There is an urban legend that when I was four, I could give accurate directions to my grandmother's house in Carmel, NY. I was apparently the life of the party as adults would ask me how to get to get to Grandma's house. I would politely answer the question while the adults laughed. While I will not debate the validity of that claim specifically, I will agree that I have always had a life long fascination with roads, and especially bridges and tunnels. Makes you wonder why I didn't decide to become an engineer...but I digress. Whenever would take long trips where I knew we would be going over a big bridge, I would tell Dad to wake me up just before we made it there. Tunnels on the other hand...I was petrified of initially. When we would drive through the Fort McHenry or Baltimore Harbor Tunnels, I would bury my head in a pillow. Since then, I have most definitely overcome that fear and taken on a fascination with tunnels and their construction as well. However, I will focus this post on bridges. In a future post I'll take a look at tunnels.
My criteria for the list included 4 factors (in order of importance):
1) Engineering quality
2) Importance in a highway network
3) Historical Significance
4) Aesthetics
So let's cut through the asphalt and concrete and get to work. I now present to you numbers 10-6 of my list of the top 10 bridges in the United States of America!
10) Tappan Zee Bridge: I-87 and I-287 over Hudson River-Nyack and Tarrytown, NY
Total length-3 miles
Span-Cantilever
Max Clearance-138 feet
Toll-$5/$4.75 with EZ Pass (Eastbound only)
This bridge makes the list more as a personal favorite of mine really more than it is a stellar bridge. I admittedly have a soft spot for the Tappan Zee having traveled over it numerous times going to Grandma's house. In fact, as a bridge, it's a piece of junk. It's falling apart. The New York Thruway Authority has been conducting studies for years about a potential replacement. The cantilever span is quite antiquated and it has long since exceeded projected traffic capacity. It is unique though in its own right as being one of the first bridges to employ a zipper barrier to control traffic flow based on rush hour times. There have actually been fears for some time that it could collapse at any time. While engineers reassure scared drivers that it is structurally sound, it is still quite a harrowing proposition. I personally think talk of it falling apart is just hyperbole (but people in Minnesota might beg to differ). Tomorrow in the honorable mentions, we recall the story of Galloping Gertie. While Tappan Zee is no Gertie, this is an old bridge that could definitely use a makeover if not a complete replacement. Nevertheless, it is a vital link in the New York metropolitan area highway network. When going to Manhattan, if you live in Rockland or Orange Counties, there really is no easy way to get around it. The next closet Hudson crossings are Bear Mountain and the George Washington Bridge, both several miles away. Speaking of....
9) George Washington Bridge: I-95, US 1, US 9, and US 46 over Hudson River-Fort Lee, NJ and New York, NY
Total length-0.88 miles
Span-Suspension
Max Clearance-212 feet
Toll-$8 at peak/$6 with EZ Pass; $2 discount for registered HOV-3 with EZ Pass (Eastbound only)
One of the original New York area Hudson crossings, the GWB has been a staple in traffic jams for decades. If you don't know your way around New York, and you're trying to cut through on your way to New England, chances are you'll end up on the GWB...and you'll be there for a while. At least while you're waiting in line you'll get to take a look at one of the nicest suspension tower designs there is. The criss-cross design is unique and adds a character to the bridge that you can only find in the New York area. As far as the engineering goes, the GWB was quite innovative for its time. The chief engineer was Othmar Ammann, who designed several of the bridges in the New York City area. The lower deck was added in 1962, and that was something that Ammann had anticipated in his original design. Check this out from the Port Authority website: "The physical construction of the bridge is itself a marvel of engineering. The four main cables are each composed of a single strand carried back and forth across the river 61 times. Each strand-itself a bundle of 434 individual wires-wraps around a strand shoe in the anchorage before looping back toward the opposite shore. Each shoe connects to a bar sunk deep into the anchorage that holds the strand in place." At least while you're sitting in traffic, you can rest assured that you are sitting on an engineering wonder.
8) Chesapeake Bay Bridge: US 50 and 301 over Chespeake Bay-Sandy Point and Kent Island, MD
Total length-5 Miles
Spans-Cantilever and Suspension
Max Clearance-186 feet (suspension span)
Toll-$2.50 (Eastbound only)
This bridge is officially titled the William Preston Lane Jr. Memorial Bridge after the former Governor of Maryland who oversaw its construction. Since the early 20th century, it was evident in the State of Maryland that a fixed crossing over the Chesapeake Bay was going to be a necessity. The explosion of the Delmarva ocean resorts, and Ocean City in particular, demanded that Western Shorer-ers have a way to get to the beach without having to drive up Route 40 all the way to Perryville, cross the Susquehanna over the Hatem Bridge, then take the long winding road down Route 213 to the shore. Several crossing studies were conducted, but it was not until 1947 that a bridge would officially become reality. In that year, a ferry service connecting Annapolis and Matapeake on the Eastern Shore (a ferry which carried the number Route 404) began in anticipation of the completion of the fixed crossing. The bridge was finally completed in 1952. The bridge (and its twin constructed in 1973) has an interesting turn in it, both literally and figuratively. The western end of the bridge carries a sharp curve. This curve is due to marine regulations that shipping channels go under bridge spans at 90 degree angles. There was no way to build the bridge shore to shore (at the location where it was built) without the curve so that ocean-going vessels could go underneath it safely. The Bay Bridge is also unique in that it has two shipping channels. The suspension portion is the main channel and where most of the big boats go. The smaller cantilever channel, which only has 75 feet of clearance, is mostly for smaller clipper type ships. When this bridge opened (and the twin span 21 years later), it opened up a gateway to the Eastern Shore that had previously divided the state of Maryland in two. Even to this day, the Eastern Shore is a compltely different way of life (until you get to OC of course) compared to the cosmopolitan nature of the Baltimore/Washington/Annapolis corridor. The Bay Bridge is also a vital link in traffic up and down the whole Eastern seaboard. Serving in its US 301 designation, it provides a tempting alternative to I-95 connecting Richmond to the Philadelphia area, allowing motorists a complete bypass of the mess of beltways and parkways that is Washington and Baltimore.
7) Mackinac Bridge: I-75 over the Straits of Mackinac-St. Ignace and Mackinaw City, MI
Total length-5 miles
Span-Suspension
Max Clearance-155 feet
Toll-$3.50
Alright, everybody all together now. It's pronounced Mack-i-NAW. Not Mack-i-NACK. Mack-i-NAW, people. Talk to Yoopers and pronounce it wrong, well, I'll let you draw your own conclusions about what might happen to you. The Mackinac Bridge is very similar to the Chesapeake Bay Bridge in that it serves as the only permanent connection between two very different regions in the State of Michigan. The Upper Peninsula is very similar to the Eastern Shore of Maryland: splendid isolation by water. Lake Michigan and Lake Huron come together quite conveniently so that only 5 miles separate the 2 peninsulas that make up that state. What a convenient place for a bridge. So the innovative people from Michigan decided to put one there. The Mackinac Bridge holds a number of distinctions. It is the 3rd longest suspension bridge in the world, and the longest in the Western Hemisphere. Since it is so long, as well as being subjected to some strong winds over the straits, it is also designed to sway, as much as 35 feet! While this would only occur under severe wind conditions, it does bring back images of a Galloping Gertie, and the lessons engineers learned from it. When the wind subsides, the weight of vehicles take it back to its normal position. Another interesting factoid about the Mackinac Bridge is that it is one of only 3 tolled sections of I-75. One is the international bridge into Canada only a few miles away. The other one is the Everglades Parkway (Alligator Alley) all they way down in South Florida, 6 full (and rather large) states away.
6) Sunshine Skyway: I-275 and US 19 over Tampa Bay-St. Petersburg, FL
Total length-5.5 miles
Span-Cable Stayed
Max Clearance-191 feet
Toll-$1/$0.75 with Electronic Toll Collection
The Sunshine Skyway I'm writing about is the replacement for a former cantilever span that was damaged by a Hurricane. Today, the old bridge is used as a fishing pier. A recurring theme nowadays is to have cable-stayed bridges replace aging (or damaged) cantilever spans. cable-stayed bridges provide several engineering advantages over cantilever (and suspension). Jeff and Joe can probably go into more detail than I can, but pretty simply, the primary load-bearing structures are the concrete towers. The cables simply stabilize the deck. This is opposed to suspension bridges where the load is primarily held in the cables. Suspension bridges typically use only 2 towers to hold up the deck, but in a cable-stayed bridge, any number of towers can be used. The Sunshine Skyway fits this model perfectly. I have never been over this bridge. The closest I ever came to it was when I was in Orlando last year. However, to truly appreciate a trip over this bridge. Take a look at this video from Freewayjim:
That concludes our first half of the top 10 bridges in America. I hope you enjoyed our little road trip and maybe learned something along the way. Stay tuned on Thursday for the conclusion of this list. Tomorrow is going to be a little difficult for me to get in front of the computer to post. I'm just going to say it now. Can all of you aspiring engineers hang in there 48 hours? I thought so :-).





No comments:
Post a Comment