therefore, they might not be too quick to drop the hammer.  After all, one hit on Peyton in his neck region and he is donezo.  You don't mess with neck injuries, and Peyton is taking a huge risk by coming back this season.  Elway could still be Tebow's mentor, and if there is anybody who won't feel animosity toward the club it is Tebow.  He won't start making trade demands, not like he has any leverage anyway.  The most likely scenario in my mind is that he will be cut.  The Broncos will look for draft pick compensation somewhere in the 3rd or 4th round range, that would be my guess.  Nobody will offer anything higher than a 6th, so the Broncos will cut Tebow to let him "find the team that best suits him."  He'll be on somebody's practice squad next year, or deli sandwhich line, whatever floats his boat.

Elsewhere in the crazy world of free agency, now that the Peyton domino has fallen, expect other quarterbacks to fall into place soon.  In San Francisco, the 49ers have to decide now whether or not to pursue Alex Smith to stay.  Smith probably will feel slighted considering the 49ers interest in Peyton, so he might not be so quick to sign on the dotted line.  Matt Flynn, another big quarterback (he who has only played one game from start to finish, and that was in mop up duty at the end of the 2011 season) has signed with Seattle.  Now this leaves other quarterback starved teams struggling.  Miami went gangbusters for Peyton, and they were burned.  Cleveland thought they had the inside track to trading up in the draft to get Robert Griffin III (HAHA!), and now they are stuck with Colt McCoy.  The Redskins have made plenty of moves as usual, as reported here at Caputo's Corner.  Now, the biggest move left is whether or not they will resign London Fletcher to captain the defense.  We here at Caputo's Corner, as well as many other fans and so-called experts all agree that the Redskins need to make this happen, and we are not (yet) alarmed that it has taken as long as it has because we still feel like a deal will eventually get done, even though there has not been a whole lot of movement yet.

Friday, September 16, 2011

The Death of Defense

There is a very interesting piece on ESPN this morning from Michael Wilbon of PTI fame.  He discusses the radical shift in football offensive philosophy from a run-oriented game to the pass-wacky game of the present day and how defenses have had to cope with it.  New rules designed to protect the quarterbacks have given the field generals more freedom than ever to dictate the flow of a game.  Case in point: Tom Brady throws for 517 yards in Week 1, 3 quarterbacks throw for over 400 yards, and 14 quarterbacks throw for over 300 yards.  At over 7,800 yards, more yards were gained passing in week 1 than ever before.  As a result, defenses are left dazed and confused, without really anything they can do about it. 

Why is this happening?  In discussions with Darren Woodson and Herm Edwards, Wilbon argues that new research into concussions and head injuries have made the game softer than it 20th century counterpart.  Throw on top of that rules such as the 5-yard chuck rule on receivers, as well as rules protecting defenseless receivers, the NFL is a league ripe for huge amounts of yards to be gained and points to be scored.  Defenses are not allowed to hit hard anymore, and the days of big-hitting defenses are, in fact, over.  Quarterback is the most important (and highest paid) position on the field.  Teams just cannot afford big time quarterbacks to get injured.  Look at Indianapolis today without Peyton Manning.  New England had to go a season without Tom Brady and missed the playoffs (granted, they were still 11-5 that year).  Bill Parcells has declared the end of the era of the strong safety.  Running offenses allow 11 guys to possibly tackle the ball carrier, whereas passing offenses make a ball carrier worry about only 3 or 4.  You are seeing a domino effect as well in lower levels (college and high school).  Even schools like Notre Dame, Alabama, and Penn State have dramatically shifted from option and run-oriented offenses to more shotgun spread, 4-wide receiver sets. 

Do I think that the defense has died in football?  No I don't.  However, it is licking its wounds as it were.  Like all sports, there are certain periods of time that favor offense, and certain periods of time that favor defense.  Think about in baseball, you have the dead ball era and the live ball era (and the steroid era...).  In football, we have entered the era of spread formations and the over-protection of the quarterback, and offenses are taking advantage.  However, coaches in football are smart.  They will learn to adjust.  Wilbon makes an excellent point in saying that the way to stop premier quarterbacks like Manning is to let them get inside the 20, and exploit the shrunken field.  These teams make their hay on spreading the field out, and big fields are exactly what they want to see.  Shrink the field, and that takes a very key weapon away.  Unfortunately, the days of true big-hitting defenses are in fact over, as I don't see the league relaxing on the rules any time soon (and rightfully so).  This just means that teams are going to have to get smarter on defense, and I feel like they will.  Instead of the mantra of "kill the quarterback," the mantra will become "take the ball away" or "get to the spot before he does" or something like that.  Football is a game built on speed moreso than power in the 21st century, and you're already starting to see that with guys like Revis and Reed patrolling the secondary.  Defense will be fine, and so will quarterbacks.  So they will enjoy their 500 yard passing games now, but eventually everyone will come back down to Earth...or just back to under center. 

Tuesday, August 16, 2011

Beck, Grossman, and Andrew Luck

Interesting piece on Dan Graziano's NFC East Blog today.  He talks about the quarterback "competition" between John Beck and Rex Grossman.  However, some might even wonder if Mike Shanahan is just conceding on the season by A) not making a serious attempt at keeping Donovan McNabb or B) not making a serious play on another veteran quarterback who can contribute right away.  Why would we he want to "tank" the season with either Beck or Grossman under center?  The answer is quite simple.  Andrew Luck (barring injury or other disaster) is going to be the undisputed #1 overall draft pick in the 2012 NFL Draft.  He would have been the #1 pick this year had he not decided to go back to Stanford for his senior season (the distinction this year went to Cam Newton, who looked pretty good in his first preseason game, but did not make one attempt to tuck it and run like he did so well at Auburn).  That being said, Andrew Luck is they type of quarterback talent that teams salivate over.  Since he's pretty much guaranteed the #1 pick next year (again, barring disaster scenarios), the formula for getting him is pretty simple.  Play as bad as you possibly can: 2 wins max, 0-16 just to be safe.  Many look at what the Redskins are doing as just our way of making sure we are as bad as possible so that we get the #1 pick and therefore Andrew Luck.

As bad as the Redskins have been since we last won the Super Bowl following the 1991 season, we have never been so bad as to have the #1 pick.  In fact, the Redskins have NEVER had the #1 pick in our entire team history (78 years worth).  There has always been at least a couple teams worse than us.  My question to Shanahan (and by proxy Daniel Snyder) is this.  Season ticket sales and waitlist sales are already dropping precipitously as it is.  What possible good will it do for the team and the organization by tanking a season so that we get an outside chance at a kid who could be the next Peyton Manning...or the next Ryan Leaf?  It's not worth it.  Snyder's ultimate fear is blackouts (which has not been a problem in the last 30 years since we have sold out every game since 1980).  That could very well happen if we put a product on the field this year that wins at most 2 games. 

If you believe the Shanahan duo (Mike and Kyle), they would have you believe that they really like what they see in Grossman and Beck in particular.  Grossman led the Chicago Bears to the Super Bowl in 2006 (on a team that was led mostly by defense and Devin Hester returning kicks...wonder how much HE likes the new kickoff rule...).  Beck has a lot of so-called "upside," but the one shot he had at starting was in 2007 after Trent Green got hurt with Miami.  He went 0-5 on the way to a 1-15 season (the one win being earned by Cleo Lemmon).  So on the surface, it appears as if neither Beck nor Grossman have the kind of pedigree to lead this team to anything more than a mediocre season.  Now, Beck has been talking some serious smack since it became clear that McNabb was not in the team's plans this year.  Beck has said from the get go that he would be the starter.  Grossman has even gone so far as to say that the Redskins would even win the NFC East.  I like the enthusiasm, but even still they need to know that they are not superstars, and other than Moss and Cooley, they don't have superstar talent around them.  However, if they play as well as they did against Pittsburgh in the preseason game last weekend, who knows?  There are 3 more preseason games to go...