Showing posts with label playoffs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label playoffs. Show all posts

Monday, January 23, 2012

Championship Game Analysis

No, Caputo's Corner has not fallen off the face of the Earth.  I've had various other committments over the last few days which have preempted quality blog time, but that does not mean I have not been paying attention over the last few days.  As you might remember (or you might not...after all it has been a year), I did a marathon blog last year for Championship Sunday.  This year, not so much, but if I had done a marathon, there would have been quite a bit to talk about. 

In the first game, we featured the classic irresitible force against the immovable object scenario when the Patriots faced off against Baltimore.  Last week, I noted that Baltimore had a very decent shot as long as they can run the football to keep Brady & Co on the sidelines.  The Patriots defense is suspect, especially their run defense.  Why can't teams exploit this?!  Ray Rice and Ricky Williams had some really nice holes to run through in the second half.  The first half they were shut down somewhat, but as the Patriots started to tire, the Ravens should have taken advantage.  Instead, Flacco tried to play the hero, and I'll give him credit, he played a MUCH better game than Brady did, a significantly better game than Brady.  He only really had one bad throw in the whole game (the 4th quarter pick).  Nevertheless, the key to beating the Patriots is to stick with a running game to wear them down.  You are NOT going to outscore them.  You have to keep Brady on the bench.  Even when Gronkowski got hurt, you just knew the Pats were not, just could not slow down.  23 points might not seem like a lot, but it could have been even less if the Ravens had just stuck with the run even more than they had. 

Notice in that entire analysis that I did not even once mention the name Billy Cundiff.  Morons who blame the Ravens' loss on the kicker are just that...morons.  Yes, it was a chip shot, and yes, he should have hit it, but it should have never come to that.  The blueprint on beating New England is very very simple, but it is very easy to throw caution to the wind, especially when they score once or twice...just ask Denver.  Again, I will give the Ravens credit, they did play an excellent ballgame, but the tactics were very questionable.  I think Harbaugh is going to have a chat with Cam Cameron over some of the playcalling in that game, telling him that he should have watched game film from Super Bowl XLII.

Speaking of which....

What do we have here?  We have a rematch!  This is the first Super Bowl rematch since Super Bowl XXX when the Cowboys and the Steelers met for the 3rd time in a Super Bowl.  The Patriots get another crack at the G-Men thanks to the Giants 20-17 overtime upset over San Francisco in the NFC Championship nightcap.  As we all remember, 19-0 turned into 18-D'OH when the unbeatable Patriots, fresh off a season full of Spygate, succombed to Eli and Plaxico in the desert.  I don't like Eli Manning.  I just don't.  Eli is a very easy guy to dislike, going all the way back to the 2004 draft when Daddy Archie whined in front of the cameras because Baby Eli didn't want to play for the Chargers.  Now, Eli is just one win away from a second Super Bowl, as opposed to big brother Peyton who still only has one.  How did they do it?  Well, I'll tell you, it wasn't Eli.  Here are the MVPs from the NFC Championship: Osi Umenyiora, Justin Tuck, Mattias Kiwanuka, and Jason Pierre-Paul.  They were wreaking havoc in the San Fran backfield all day.  Frank Gore could not get his engine started.  Alex Smith was running for his life all night (and so was Eli).  When he did have time, Smith found Vernon Davis.  Davis only caught 3 balls on the night, but two of them went for TDs (28 and 73 yards each).  However, the key play of this game was a punt...yes, a punt.  In the 4th quarter, Steve Weatherford (who did about as much as a punter could to earn game MVP honors...12 boots for 557 yards) booted to Ted Ginn, and the ball appeared to graze off of his left knee.  Initially the ruling on the field was that the ball did not touch Ginn and the 49ers kept possession.  However, the Giants challenged and the ball did in fact hit Ginn, setting the Giants up inside San Francisco 30.  They scored a few plays later to go up 17-14.  Up to that point, the Giants offense had been stymied, but that sequence of events proved to be enough as the Giants defense was just as up to the task as the Niner defense was. 

In overtime, the Giants won the toss, but a quick 3 and out put to bed any chance of the new playoff overtime rule coming into effect.  The winning field goal was set up by...you guessed it...another punt.  This time, Kyle Williams did the honors, fumbling the punt away to put the Giants in field goal range immediately.  Lawrence Tynes was true from 31 yards out, setting up the first rematch in a Super Bowl in 16 years.  The early edge has to go to the Patriots.  However, as the Patriots can tell you, if there ever was a team that knew the blueprint for beating them (and sticking to it), it's the New York Giants.  Eli Manning won the MVP in Super Bowl XLII, but that was more of a product of giving the MVP to the quarterback because there was nobody else who really earned it.  The MVPs in that game should have been the entire Giant defense, and expect more of the same this year.  Throughout the playoffs, the Giants have succeeded with strong running game and defense, a Tom Coughlin staple.  That's how they were able to beat the top 2 seeds in the NFC on the road, both of whom had high octane offenses that could chew up lots of yards in short periods of time.  This game against the Patriots will be more of the same.  All they have to do to look for inspiration is go back to 2007.  They got pressure on Brady and controlled the clock.  Even when the Patriots scored, they did not start to panic and go pass-whacky, they stuck to the game plan, and that frustrated the Patriots even more because they got used to teams resorting to the pass early in games.  The Giants simply won't do that.  I'll have more Super Bowl analysis over the next two weeks.  No, I don't have another Super Bowl preview week planned, but I will be bringing back everyone's favorite...the prop bet forecast!  Stay tuned. 

Monday, January 16, 2012

Divisional Playoffs Recap

Happy MLK Day, blogosphere!  I hope you are all enjoying your bonus Monday off (unless of course you do not, in which case, keep working hard).  Anyway, this past weekend featured what many call the best weekend of football on the calendar: the Divisional Playoffs...

...and the weekend lived up to the billing. 

All of the games (ok...maybe 3 out of the 4) were exciting, close, competitive, and went down to the very bitter end.  The fourth game, Denver at New England, seemed to also be competitive on paper, especially with the way Tim Tebow dismantled Pittsburgh last week, but Brady, Gronk, & co quickly put that Cinderella story back into the pumpkin carriage with a 45-10 steamrolling.  What is up with Rob Gronkowski?  Where did this guy come from?  He might be the best pass catching tight end in the history of the league.  I know, I know, before you make acclamations like that, you have to do apples to apples comparisons with the likes of Tony Gonzales, Kellen Winslow, and the like, but how can you ignore the production of this guy throughout the season?  On Saturday, he had 3 touchdowns, in the first half!  And these were not easy TDs, these were all-out, horizontal to the ground, nobody else can catch it except Gronk types of TDs.  Needless to say, on the MIISFFL front, JP will be keeping Gronkowski for the 2012 season.  As for the Tim Tebow experience, it ended with a resounding thud.  I know, there probably was no way the Broncos were going to win regardless of how Tebow did, but many thought that given the way Tebow was playing lately, and considering how bad the Patriots D has been all season, at least the Broncos would be able to go point for point with the Pats.  They didn't even come close.  Their lone touchdown came after a Brady interception deep in Patriots territory.  After that, 3 and out, 3 and out, and another 3 and out came and went.  By the time the 3rd quarter came around, everyone was wondering when Ryan Mallet would be entering for New England.

Elsewhere, the games were far more competitive.  The first game on Saturday might have been an instant classic, at least the last 5 minutes anyway.  Considering the way the New Orleans offense has been playing lately, not many gave the 49ers a shot, despite the home game.  It seemed reasonable considering that the Saints put 45 on the Lions in the wild card game.  For 3 and a half quarters, the Saints offense had essentially been stymied, but then Brees and Company got it in gear.  Darren Sproles caught a 44 yard touchdown pass from Brees to put the Saints up 24-23, and at this point you started to think it was over for San Francisco.  Yet, Alex Smith never wavered.  Who would have thought that Alex Smith would have been unflappable in pressure situations?  This is the same Alex Smith who was picked number 1 in 2005...ahead of Aaron Rodgers.  The 49ers looked like they had egg on their face after Rodgers won it all last year and went 15-1 this year, but after Smith scored on a 28 yard scramble to make it 29-23 San Francisco with 2:11 left, a lot of those doubts started to disappear.  2:11 left was a blessing and a curse for New Orleans.  It was a blessing because it was plenty of time to score a touchdown to win.  It was a curse because it was too much time.  Those Saints just score way too fast sometimes.  Jimmy Graham's 66 yard catch, run, and dunk over the goalpost once again put the Saints up.  After the 2-point play made it 32-29, once again you thought that the Saints had it.  Enter Vernon Davis.  Vernon, the Terp, made two huge catches on the last 49er possession, including a 14-yard score reminiscent of Terrell Owens big catch to beat Green Bay in the playoffs back in 1998.  Vernon even cried like Owens did.  Final score: San Francisco 36 New Orleans 32. 

The state of Maryland was giddy about the Ravens first home playoff game in 5 years.  Well, we have to withstand another week of Purple Friday as the Ravens took care of buisness against a plucky, but ultimately overmatched Houston squad 20-13.  Like most Baltimore playoff games, it begins and ends with their defense.  The name of the game in this one was bend but don't break as Arian Foster got his, to the tune of 132 yards and a touchdown.  Foster was the first 100-yard rusher the Ravens have ever allowed in a playoff game.  This raises questions about how much more can this defense do?  They are getting up there in years, and are starting to show some wear and tear.  Ed Reed pulled up lame on a number of occasions, including on the last play of the game.  However, nobody ever doubts their ability to rise to the occasion, as it was Reed's interception inside of 2 minutes that effectively ended the game.  Offensively, the Ravens were able to move the ball well, like Houston, but with the exception of the first quarter, seemed to bog down in opposition territory, settling for field goals or punting.  Against New England, Baltimore has to exploit the Patriots' inferior pass defense, something the Fightin' Tebows just could not do.  Baltimore is much better than Denver in the passing game, but they have to prepare themselves to go point for point with Brady's offense.  Bending but not breaking may work against the Houston Texans, but the New England Patriots and Gronkowski are a totally different beast.  If they can take Gronk out of the game, and force somebody else to step it up, they stand a fightin' chance in Foxboro.

In what was probably the biggest shocker of the weekend, the New York Giants upset the #1 seed in the NFC, thanks in no small part to a completed Hail Mary pass from Eli Manning to Hakeem Nicks to end the first half.  Most pundits will focus on the emotional and strategic fallout from the Hail Mary, but really where this game won was in the trenches.  The Giants were able to do what no other team was able to do all season...except for the Kansas City Chiefs: get significant pressure on Rodgers.  Like any good quarterback, Rodgers works best when he was a solid pocket to step into and survey the field.  It is kind of assumed that he will always have this kind of pocket.  I don't care how good the quarterback is, if he's looking up into the lights, he can't beat anybody.  Jason Pierre-Paul, Justin Tuck, Osi Umenyiora, and Matthias Kiwanuka wreaked havoc in the Green Bay backfield all night.  Rodgers turned the ball over twice, and a crucial turnover by Ryan Grant late in the game set up the final Giants touchdown to make the score 37-20.  Green Bay's offense succeeded during the regular season in no small part because of their ball security.  However, 4 turnovers in this game proved to be the difference.  The Hail Mary didn't help, but if Green Bay could have protected the football more, there is no reason why they should not have won this game.  In any event, the Giants now go to San Francisco for another rematch from the regular season.  San Francisco won 27-20 back in the November, but both teams are on a roll, back then, the Giants were not.  Expect two good ones next week.

Monday, January 24, 2011

In Defense of Jay Cutler?

There has been lots of speculation in the last 24 hours regarding the health of Jay Cutler's left knee.  Today, an MRI revealed that Cutler does in fact have an MCL sprain.  The reason this is newsworth is because of when Cutler was pulled out of the NFC Championship game against Green Bay...trailing 14-0 after the first possession of the third quarter.  I had noted during my blog session yesterday that if Cutler had been playing like he did against Seattle, there was no way that he would have been pulled.  The knee injury was an excuse, and I (as well as others) felt vindicated when we saw Cutler laughing on the sideline, without a noticable limp, at least from the untrained eye.  Caleb Hanie nearly was able to bring the Bears back as Green Bay could not finish off the Bears despite their obvious superiority in a number of areas. 

Today's MRI perhaps ought to quiet some of Cutler's critics, but that does not all of a sudden mean we should have a wave of sympathy for him.  There have been plenty of opinions on whether or not Cutler should have toughed it out anyway, since it was the conference championship game.  Several players noted (either live or via the now ubiquitous Twitter) that a simple sore knee would not have kept them out of the game.  However, Cutler's Bears teammates were much more willing to give him the benefit of the doubt, claiming Cutler was tough enough.  It had to be a serious injury to force him out of the game.  Other outside the Bears were not so forgiving.  Darnell Dockett and Maurice Jones Drew essentiall said (via Twitter of course) that they would have toughed it out.  Jerry Angleo (Bears owner) took somewhat of a pot shot at the union because of these comments.  Angelo said to ESPN (see link above), "I think it's crap.  I thought they were a union. If that's the way they unionize themselves, they got bigger issues than the one that they have with the owners. I'm very disappointed. That, to me, is dirty poor."  This certainly is something to follow as the CBA talks come to a head in February. 

Here are the facts.  Jay Cutler did not play well yesterday.  He was not going to give the Bears the best chance to win, plain and simple.  It's a pretty safe assumption that his knee might have had something to do with it.  I'm not questioning his toughness, but in the NFL, your reputation precedes you.  Cutler throughout the years has been one of the least likable characters in the league.  He essentially forced his way out of Denver after the Broncos hired Josh McDaniels (perhaps he knew something at the time we didn't) and didn't exactly hide his emotions about it.  Had he been a little more magnanimous in his handling of those kinds of situations (a la Donovan McNabb), perhaps he would have received a little easier treatment from the media over the last 24 hours.  I'm not fan of the media, but I don't feel like a mea culpa is in order here.  Cutler did this to himself because of his past attitudes.  Lovie Smith has every right to defend him (as well he should), and I am willing to concede that Cutler was genuinely hurt and could not continue in the game against the Packers, but if he (or the Bears) are supposed to think that everyone should start feeling sorry for him, they got another thought coming.  I'm not condoning comments like those from Dockett or Jones-Drew, but I get the sense that the Bears and Cutler are looking for an apology, and I don't feel like they really deserve one.

Michael Wilbon writes an excellent piece on the Cutler issue today.  He does not doubt for one second that Cutler was legitimately injured, but when your past (and present) clearly shows a lack of heart, you're not going to get any sympathy from many people.  He even notes that Cutler did not appear to be counseling Todd Collins or Caleb Hanie after they had entered the game.  That does not look good. 

On the other side of the coin, you look at Aaron Rodgers, who went from projected #1 overall pick to just being lucky to get out of the green room in the first round.  He was the consummate teammate, paitently waiting his turn behind a Brett Favre who just wouldn't go away.  When he finally got his shot, he delivered, with a playoff berth in only his second season, and now a trip to the Super Bowl in his third.  Jay Cutler is still young, he is a very good quarterback.  He has all the physical tools: arm strength, accuracy, and decision making, but if he wants to elevate his game to the elite status that Aaron Rodgers has in just 3 years, he need just watch some film of Brett Favre's faithful former understudy.

Sunday, January 16, 2011

DIvisional Playoffs Recap

Here is a quick take on the results of the divisional playoffs this weekend:

Game 1: Pittsburgh 31 Baltimore 24:
Baltimore squandered a golden opportunity here.  Pittsburgh was far and away their biggest nemesis in the playoffs.  Both teams played similar, physical styles.  You had to figure the winner of this game would feel pretty good against a finesse time like New England in the AFC title game (ummmmmmm.........see below).  Given the prior bad blood between these two, you had to figure a 12 round slobberknocker was in store.  Oddly enough, more points were scored in this game than in the first two games between these two combined (55 to 54).  Despite this, defense ruled the day with 5 total turnovers and 31 points scored off of those turnovers.  The difference was the second half, as Baltimore lost their composure on offense and things started to snowball (which usually happens with a turnover laden game).  Baltimore held a 21-7 lead, but a Ray Rice fumble deep in Baltimore territory gave Pittsbugh a chance for a quick strike that made it 21-14.  Ryan Clark's pick of Flacco 2 drives later set Pittsburgh up for the tying score.  One more Flacco fumble set up a Shaun Suisham field goal that gave Pittsburgh their first lead since 7-0.  Meanwhile, while the Ravens were tripping all over themselves, the Steelers were steady.  They made their mistakes in the first half, allowing Baltimore to build their lead, but as the tide started the turn in the 3rd quarter, they took settled down.  They took advantaged of opporutnites provided by takeaways from their defense and did not give the ball away themselves.  In the end, the Ravens offense could not get back in gear.  Neither could Pittsburgh, but a long pass to Antonio Brown on 3rd and 19 down to the Baltimore 4 set up Pittsburgh for what proved to be the winning points. 

Friday, January 14, 2011

Reggie Jackson puts Cromartie in his place

In case you didn't hear, the Jets' Antonio Cromartie used a dirty word when asked what he thought of Tom Brady in the lead up to the Jets-Patriots playoff game this weekend.  Apparently, everybody's got an opinion, including former World Series MVP Reggie Jackson who basically told Cromartie to just shut up. 

It's pretty simple really.  To summarize what Jackson said, Brady can do basically whatever he wants to you...you being the Jets...because he's got 3 Super Bowl rings and 2 MVPs.  What do you have, Antonio?  Don't answer that.  You want him to not point at your bench after throwing a TD pass?  Make sure that that particular TD pass doesn't make the score 38-3 Patriots. 

If the Jets win on Sunday, well then all bets are off.

Wednesday, January 12, 2011

Archives: The Second Team

This piece deals with my antipathy toward rooting for any other NFL team besides the Washington Redskins...even if workplace etiquette would dictate otherwise (from January 2010)...

State of the NFL

Usually, Roger Goodell takes care of this during Super Bowl week, but with the steady stream of headlines in the last few months about how both owners and players are posturing in advance of a potential lockout, now seems like a good time to address the state of the league.

Why is the NFL preparing to lock out the players union? This reeks eerily similar to the infamous NHL lockout and lost season of 2004-2005. During that entire ordeal, Gary Bettman preached "cost certainty." While the NFL is not using those exact words, if your read Greg Aiello's piece on ESPN.com, you certainly get the sense that cost certainty is what he is preaching. What the NHL was ultimately after was a salary cap. The players wouldn't budge, and the end result was not pretty for the sport of hockey. Now, thanks to the likes of Alex Ovechkin and even Sidney Crosby (gag me), that sport has enjoyed a very nice rebound. Events like the 2011 Winter Classic (take that Pittsburgh...HA!) will ensure that hockey has a strong future. Nevertheless, a lost season is a lost season, and the NFL...the golden goose of professional sports leagues...is staring straight down the barrel of one. My take on a couple key issues after the jump.