Showing posts with label Barack Obama. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Barack Obama. Show all posts

Monday, March 26, 2012

Calling Dr. Justice...

The Supreme Court will hear oral arguments over the next few
days over the legality of ObamaCare (from foxnews.com)
Today is the first of 3 days worth of oral arguments the Supreme Court will hear on the constitutionality of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act, AKA "ObamaCare."  Two years ago, this law was signed sparking sharp debate from supporters and critics alike. 

I'll just cut to the chase, we here at Caputo's Corner believe that forcing everyone in the country to buy health insurance is totally, emphatically, and unequivocally unconstitutional.  Who is Uncle Sam to say what we can and cannot buy for ourselves?  Intrusions of government into our private lives such as this one are sickening, and would make the founding fathers, who praised individual liberty and the limited role of federal government, roll in their graves.  Therefore, the Supreme Court better rule this thing unconstitutional...or should I say, Justice Kennedy better rule this unconstitutional.  We all know how the other 8 are going to vote. 

Now that I got that out of the way, there are actually 4 different provisions here that the court will consider, and I'll take each of those individually next:

-The first challenge is more of a last ditch attempt to make sure the court punts for another 3 years.  26 states have challenged the law, and in 2 of the lower courts, judges have ruled that the penalty for not having health insurance (starting in 2014) is actually a "tax," and according to the archaic Anti-Injunction Act (AIA) passed in 1867 (yes, 1867!) challenges to tax laws cannot be heard until the tax is first collected.  This is rediculous on a number of levels.  First, the penalty is just that, a penalty.  Taxes are levied for the purpose of raising revenue for the government.  Assuming everyone does their "duty" and buys insurance, no money will be raised, thus producing no revenue.  Second, the law was passed during Reconstruction for the purpose of reintegrating the Southern States after the Civil War.  Sorry, but Reconstruction era legislation should have no bearing on policy decisions in 2012.  This matter is a joke, and most legal eagles believe the court will also see it that way.  The only reason this is even an issue at all is because it gives the court a potential escape from having to decide this law on the merits during an election year, which quite frankly would be highly irresponsible on their part.

-The second, and probably most important decision will be on the constitutionality of the individual mandate.  As I stated above, this is most definitely unconstitutional.  It is not the business of the government to force people into buying health insurance.  Proponents will argue that the Commerce Clause gives the government the right to do so because health care is interstate commerce.  However, you can't be FORCED into interstate commerce.  The mandate does just that.  Liberals and big government advocates always seem to somehow spin the Commerce Clause in different ways (not to mention obscure legislative procedures) to get laws like ObamaCare passed.

-The third matter regards the severance of the individual mandate from the rest of the law.  The entire law as written was over 2,700 pages.  Yikes!  Clearly there is more to this than the individual mandate.  If the mandate is struck down, the issue becomes whether or not the rest of the law has to go down with it.  The administration itself has said that without the mandate, the law cannot stand.  So in that sense it really seems like an open and shut case.  Without the mandate, the entire law must go.  However, the court does not necessarily have to view it that way.  They can say the mandate is unconstitutional and then leave it to Congress and the president to figure out the rest.  Personally, the whole thing is unconstitutional and should be struck down on the merits, not just the mandate, but that's just me. 

-The final case to be heard on Wednesday afternoon deals with the expansion of Medicaid, which if made compulsory as the law would have happen, the costs would be astronomical, and would achieve the same effect of forcing people into insurance.  Thus the same arguments for striking down the individual mandate would hold for this provision expanding Medicaid. 

All in all, it is quite clear that ObamaCare is not popular with the electorate.  Majorities of voters in just about all areas (save of course for liberal Democrats) disagree with at least one portion of the law (mostly the individual mandate).  Republicans in Congress are working on getting some kind of a repeal measure through, but as long as the Democrats control the Senate and Obama is in the White House, that will never happen.  A ruling on the constitutionality of ObamaCare will not come until early in the Summer. 

Tuesday, January 25, 2011

State of the Union tonight-check please

I don't think I'm going to watch the State of the Union tonight...well, I guess I might...if it's a REALLY slow sports night.  Don't really see the point.  It's just going to be an hour of applause at just about everything Obama says, perhaps some head shaking (oh wait...Sam Alito's not there) perhaps somebody screaming out "YOU LIE!"  He might even look up to the rafters once or twice and pretend to have a tear in his eye.  I can basically summarize the content of what he is going to say in a few words. 

1) Don't bother trying to repeal Obamacare...your efforts are futile.

2) I might say I want to think about curbing spending, but I still want you (Congress) to spend spend spend (when nobody's watching of course)!

3) Americans are great...nah we're just OK (what's up, China?)

4) Whatever the Tea Party is going to say after I'm finished is meaningless

5) Don't forget to clap at everything I say

6) I'm in charge...and there's nothing you can do about it

There will be a couple of firsts tonight, one is kind of stupid and one is kind of significant.  The first stupid idea is that Republicans and Democrats are going to be sitting side by side, instead of on opposite sides of the center aisle as is usually the case.  This is the dumbest idea I've heard in a while.  What are they trying to prove...that everybody is everybody's best friend?  All this means is that when the Democrats stand up to cheer all the liberal points of the speech, instead of seeing one side of the chamber rise up, it will look like a pathetic minor league game with a few people here and there standing and applauding.  I don't know much about politics...but I don't think that looks good on camera, but that's just me.

The other significant idea (I'm not necessarily saying smart...that remains to be seen) is that there is going to be 2 opposition responses to it.  Paul Ryan of Wisconsin will give the official Republican response, but Michelle Bachmann of Minnesota is going to give the Tea Party Caucus response.  Bachmann's response (oddly enough) is only going to air on..........ready for it....CNN (gasp! that bastion of conservative blasphemy Fox News isn't going to cover their glorious Tea Party revolution???).  I don't know what is going to come of it (if anything), but I can almost guarantee that what she's going to say will be far more scathing than what Ryan is going say.  Ryan's response will probably be something along the lines of "while we don't necessarily agree with what President Obama is saying, we all agree that we should work together to help make America great" (cue aww shucks moment).  Bachmann will most likely say something along the lines of "Mr. President, your policies of tax and spend are running this country into the ground.  Countries like China, and all of their human rights travesties, are quickly passing us as the world's leader in economics, trade, and a bunch of other areas...because instead of standing up to them, you give them a state dinner!  If you are truly concerned with keeping America great, you need to radically alter your way of thinking.  Cut taxes (don't just prevent them from increasing), eliminate wasteful spending of all kinds, and stop saying that your government knows best, because it doesn't" 

Depending on how well the "Tea Party response" is received, it could alter the way Obama deals with a Republican congress, and could force him to make some more compromises than he otherwise would like.  On the other hand, he could also completely ignore them (and what the people are saying)...wouldn't be the first time.