Great post last Tuesday on our first half of the top 10 bridges in America. I just need to clear something up before I move on to the honorable mentions and top 5. While total length was a factor in the ranking, it was not a be all end all in what bridges made my list. You'll see a couple long bridges today, but also a couple of shorter ones. Several bridges can claim to be the "longest" using any number of different sets of criteria. These records are being shattered on a regular basis in Europe and Asia. However, I am not quite as familiar with the architecture and engineering over there as I am with it in this country. Perhaps in a future post I could do a little research.
In any event, here are the almost-5: the honorable mentions. Neat in their own little right, but not quite magnificent enough to make my top 10.
Tacoma Narrows Bridge: SR 16 and SR 14 over Puget Sound-Tacoma, WA
Seems pretty odd considering I referenced Galloping Gertie twice in yesterday's post. However, I find it hard to include a bridge that collapsed 4 months after it opened on a list of top 10 bridges of all time. Nevertheless, there were several engineering lessons learned as a result...and elementary physics students can marvel at the near perfect harmonic oscillation.
Leonard P. Zakim Bunker Hill Bridge: I-93 over Charles River-Boston, MA
I came very close to putting this on the featured list. I decided to omit it for a couple reasons. First, I did not want the list to be overrun with cable-stayed bridges that replaced antiquated cantilever designs. I have another one of those in the top 5 in addition to the Sunshine Skyway yesterday. Also, this bridge is a key cog in the Boston Big Dig, and an item on this bridge would inevitably transition into a lecture on the merits of the Big Dig, the politics thereof, and would then move into (leaky) tunnel technology. This is a piece on bridges after all. I must admit that it is spectacular to look at. Did I ever mention that climbing to the top of the Bunker Hill monument tires you out?
Woodrow Wilson Bridge: I-95 and I-495 over Potomac River-Alexandria, VA and Oxon Hill, MD
Drawbridges don't make a featured list. Period. However, DC's favorite bottleneck eeks its way into the honorable mentions because of the innovations added as part of its reconstruction in the 2000s. The express/local configuration is not new (I-270 has had it for years), but the bridge now has capacity for a dozen lanes...and a right-of-way for a high-speed rail corridor. It took a bridge that had more than tripled its originial design capacity and turned it into an engineering staple of the DC area. There's a problem though. It's still a drawbridge! While the reconstruction has lowered the number of scheduled openings from about 200 to about 70 per year, a drawbridge on the Interstate Highway System in my opinion is a no-no. Interstates are not supposed to have holes in it, especially I-95: the main street of the East Coast and probably the most important highway in the country, if not the world (still waiting for New Jersey to close that little gap...) I must admit it is much prettier to drive over though now than it used to be.
Fort Pitt Bridge: I-279, US 30, and US 22 over Monongahela River-Pittsburgh, PA
This bridge makes the honorable mention list for purely selfish reasons alone. This:
Benjamin Franklin Bridge: I-676 and US 30 over Delaware River-Philadelphia, PA and Camden, NJ
The "other" Big Ben (and I'm not referring to the dude with the busted schnoz in Pittsburgh) is the best way to get into Center City Philadelphia from New Jersey. The alternatives are the Whitman, which takes you too far south, the Commodore Barry which dumps you in Chester, and Scudder Falls up by Trenton...but at least that last one's toll free.
Interesting, diverse sample in the HMs, but now we get to the big guns. I now present to you the top 5 bridges in America!
Showing posts with label Bridges. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bridges. Show all posts
Thursday, February 17, 2011
Tuesday, February 15, 2011
Nick's Lists: Top 10 Bridges in America (10-6)
As I said in Monday's post, I am a bit of a road geek. As a science guy as well, I am somewhat fascinated in the science and engineering principles that go into bridge building. I had so much fun doing my post on road construction, that I decided to take it one step further and do a full edition of Nick's Lists dedicated to bridges. Caputo's Corner reader Jeff will be the unofficial engineering fact checker on this post. If I get the physics wrong on any of this, please feel free to call me on it. My brother the architect and wannabe civil engineer also probably knows more about bridge building than I ever will, so he has free reign to correct me if the science or architectural analysis is inaccurate. I was a chemistry/natural science guy in college. If you want to (safely :-)) blow stuff up and have a good time doing it, I'm your guy. If you're into building and materials science, Joe and Jeff are the guys to call.
There is an urban legend that when I was four, I could give accurate directions to my grandmother's house in Carmel, NY. I was apparently the life of the party as adults would ask me how to get to get to Grandma's house. I would politely answer the question while the adults laughed. While I will not debate the validity of that claim specifically, I will agree that I have always had a life long fascination with roads, and especially bridges and tunnels. Makes you wonder why I didn't decide to become an engineer...but I digress. Whenever would take long trips where I knew we would be going over a big bridge, I would tell Dad to wake me up just before we made it there. Tunnels on the other hand...I was petrified of initially. When we would drive through the Fort McHenry or Baltimore Harbor Tunnels, I would bury my head in a pillow. Since then, I have most definitely overcome that fear and taken on a fascination with tunnels and their construction as well. However, I will focus this post on bridges. In a future post I'll take a look at tunnels.
My criteria for the list included 4 factors (in order of importance):
1) Engineering quality
2) Importance in a highway network
3) Historical Significance
4) Aesthetics
So let's cut through the asphalt and concrete and get to work. I now present to you numbers 10-6 of my list of the top 10 bridges in the United States of America!
There is an urban legend that when I was four, I could give accurate directions to my grandmother's house in Carmel, NY. I was apparently the life of the party as adults would ask me how to get to get to Grandma's house. I would politely answer the question while the adults laughed. While I will not debate the validity of that claim specifically, I will agree that I have always had a life long fascination with roads, and especially bridges and tunnels. Makes you wonder why I didn't decide to become an engineer...but I digress. Whenever would take long trips where I knew we would be going over a big bridge, I would tell Dad to wake me up just before we made it there. Tunnels on the other hand...I was petrified of initially. When we would drive through the Fort McHenry or Baltimore Harbor Tunnels, I would bury my head in a pillow. Since then, I have most definitely overcome that fear and taken on a fascination with tunnels and their construction as well. However, I will focus this post on bridges. In a future post I'll take a look at tunnels.
My criteria for the list included 4 factors (in order of importance):
1) Engineering quality
2) Importance in a highway network
3) Historical Significance
4) Aesthetics
So let's cut through the asphalt and concrete and get to work. I now present to you numbers 10-6 of my list of the top 10 bridges in the United States of America!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
