OK, before I get into this piece about the upcoming start of free agency and the end of the NFL's longest work stoppage in history, just a few personal updates. For those of you on Facebook (thanks, Carol...I think?), I was struck in the face with an aluminum softball bat while playing catcher on Sunday. I needed 9 stitches to close the cut. I am fine and no worse for wear, but I'll have a nice shiner for a few days after I get the stitches out on Friday. This was the first time in my life that I ever needed stitches, and it was a little scary for a little bit there, but thanks for all of the encouragement over the last 36 hours.
Alright, onto the featured article of the day. IT'S OVER!!!!!! Yes, after a 132 day stalemate, the players executive committee ratified unanimously the CBA approved by the owners on Thursday. With that approval, the NFL lifted the lockout immediately, opening team facilities to the league's 1900 players. The league has posted a timeline for when certain events that occur over the course of an entire offseason can occur in the span of 1 week. The Hall of Fame Game will be the only casualty of the preseason. Every other preseason game will go on as scheduled. Here's how it will go down:
Today-Facilities open to players. Teams can negotiate with, but not sign, veteran free agents. Teams can sign draft picks and undrated rookies.
Wednesday through Sunday-Training camps can open for teams 15 days before their first preseason game. 10 teams each open Wednesday through Friday, 2 on Sunday. The Redskins open on Thursday.
Friday-Teams can begin signing free agents starting at 6PM.
August 4-League-imposed deadline for the NFLPA to recertify as a union and ratify the CBA.
September 4-Menace II Sobriety Fantasy Football League Draft
September 8-Opening match of the NFL Season between Saints and Packers
A very important date on that calendar is August 4, a week from Thursday. By then camps will have long since opened, but at this moment, the NFLPA is still not a union. One of the last minute concessions by the owners was to allow the league year to start without formal recertification. There are still several outstanding issues that legally cannot be agreed upon in a CBA so long as the NFLPA is not a union. This include things like drug testing, player safety rules, etc. They say that formal recertification is just a formality. Emphasis on that they say.....
Assuming that the August 4 day comes and goes quietly, the next week will be a 3-ring circus of transaction activities that ordinarily take place over the course of 5 months. Some potential trades to keep an eye on will be what the Eagles do with Kevin Kolb. Rumor has it that he's destined for Arizona. Santonio Holmes is a very attractive free agent for teams like the Redskins...who always seem to have the money to pay for them.
Some highlights of the deal for you:
-Rosters expand to 90 players in camp. Veterans don't really like this because there is more competition for jobs.
-Rookie contracts are limited to 4 years, with a club option for a 5th on 1st round picks only. Salaries compared to past years will be slashed for first round picks especially
-There is no prospect of an expanded season until at least 2013, and only with union approval
-The owners get 53% of the revenue pool, but that does not include any credits off the top for capital projects. Players will never get less than 46% of the revenue pool at any point over the course of the CBA.
-Neither side has an opt out, meaning that there will be labor peace for at least 10 years.
Stay tuned with Caputo's Corner for all of your abbreviated NFL offseason action. This will be the last post I will make with the tag "lockout" on it. Football is back. Let's all move on with our lives!
Showing posts with label CBA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label CBA. Show all posts
Tuesday, July 26, 2011
Friday, July 22, 2011
Owners Approve CBA
In a 31-0 vote (with only the Oakland Raiders abstaining), NFL owners voted to approve a new collective bargaining agreement with the NFL Players Association. This deal provides for labor peace until 2021. However, the lockout has not been lifted yet. This is contingent on the NFLPA reconstituting as an official union (as of now they are still just a trade association) and approving the CBA according to the terms of the deal the owners voted on today.
This of course is not a done deal. DeMaurice Smith has consistenly reiterated that the NFLPA has not agreed to any sort of "deal," despite what the owners may have said. The biggest issue still outstanding is the pending Brady et al vs. NFL antitrust suit. This is a very touchy situation, because there are 10 plaintiffs named in that case and they all want very specific things (or so they say). One of the biggest issues in that case deals with the so-called "franchise tag." For those of you who are not well-learned in NFL contract jargon like I am, there are two kinds of "tags" teams can apply to players who are pending free agents. The franchise tag allows a team to retain the rights to a player whos contract has expired and who otherwise would become an unrestricted free agent. If a team applies the franchise tag, they retain exclusive negotiating rights with the player, or they can trade him. If the two sides cannot agree to a contract, the player in question signs a 1-year tender which would give him a salary equal to the average of the top 5 salaries of all players at that particular position. Each team only has 1 franchise tag they can use. The other type of tag is a "transition tag." This is similar to the franchise tag except that the salary would be the average of the top 10 salaries at that postion, and the team does not get exclusive negotiating rights. They only have right of first refusal and would get draft pick compensation should another team sign that player away. Each team only gets one transition tag to go along with the franchise tag. The Brady et al case attempted to give the plaintiffs a lifetime exemption from the franchise tag (similar to to the plaintiffs in Reggie White's lawsuit against the league in 1993). That will not happen, but the owners' attempt to negotiate 3 additional transition tags for players did not happen either.
The lockout has claimed its next victim. The NFL has announced that despite the progress in negotiations, the Hall of Fame game has been cancelled. However, if the players approve the CBA by Tuesday (the date the owners gave them if they want to start the season on time), training camp will open for all teams on August 1st and the preseason will otherwise be played as scheduled.
If I were DeMaurice Smith, I'd be telling the "union" to sign onto this deal and get on with the season. The public (whoever is left anyway) is sick of all of the posturing and legal wrangling that has gone on since March. At the end of the day, these guys are multimillionaires. The owners have agreed to a CBA that they negotiated. I understand that they want a deal that's fair to them and the owners opted out of the previous agreement that the players thought was agreeable to them (this deal if approved would have no opt-out provisions). Here's what they have to ask themselves? Are they really worse off now than they were under the old deal. If the answer is no, then they should just make themselves a union again and agree to the deal so we can get on with our lives.
Then again, you have guys like Josh who are praying really hard that the deal falls to pieces and the NFL as we know it ceases to exist. He's an Eagles fan. If I were an Eagles fan, I'd wish the league would cease to exist too.
This of course is not a done deal. DeMaurice Smith has consistenly reiterated that the NFLPA has not agreed to any sort of "deal," despite what the owners may have said. The biggest issue still outstanding is the pending Brady et al vs. NFL antitrust suit. This is a very touchy situation, because there are 10 plaintiffs named in that case and they all want very specific things (or so they say). One of the biggest issues in that case deals with the so-called "franchise tag." For those of you who are not well-learned in NFL contract jargon like I am, there are two kinds of "tags" teams can apply to players who are pending free agents. The franchise tag allows a team to retain the rights to a player whos contract has expired and who otherwise would become an unrestricted free agent. If a team applies the franchise tag, they retain exclusive negotiating rights with the player, or they can trade him. If the two sides cannot agree to a contract, the player in question signs a 1-year tender which would give him a salary equal to the average of the top 5 salaries of all players at that particular position. Each team only has 1 franchise tag they can use. The other type of tag is a "transition tag." This is similar to the franchise tag except that the salary would be the average of the top 10 salaries at that postion, and the team does not get exclusive negotiating rights. They only have right of first refusal and would get draft pick compensation should another team sign that player away. Each team only gets one transition tag to go along with the franchise tag. The Brady et al case attempted to give the plaintiffs a lifetime exemption from the franchise tag (similar to to the plaintiffs in Reggie White's lawsuit against the league in 1993). That will not happen, but the owners' attempt to negotiate 3 additional transition tags for players did not happen either.
The lockout has claimed its next victim. The NFL has announced that despite the progress in negotiations, the Hall of Fame game has been cancelled. However, if the players approve the CBA by Tuesday (the date the owners gave them if they want to start the season on time), training camp will open for all teams on August 1st and the preseason will otherwise be played as scheduled.
If I were DeMaurice Smith, I'd be telling the "union" to sign onto this deal and get on with the season. The public (whoever is left anyway) is sick of all of the posturing and legal wrangling that has gone on since March. At the end of the day, these guys are multimillionaires. The owners have agreed to a CBA that they negotiated. I understand that they want a deal that's fair to them and the owners opted out of the previous agreement that the players thought was agreeable to them (this deal if approved would have no opt-out provisions). Here's what they have to ask themselves? Are they really worse off now than they were under the old deal. If the answer is no, then they should just make themselves a union again and agree to the deal so we can get on with our lives.
Then again, you have guys like Josh who are praying really hard that the deal falls to pieces and the NFL as we know it ceases to exist. He's an Eagles fan. If I were an Eagles fan, I'd wish the league would cease to exist too.
Wednesday, July 13, 2011
The NFL is Getting Close...
When I started this blog back in January, in my mind, I had three main content focuses:
-NFL and College Football
-Science, STEM, and Education
-Any other topics that interest me and are worthy of me writing about them
Admittedly, the first bullet item was what was going to dominate the blog. I am a huge football fan, and I try to pay attention to the goings on during the offseason. Most people tune out and focus on other sports during the offseason, or no sports at all. When I started the blog, we were neck deep in the playoffs. I even dedicated an entire week to playing around with various aspects of the Super Bowl. So, can you imagine how it made me feel inside when for the last 5 and a half months, my football content consisted of mostly analysis of labor law? Now, I know that without football, the world will go on. Clearly, I have dedicated a significant amount of content to other areas besides sports. Nevertheless, I crave football. Saturdays and Sundays in the Fall are usually filled with touchdown celebrations, "C'mon Mans," and flying prolate spheroids.
I say this because finally...FINALLY...we might be reaching a conclusion. FINALLY, we might be reaching labor harmony. FINALLY, my blog will not be an analysis of labor law (but if you really are into that stuff, check out Rob's feed down in the blog roll), but rather a critique of what's actually happening on the gridiron. I am an X's and O's kind of guy. I can actually tell you what the difference is between an off-tackle play and the counter trey (it has to do with the direction of blocking on the offensive line and the way the running back cuts after receiving the handoff). I can't wait until we actually get to see some real action on the field so I can talk about players, coaches, strategy, fantasy stats, and playoff scenarios. I'll even talk/vent about how good/bad the Redskins are/were...or something like that. Menace II Sobriety has our draft scheduled for Labor Day weekend, so that will be on the agenda as well.
However, there is no deal done yet. The magic date is July 21st. That is when the next round of owners meetings will be held, and where (theoreticaly) the owners will vote on ratification of a new CBA. The latest round of negotiations have brought the two sides closer than they have ever been since the lockout began, but it's not over yet. Several players are now saying that they have conceded as much as they're willing to concede. If a CBA is to be ratified on July 21st, an agreement in principle has to be done well before then. It appears as if the final sticking point is the rookie wage scale. The two sides are pretty much in cahoots on how to split the $9 billion (which was the biggest issue from the beginning). However, rookie salaries can still be a major issue as draft picks have yet to even begin negotiations, let alone sign contracts. The good news is that, as part of these negotiations, the two sides have essentially agreed upon "transition rules" which will govern how free agency, trades, and rookie negotiations (both for drafted and undrafted players) will work. There seems to be agreement here, except when it comes to a deadline on when rookies can have contracts signed, but this goes back to the wage scale issue. If the wage scale gets approved, then Cam Newton is looking at 4 or 5 years around $50 million. Players only want 4 year contracts for top picks so that they can test the free agency market sooner. Owners would obviously like a little more control over the top picks and sign rookies to 5 year contracts. We shall see. It would be a shame that the two sides have come this far in negotiations...only to see a deal fall apart over one issue like this.
As far as the season structure, assuming the deal is ratified on July 21st, there should not be many changes. Many teams have already cancelled off-site training camps (such as the Ravens and Giants), but assuming a deal is in place, they can have a full training camp. The problem is that with no offseason work, the coaches are starting from scratch. You can't tell me that players running their own "OTA" sessions are doing anything to install playbooks, and even if they were, coaches would be foolish to assume that the players are as knowledgeable as they should be. As a result, the Hall of Fame Game would still be in serious jeopardy. The Rams and Bears open camp on the 22nd, but given the fact that they had absolutely zero offseason work (and literally no time at all to make roster moves prior to that), I'm fairly certain that the teams will not want to play the game. Other than that, you should see training camp and the preseason go on as scheduled. What will be interesting to see is how much starters play during the presason. Ordinarily, starters really only see significant work in the third preseason game. However, given the rust from the offseason, I would not be surprised to see starters play significantly more minutes in the first two preseason games. The fourth preseason game will still be a junk game for 3rd and 4th stringers to avoid being cut.
Hopefully, my next post on this subject will be something along the lines of "DEAL DONE!!! FOOTBALL IN 2011!!!" However, I have taken a "I'll believe it when I see it" approach for the entire offseason, and I still feel this way, despite the apparent progress. I do sincerely hope that a deal is done by July 21st (if not sooner), and I can soon start discussing obscure training camp themes such as "The Oklahoma Drill," and "The Turk."
-NFL and College Football
-Science, STEM, and Education
-Any other topics that interest me and are worthy of me writing about them
Admittedly, the first bullet item was what was going to dominate the blog. I am a huge football fan, and I try to pay attention to the goings on during the offseason. Most people tune out and focus on other sports during the offseason, or no sports at all. When I started the blog, we were neck deep in the playoffs. I even dedicated an entire week to playing around with various aspects of the Super Bowl. So, can you imagine how it made me feel inside when for the last 5 and a half months, my football content consisted of mostly analysis of labor law? Now, I know that without football, the world will go on. Clearly, I have dedicated a significant amount of content to other areas besides sports. Nevertheless, I crave football. Saturdays and Sundays in the Fall are usually filled with touchdown celebrations, "C'mon Mans," and flying prolate spheroids.
I say this because finally...FINALLY...we might be reaching a conclusion. FINALLY, we might be reaching labor harmony. FINALLY, my blog will not be an analysis of labor law (but if you really are into that stuff, check out Rob's feed down in the blog roll), but rather a critique of what's actually happening on the gridiron. I am an X's and O's kind of guy. I can actually tell you what the difference is between an off-tackle play and the counter trey (it has to do with the direction of blocking on the offensive line and the way the running back cuts after receiving the handoff). I can't wait until we actually get to see some real action on the field so I can talk about players, coaches, strategy, fantasy stats, and playoff scenarios. I'll even talk/vent about how good/bad the Redskins are/were...or something like that. Menace II Sobriety has our draft scheduled for Labor Day weekend, so that will be on the agenda as well.
However, there is no deal done yet. The magic date is July 21st. That is when the next round of owners meetings will be held, and where (theoreticaly) the owners will vote on ratification of a new CBA. The latest round of negotiations have brought the two sides closer than they have ever been since the lockout began, but it's not over yet. Several players are now saying that they have conceded as much as they're willing to concede. If a CBA is to be ratified on July 21st, an agreement in principle has to be done well before then. It appears as if the final sticking point is the rookie wage scale. The two sides are pretty much in cahoots on how to split the $9 billion (which was the biggest issue from the beginning). However, rookie salaries can still be a major issue as draft picks have yet to even begin negotiations, let alone sign contracts. The good news is that, as part of these negotiations, the two sides have essentially agreed upon "transition rules" which will govern how free agency, trades, and rookie negotiations (both for drafted and undrafted players) will work. There seems to be agreement here, except when it comes to a deadline on when rookies can have contracts signed, but this goes back to the wage scale issue. If the wage scale gets approved, then Cam Newton is looking at 4 or 5 years around $50 million. Players only want 4 year contracts for top picks so that they can test the free agency market sooner. Owners would obviously like a little more control over the top picks and sign rookies to 5 year contracts. We shall see. It would be a shame that the two sides have come this far in negotiations...only to see a deal fall apart over one issue like this.
As far as the season structure, assuming the deal is ratified on July 21st, there should not be many changes. Many teams have already cancelled off-site training camps (such as the Ravens and Giants), but assuming a deal is in place, they can have a full training camp. The problem is that with no offseason work, the coaches are starting from scratch. You can't tell me that players running their own "OTA" sessions are doing anything to install playbooks, and even if they were, coaches would be foolish to assume that the players are as knowledgeable as they should be. As a result, the Hall of Fame Game would still be in serious jeopardy. The Rams and Bears open camp on the 22nd, but given the fact that they had absolutely zero offseason work (and literally no time at all to make roster moves prior to that), I'm fairly certain that the teams will not want to play the game. Other than that, you should see training camp and the preseason go on as scheduled. What will be interesting to see is how much starters play during the presason. Ordinarily, starters really only see significant work in the third preseason game. However, given the rust from the offseason, I would not be surprised to see starters play significantly more minutes in the first two preseason games. The fourth preseason game will still be a junk game for 3rd and 4th stringers to avoid being cut.
Hopefully, my next post on this subject will be something along the lines of "DEAL DONE!!! FOOTBALL IN 2011!!!" However, I have taken a "I'll believe it when I see it" approach for the entire offseason, and I still feel this way, despite the apparent progress. I do sincerely hope that a deal is done by July 21st (if not sooner), and I can soon start discussing obscure training camp themes such as "The Oklahoma Drill," and "The Turk."
Friday, July 8, 2011
Caputo's Corner Goes to the Beach...
This weekend, Caputo's Corner will be in Ocean City, MD celebrating Summer with Menace II Sobriety. The team will be getting a condo on 83rd Street, but I will be staying with my Aunt in Ocean View, DE...about 15 minutes away from the guys. Our agenda will include a trip to the Ocean City Boardwalk, minigolf, Seacrets (sssshhhhh.......), and of course, the beach. I will be returning on Sunday since I am currently neck-deep in the Maryland STEM ePortfolio Project Summer Academy 2011. Monday is Geocaching Day...SWEET! Should be a fun weekend all around. I'll have a full report upon my return.
In other news, it might actually be happening, but we shall see. Players and owners in the NFL Lockout mess are in the middle of marathon negotiations trying to hammer out a CBA before the Bears and Rams open training camp on July 22nd. Right now, there seems to be consensus on rookie wage scales and a league calendar for when the lockout is lifted, and the two sides are close on how to split the $9.3 billion in revenues. Right now, the talk is that the split will be 60/40 in favor of the owners, but the owners will not take any money off the top for capital improvements as they did under the prior deal. The sticking points right now include how to deal with free agency after the lockout is lifted. Owners would like right of first refusal for up to 3 free agents on the roster. Players don't like that since they feel like top players might get weaseled out of top dollar. Nevertheless, the two sides are closer now than they ever have been, and right now the goal is to have a basic framework for the CBA finished by tomorrow. The two sides have committed to working through the weekend to get a deal done, despite federal magistrate Arthur Boylan (the mediator) taking a vacation day on Saturday. The goal is to have a deal done by next week. I'll believe it when I see it, but Josh might be lifting his moratorium on all things football very soon.
In other news, it might actually be happening, but we shall see. Players and owners in the NFL Lockout mess are in the middle of marathon negotiations trying to hammer out a CBA before the Bears and Rams open training camp on July 22nd. Right now, there seems to be consensus on rookie wage scales and a league calendar for when the lockout is lifted, and the two sides are close on how to split the $9.3 billion in revenues. Right now, the talk is that the split will be 60/40 in favor of the owners, but the owners will not take any money off the top for capital improvements as they did under the prior deal. The sticking points right now include how to deal with free agency after the lockout is lifted. Owners would like right of first refusal for up to 3 free agents on the roster. Players don't like that since they feel like top players might get weaseled out of top dollar. Nevertheless, the two sides are closer now than they ever have been, and right now the goal is to have a basic framework for the CBA finished by tomorrow. The two sides have committed to working through the weekend to get a deal done, despite federal magistrate Arthur Boylan (the mediator) taking a vacation day on Saturday. The goal is to have a deal done by next week. I'll believe it when I see it, but Josh might be lifting his moratorium on all things football very soon.
Monday, June 20, 2011
Lockout Updates-Owners Bickering Among Themselves
So much for progress?
It appears we are not quite as close to a new CBA as we thought we were. Heeding Judge Kermit Bye's warning that neither side will like the 8th Circuit's ruling to block the injunction issued by Judge Susan Nelson in Minnesota, owners and players have made quite significant progress (secret meetings usually produce positive results) towards a new CBA. However, some of the owners who were unsatisfied with the previous CBA (**cough cough ** Ralph Wilson **cough cough**) are starting to rear their naysaying heads yet again. The owners have called for at least one day of internal meetings where they will discuss whether or not the CBA currently being negotiated actually addresses the orginial issues the owners had with the first CBA. Mostly, the owners feel like the CBA favors the players too much (of course) in that it gives them too much of a percentage of the league's revenues.
It appears as if both sides have made significant progress in addressing the peripheral issues that go into this CBA (rookie wages and retiree benefits...although some hall of famers beg to differ). Nevertheless, the core issue remains how to divide $9 billion in revenues. The owners want at least $2 billion off the top before splitting the rest with the players to cover operational costs. The players believe that $1billion is enough for those costs. Now, the negotiations probably have bridged that gap considerably, but is that enough to satisfy the small market owners who were able to get the league to void the CBA in the first place? One of the purposes of this meeting (allegedly) is to determine if Goodell is actually representing the best interest of the league (i.e. the owners) in negotiations. Hmmm, if I may opine here for a second, it certainly isn't in the best interest of the league to have a prolonged work stoppage, no matter what kind of war chest they may have. If Goodell is honestly negotiating to make sure there is football in 2011, he is negotiating in the best interest of the league. He's not there to negotiate on behalf of Ralph Wilson (did I just say that?).
Owners believe that in order to have a regular training camp and season (at least one that starts on time), a deal must be done by the Fourth of July. However, contingency plans are already in place as many of you probably know. Right now, it looks like the deciding factor in whether or not the season will start on time (if at all) is not what the 8th Circuit says...we're beyond that it seems. It is whether or not the Jerry Jones and Daniel Snyders can tell the Ralph Wilsons and Al Davis's to swallow a deal they didn't want in the first place.
It appears we are not quite as close to a new CBA as we thought we were. Heeding Judge Kermit Bye's warning that neither side will like the 8th Circuit's ruling to block the injunction issued by Judge Susan Nelson in Minnesota, owners and players have made quite significant progress (secret meetings usually produce positive results) towards a new CBA. However, some of the owners who were unsatisfied with the previous CBA (**cough cough ** Ralph Wilson **cough cough**) are starting to rear their naysaying heads yet again. The owners have called for at least one day of internal meetings where they will discuss whether or not the CBA currently being negotiated actually addresses the orginial issues the owners had with the first CBA. Mostly, the owners feel like the CBA favors the players too much (of course) in that it gives them too much of a percentage of the league's revenues.
It appears as if both sides have made significant progress in addressing the peripheral issues that go into this CBA (rookie wages and retiree benefits...although some hall of famers beg to differ). Nevertheless, the core issue remains how to divide $9 billion in revenues. The owners want at least $2 billion off the top before splitting the rest with the players to cover operational costs. The players believe that $1billion is enough for those costs. Now, the negotiations probably have bridged that gap considerably, but is that enough to satisfy the small market owners who were able to get the league to void the CBA in the first place? One of the purposes of this meeting (allegedly) is to determine if Goodell is actually representing the best interest of the league (i.e. the owners) in negotiations. Hmmm, if I may opine here for a second, it certainly isn't in the best interest of the league to have a prolonged work stoppage, no matter what kind of war chest they may have. If Goodell is honestly negotiating to make sure there is football in 2011, he is negotiating in the best interest of the league. He's not there to negotiate on behalf of Ralph Wilson (did I just say that?).
Owners believe that in order to have a regular training camp and season (at least one that starts on time), a deal must be done by the Fourth of July. However, contingency plans are already in place as many of you probably know. Right now, it looks like the deciding factor in whether or not the season will start on time (if at all) is not what the 8th Circuit says...we're beyond that it seems. It is whether or not the Jerry Jones and Daniel Snyders can tell the Ralph Wilsons and Al Davis's to swallow a deal they didn't want in the first place.
Wednesday, June 8, 2011
Owners and Players in "Secret Meetings"
So the owners and players "union" are meeting after all. Historically in pro sports labor, when two sides engage in "secret" negotiations, that usually means that something is getting done. They want to avoid outside distractions so they keep the meetings and their contents under wraps. They are still under a gag order by the magistrate judge who is mediating (as per Judge Nelson's order back from April). Nevertheless, they were meeting in Chicago last week and in an "undisclosed" location this week. Both sides are denying that negotiations are taking place, but Greg Aiello, league spokesman, admitted that "confidential" negotiations were underway and would continue.
What does all this mean? In the short term, it doesn't mean much. The two sides had been "negotiating" since before the lockout even started, and as far as we know, are still miles apart on how to split $9 billion (as well as the whole host of issues revolving around rookie pay scales and retiree benefits). The league seems content that an 18 game schedule is off the table for at least another couple years. However, the fact that the negotiations are "secret" or "confidential" (whatever word you prefer), indicates to me that something serious is going on. How serious? I don't know. I am still of the belief that both sides want the 8th Circuit Court to rule on the permanent stay of Judge Nelson's injunction order first before either side makes a move at the table. According to Judge Kermit Bye (the one judge who sided with the players in the 3 judge panel issuing the temporary stay), neither side will be happy if the Court has to make a ruling before any sort of deal is struck. Nelson said essentially the same thing in Minnesota, but eventually sided with the players.
The difference between the 8th Circuit Court in St. Louis and Nelson's federal district court in Minnesota is that the 8th Circuit has traditionally been more pro-buisness than the district court. Therefore, they would be much more receptive to the league's unfair labor practices claims than Judge Nelson or Judge Doty in Minnesota. It is impossible, however, to collectively bargain if there is no organized union against whom to bargain (as the NFLPA has constantly reminded us since March 11th). Perhaps the players realize that as long as the lean in the 8th Circuit favors the owners, their days are numbered since there is absolutely NO WAY this gets a Supreme Court nod (and even if it did, the only justice really they have to convince is Kennedy). Therefore, negotiations might be in their best interest. Training camp is supposed to open in less than 2 months, with the first preseason game shortly thereafter. It is getting dangerously close to crunch time for the players, who stand to lose the most if no season is played (regardless of any TV warchest the owners have built).
I'll believe a deal is done when I see it. When the 8th Circuit Court rules on the permanent stay of Nelson's injunction (and it will), that will determine the fate of at least the start of the 2011 season. If they rule to permanently stay the injunction, the season at the very least will be delayed. There's no way camps will open in time (barring the miraculous and a CBA being agreed upon between the owners and the pseudo-union). If the injunction is allowed to stand, the league will have to scramble to come up with a set of rules for free agency and other player transactions in the very limited free agency period there will be before camp opens. That does not mean that there will be limited player movement. The moment teams are allowed to make moves, you will see the entire deck shuffled. Then...crickets. Teams have been talking to each other since before the lockout began, so by now, most teams know what they want to do. So they'll do it and not waste any time so that they can have their rosters as much in place as possible before camp.
What does all this mean? In the short term, it doesn't mean much. The two sides had been "negotiating" since before the lockout even started, and as far as we know, are still miles apart on how to split $9 billion (as well as the whole host of issues revolving around rookie pay scales and retiree benefits). The league seems content that an 18 game schedule is off the table for at least another couple years. However, the fact that the negotiations are "secret" or "confidential" (whatever word you prefer), indicates to me that something serious is going on. How serious? I don't know. I am still of the belief that both sides want the 8th Circuit Court to rule on the permanent stay of Judge Nelson's injunction order first before either side makes a move at the table. According to Judge Kermit Bye (the one judge who sided with the players in the 3 judge panel issuing the temporary stay), neither side will be happy if the Court has to make a ruling before any sort of deal is struck. Nelson said essentially the same thing in Minnesota, but eventually sided with the players.
The difference between the 8th Circuit Court in St. Louis and Nelson's federal district court in Minnesota is that the 8th Circuit has traditionally been more pro-buisness than the district court. Therefore, they would be much more receptive to the league's unfair labor practices claims than Judge Nelson or Judge Doty in Minnesota. It is impossible, however, to collectively bargain if there is no organized union against whom to bargain (as the NFLPA has constantly reminded us since March 11th). Perhaps the players realize that as long as the lean in the 8th Circuit favors the owners, their days are numbered since there is absolutely NO WAY this gets a Supreme Court nod (and even if it did, the only justice really they have to convince is Kennedy). Therefore, negotiations might be in their best interest. Training camp is supposed to open in less than 2 months, with the first preseason game shortly thereafter. It is getting dangerously close to crunch time for the players, who stand to lose the most if no season is played (regardless of any TV warchest the owners have built).
I'll believe a deal is done when I see it. When the 8th Circuit Court rules on the permanent stay of Nelson's injunction (and it will), that will determine the fate of at least the start of the 2011 season. If they rule to permanently stay the injunction, the season at the very least will be delayed. There's no way camps will open in time (barring the miraculous and a CBA being agreed upon between the owners and the pseudo-union). If the injunction is allowed to stand, the league will have to scramble to come up with a set of rules for free agency and other player transactions in the very limited free agency period there will be before camp opens. That does not mean that there will be limited player movement. The moment teams are allowed to make moves, you will see the entire deck shuffled. Then...crickets. Teams have been talking to each other since before the lockout began, so by now, most teams know what they want to do. So they'll do it and not waste any time so that they can have their rosters as much in place as possible before camp.
Tuesday, April 26, 2011
Lockout Lifted...but for what?
US District Judge Susan Richard Nelson, in an 89 page ruling yesterday, grated the NFLPA's request for a preliminary injunction, effectively ending the NFL's lockout of the players. What does this mean? In short, chaos.
Pure and utter chaos.
Players are being told by the union/trade association that they can (and should) report to team facilities to start working out. Nevertheless, teams are allowing players in the facilities, but not allowing them to work out. DeMaurice Smith is saying that the league is breaking the "law of the land" by not allowing players to work out. (aside...sorry, DeMaurice, labor law is not the Constitution...end aside). The league has already filed a motion with the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals to issue a stay of Judge Nelson's ruling, which would delay the execution of the injunction. Judge Nelson refused to issue a stay in her courtroom. The ruling was based on Nelson's opinion that the lockout was doing "irreparable harm" to the players association, citing (among other reasons) the short duration of players' careers. Losing one year of work would be extremely detrimental.
So does free agency begin now 2 days before the draft? Can players be traded? The answer is yes, but there are no rules. Under the old CBA rules, players became unrestricted free agents after 6 accrued years of service (4 years before 2010). Players became restricted free agents after 4 (3 years before 2010). There was no salary cap in 2010, but before that year there was the "hardest cap" in pro sports. Players can be traded, but teams are hesitant to do so until there is a new set of rules in place regarding compensation. Teams losing qualifying free agents are usually granted compensatory draft picks. With no CBA, they would be granted nothing.
Ultimately this ruling gets us no closer to resolving the issue. What I feel will ultimately happen is the 2011 season will be played (perhaps on schedule, perhaps not), but will be played with no CBA and no union. Every player will be on his own as far as negotiations. This could be good for somebody like a Peyton Manning or Tom Brady, who could stand to receive a HUGE payday. However, with no salary cap (and likewise no salary floor), players who barely make the 53 man roster will probably not get much of anything. It may even be in their best interests to get cut and pursue other work...
In other football news, so much for that boycott. A record 25 prospects will be at Radio City Music Hall on Thursday for the first round of the NFL Draft, including Texas A&M linebacker Von Miller, the one non-union player named as a plaintiff in the lawsuit in Judge Nelson's court which prompted the preliminary injunction. Miller is a projected top 10 draft pick, so I wonder what the Rog' will think when he gets to shake his hand and give him a jersey and cap... Anyway, the union/trade association has said that they have scheduled a series of events for the players that were not designed to conflict with the NFL's draft schedule. Yeah, right...
The schedule came out last week too...whoopie.....(sarcasm...). The league may be losing in court, but they are very shrewd when it comes to contingencies. They constructed the schedule so that they can delay the start of the season by as many as 3 weeks if needed. This would include eliminating the bye between the conference championships and the Super Bowl, pushing the Super Bowl itself back by a week (the league has book hotels in Indianapolis through the following weekend), and finally, every game in week 3 features two teams playing each other who share a common bye week. That way, if necessary, the league can save a week by simply eliminating byes and making everyone play a full 16 week schedule.
That's your dose of NFL nonsense for now. I'll have more after the draft.
Pure and utter chaos.
Players are being told by the union/trade association that they can (and should) report to team facilities to start working out. Nevertheless, teams are allowing players in the facilities, but not allowing them to work out. DeMaurice Smith is saying that the league is breaking the "law of the land" by not allowing players to work out. (aside...sorry, DeMaurice, labor law is not the Constitution...end aside). The league has already filed a motion with the 8th Circuit Court of Appeals to issue a stay of Judge Nelson's ruling, which would delay the execution of the injunction. Judge Nelson refused to issue a stay in her courtroom. The ruling was based on Nelson's opinion that the lockout was doing "irreparable harm" to the players association, citing (among other reasons) the short duration of players' careers. Losing one year of work would be extremely detrimental.
So does free agency begin now 2 days before the draft? Can players be traded? The answer is yes, but there are no rules. Under the old CBA rules, players became unrestricted free agents after 6 accrued years of service (4 years before 2010). Players became restricted free agents after 4 (3 years before 2010). There was no salary cap in 2010, but before that year there was the "hardest cap" in pro sports. Players can be traded, but teams are hesitant to do so until there is a new set of rules in place regarding compensation. Teams losing qualifying free agents are usually granted compensatory draft picks. With no CBA, they would be granted nothing.
Ultimately this ruling gets us no closer to resolving the issue. What I feel will ultimately happen is the 2011 season will be played (perhaps on schedule, perhaps not), but will be played with no CBA and no union. Every player will be on his own as far as negotiations. This could be good for somebody like a Peyton Manning or Tom Brady, who could stand to receive a HUGE payday. However, with no salary cap (and likewise no salary floor), players who barely make the 53 man roster will probably not get much of anything. It may even be in their best interests to get cut and pursue other work...
In other football news, so much for that boycott. A record 25 prospects will be at Radio City Music Hall on Thursday for the first round of the NFL Draft, including Texas A&M linebacker Von Miller, the one non-union player named as a plaintiff in the lawsuit in Judge Nelson's court which prompted the preliminary injunction. Miller is a projected top 10 draft pick, so I wonder what the Rog' will think when he gets to shake his hand and give him a jersey and cap... Anyway, the union/trade association has said that they have scheduled a series of events for the players that were not designed to conflict with the NFL's draft schedule. Yeah, right...
The schedule came out last week too...whoopie.....(sarcasm...). The league may be losing in court, but they are very shrewd when it comes to contingencies. They constructed the schedule so that they can delay the start of the season by as many as 3 weeks if needed. This would include eliminating the bye between the conference championships and the Super Bowl, pushing the Super Bowl itself back by a week (the league has book hotels in Indianapolis through the following weekend), and finally, every game in week 3 features two teams playing each other who share a common bye week. That way, if necessary, the league can save a week by simply eliminating byes and making everyone play a full 16 week schedule.
That's your dose of NFL nonsense for now. I'll have more after the draft.
Sunday, April 10, 2011
League and "Union" to Reenter Mediation
Judge Susan Nelson in Minnesota has ordered both the NFL and NFLPA to reenter mediated negotiations starting this week. The details of the mediation (where, when, and who will be conducting) remain to be determined, but with this order, the judge in the case is adamantly stating that she does NOT want to rule on the players' request for an injunction if she can avoid it. You see, though, both sides will never admit it, but a ruling on the injunction is EXACTLY what both sides want to have happen before negotiations resume. Obviously, the two sides want different outcomes, but one thing is certain. Nothing will get done until the injunction is ruled upon one way or the other. This "forced mediation" as it is being called really will accomplilsh nothing. This is just the judge's way of trying to avoid making a decision that will be scrutinized for a long time. Eventually she will realize this.
Now, I could be wrong. Perhaps forcing mediation will accomplish something, but there is a fundamental road block here. The union is demanding full financial disclosure from the league. The league claims that they have done that, but the union has not. The league is demanding that the "trade association" reforms as a union (or at least calls itself one) before they engage in collective bargaining (something the league says it really wants to do instead of litigate). So until that difference is resolved, mediated negotiation will accomplish nothing. This judge will have to rule on the injunction eventually. Hopefully she's prepared to live with herself when she does.
Now, I could be wrong. Perhaps forcing mediation will accomplish something, but there is a fundamental road block here. The union is demanding full financial disclosure from the league. The league claims that they have done that, but the union has not. The league is demanding that the "trade association" reforms as a union (or at least calls itself one) before they engage in collective bargaining (something the league says it really wants to do instead of litigate). So until that difference is resolved, mediated negotiation will accomplish nothing. This judge will have to rule on the injunction eventually. Hopefully she's prepared to live with herself when she does.
Monday, April 4, 2011
Mike Vrabel Is a Thief...for you AK
So Mike Vrabel was arrested for theft last night. Of course he spent today apologizing profusely and calling the matter a "miscommunication" and declaring that he will "resolve this matter." We shall see, but Vrabel has been one of the more visible members of the "trade association" during this whole lockout ordeal. He is one of the 10 names in the lawsuit that the "trade association" has brought forth in a Minnesota court. Ever since that suit was filed, there has been nothing but posturing and rhetoric from both sides. The players are crying for full financial disclosure from the owners, and the owners are demanding that the "trade association" refer to itself as a "union" and come back to the table. It's all just a song and dance. Both sides know that nothing will get done until a ruling is made on the injunction. The hearing is on Wednesday. Stay tuned.
In other news, start making your plans now. Mark your territory on Pratt Street because the parade is coming. Yes, blogosphere, the Baltimore Orioles are 4-0!!! From watching the traffic on Facebook, you'd think that they just won the World Series. This is just a typical Baltimore post 1990s pattern. They either start strong and finish weak, or they come out of the gate weak and finish strong in September. I see no reason why this year is any different. Let's say they race out to June in 1st place. They'll be so shocked at seeing themselves at the top of the standings that they'll start to feel complacent, and they'll fall apart. Besides, you know the Sox and Yanks will get their act together at some point. Fellas, this is only April. The hockey playoffs are coming, and that will be diverting my through May and (hopefully) early June.
Speaking of, I just got another great blog idea! Great Moments in Washington Capitals Playoff History. Last week was STEM week. This week is Caps Playoffs week. I'll be back later with our first installment.
In other news, start making your plans now. Mark your territory on Pratt Street because the parade is coming. Yes, blogosphere, the Baltimore Orioles are 4-0!!! From watching the traffic on Facebook, you'd think that they just won the World Series. This is just a typical Baltimore post 1990s pattern. They either start strong and finish weak, or they come out of the gate weak and finish strong in September. I see no reason why this year is any different. Let's say they race out to June in 1st place. They'll be so shocked at seeing themselves at the top of the standings that they'll start to feel complacent, and they'll fall apart. Besides, you know the Sox and Yanks will get their act together at some point. Fellas, this is only April. The hockey playoffs are coming, and that will be diverting my through May and (hopefully) early June.
Speaking of, I just got another great blog idea! Great Moments in Washington Capitals Playoff History. Last week was STEM week. This week is Caps Playoffs week. I'll be back later with our first installment.
Sunday, March 20, 2011
NFL Lockout...No Time to Panic...yet...
As we inch closer to an April 6th Judgement Day on the NFLPA's request for a preliminary injuction in the court of David Doty of Minneapolis, MN, players are preparing themselves for second careers in the event the NFL does not return this August. Usually, players are not allowed to sign pro contracts with other leagues, but since there is no CBA in place (and no union), it is essentially a free for all for these players. Some players are signing with rival football leagues, including practice squad players Troy Bergeron and Rod Windsor who have signed contracts with the Arena Football League.
**Quick aside...in the NFLPA's lawsuit, the players named as being the ones suffering the grievance are Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Peyton Manning, Vincent Jackson, Logan Mankins, Mike Vrabel...and a couple of lesser known names such as Ben Leber and Von Miller (linebacker at Virginia Tech...perhaps I should do a draft profile on him...perhaps not...). I know the names on the lawsuit are mostly symbolic, but seriously, I have a hard time believing that Brady, Brees, and Manning are in any way "grieved" as a result of this lockout. If anything, they would be the LAST people I would put as a plaintiff in this suit. The entire roster of plaintiffs should be the Von Millers, Troy Bergerons and Rod Windsors...end aside**
Anyway, as I noted in one of the items in my A-Z Lockout Guide, rival leagues such as the Arena League, Canadian League, and the UFL once we get closer to Fall stand a huge chance of gaining far more traction in pro football than they otherwise would have because they have no NFL to compete against them. If these leagues can somehow pull off getting A-list names like the ones named as plaintiffs in the lawsuit, their legitimacy would increase exponentially. This is something the NFL must consider as they negotiate. It is not a guarantee, but there is chance that at least some of these billions of dollars in revenues the league is "expecting" would end up going to rival leagues because big-money players gave up on their NFL franchise. I do encourage everyone to read my A-Z Lockout Guide for background on the issues and people in charge of seeing this thing through to an end.
I have one quick note as well on this whole draft boycott idea. What. A. Joke. Seriously, guys, you only get to be drafted once. I understand you want to put on your front of "solidarity" and stick it to the league however you can, but let these kids have their moment. You only get drafted once, and even though they'll be shaking the hand of the eeeeeeeeeeevil commissioner, as soon as it is over, they're in your camp. Sorry, shaking DeMaurice's hand is not the same as shaking the commissioner's on draft day.
Finally today, there is this little submission from Lattanzi Land. Josh is on a self-imposed moratorium from commenting on anything football during the duration of the lockout. I, however, am not. Nevertheless, he found this piece on how the chicken wing industry could potentially suffer if there is no football this Fall. I understand the claim. What goes better on a Sunday afternoon with football than pizza, wings, and beer? 1.25 billion wings were consumed on Super Bowl Sunday alone. However, as long as there is some variation of football to watch, college or otherwise, people will find their reasons to chow down on their chicken wings. I for one, fully intend on purchasing entire farms worth of chickens on Saturdays this fall as we propagate the parking lots at the University of Maryland and FedEx Field when the Terps take on Notre Dame in November. The junk food industry will live on, blogosphere. It most certainly will.
We'll be back later with an update on Round 2 (NOT 3) of FBL 2011.
**Quick aside...in the NFLPA's lawsuit, the players named as being the ones suffering the grievance are Tom Brady, Drew Brees, Peyton Manning, Vincent Jackson, Logan Mankins, Mike Vrabel...and a couple of lesser known names such as Ben Leber and Von Miller (linebacker at Virginia Tech...perhaps I should do a draft profile on him...perhaps not...). I know the names on the lawsuit are mostly symbolic, but seriously, I have a hard time believing that Brady, Brees, and Manning are in any way "grieved" as a result of this lockout. If anything, they would be the LAST people I would put as a plaintiff in this suit. The entire roster of plaintiffs should be the Von Millers, Troy Bergerons and Rod Windsors...end aside**
Anyway, as I noted in one of the items in my A-Z Lockout Guide, rival leagues such as the Arena League, Canadian League, and the UFL once we get closer to Fall stand a huge chance of gaining far more traction in pro football than they otherwise would have because they have no NFL to compete against them. If these leagues can somehow pull off getting A-list names like the ones named as plaintiffs in the lawsuit, their legitimacy would increase exponentially. This is something the NFL must consider as they negotiate. It is not a guarantee, but there is chance that at least some of these billions of dollars in revenues the league is "expecting" would end up going to rival leagues because big-money players gave up on their NFL franchise. I do encourage everyone to read my A-Z Lockout Guide for background on the issues and people in charge of seeing this thing through to an end.
I have one quick note as well on this whole draft boycott idea. What. A. Joke. Seriously, guys, you only get to be drafted once. I understand you want to put on your front of "solidarity" and stick it to the league however you can, but let these kids have their moment. You only get drafted once, and even though they'll be shaking the hand of the eeeeeeeeeeevil commissioner, as soon as it is over, they're in your camp. Sorry, shaking DeMaurice's hand is not the same as shaking the commissioner's on draft day.
Finally today, there is this little submission from Lattanzi Land. Josh is on a self-imposed moratorium from commenting on anything football during the duration of the lockout. I, however, am not. Nevertheless, he found this piece on how the chicken wing industry could potentially suffer if there is no football this Fall. I understand the claim. What goes better on a Sunday afternoon with football than pizza, wings, and beer? 1.25 billion wings were consumed on Super Bowl Sunday alone. However, as long as there is some variation of football to watch, college or otherwise, people will find their reasons to chow down on their chicken wings. I for one, fully intend on purchasing entire farms worth of chickens on Saturdays this fall as we propagate the parking lots at the University of Maryland and FedEx Field when the Terps take on Notre Dame in November. The junk food industry will live on, blogosphere. It most certainly will.
We'll be back later with an update on Round 2 (NOT 3) of FBL 2011.
Saturday, March 12, 2011
NFL Lockout: An A-Z Guide
Here is a little handy-dandy guide to help you understand what to watch for and understand during the upcoming NFL lockout. Will games be lost? What else is there to know. This guide will help you navigate the stormy seas. Enjoy!
A-August
August is when the preseason begins. This is when the league would really start to feel the effects of a work stoppage. Preseason games don't nearly rake in the dollars that regular season games do, but since most teams (like the Redskins) force season ticket holders to buy preseason tickets, you will see even less motivation this year for fans to buy season tickets.
B-Brees, Drew
Drew Brees (New Orleans Saints quarterback) has been one of the faces of the union during the last few days as he has taken a very active role in the mediated negotiations. He was also the one who led the the Saints and Vikings in the solidarity finger prior to the first game of the year in 2010 (on Thursday Night Football).
C-Cohen, George
George Cohen is the federal mediator representing the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service, who has overseen the negotiations between the players and owners since the Super Bowl. He himself has said that it is probably best that negotiations cut off after today for a while. Nothing good would be accomplished if they were to continue.
Just 23 letters to go after the jump!
A-August
August is when the preseason begins. This is when the league would really start to feel the effects of a work stoppage. Preseason games don't nearly rake in the dollars that regular season games do, but since most teams (like the Redskins) force season ticket holders to buy preseason tickets, you will see even less motivation this year for fans to buy season tickets.
B-Brees, Drew
Drew Brees (New Orleans Saints quarterback) has been one of the faces of the union during the last few days as he has taken a very active role in the mediated negotiations. He was also the one who led the the Saints and Vikings in the solidarity finger prior to the first game of the year in 2010 (on Thursday Night Football).
C-Cohen, George
George Cohen is the federal mediator representing the Federal Mediation and Conciliation Service, who has overseen the negotiations between the players and owners since the Super Bowl. He himself has said that it is probably best that negotiations cut off after today for a while. Nothing good would be accomplished if they were to continue.
Just 23 letters to go after the jump!
Friday, March 11, 2011
National Football League (August 20, 1920-March 11, 2011)
No, I don't think the NFL is dead (as the title of this post might suggest), but it will never be the same after today. When it returns, we will see a completely different pro football landscape than we have been used to.
Today, the NFL Players Association declared their dissolution as a labor union and reorganization as a "professional trade association." This move essentially serves one purpose. As a union, the NFLPA cannot bring legal action against their employers (the NFL). By reforming as a "trade association," individual players can now bring legal suit against the league using antitrust law. Their hope is to regain potential wages lost by the owners locking them out.
A lockout cannot happen until the CBA officially expires, and that will happen at 11:59 tonight. A vote to start a lockout is surely to follow.
The more immediate concern for the owners is the players seeking an injunction in the court of David Doty in Minnesota. This is the same judge who ruled last week that the owners did not negotiate in "good faith" when they signed TV contracts guaranteeing payouts to the league amounting to $4 billion in the event of a lockout. An injunction would immediately stop any lockout proceedings. So, you would think the pendulum is in favor of the players, but not so fast. Injunctions are very hard to get. Essentially, in order to get an injunction to stop a lockout, the players have to prove to Doty that their entire livelihood will be negatively affected by being locked out. Since most of these guys are millionaires, I doubt they'll have an easy time proving that. We shall see.
In my next post, I will be posting an A-Z guide to help you navigate through the stormy waters that is the NFL collective bargaining mess.
Today, the NFL Players Association declared their dissolution as a labor union and reorganization as a "professional trade association." This move essentially serves one purpose. As a union, the NFLPA cannot bring legal action against their employers (the NFL). By reforming as a "trade association," individual players can now bring legal suit against the league using antitrust law. Their hope is to regain potential wages lost by the owners locking them out.
A lockout cannot happen until the CBA officially expires, and that will happen at 11:59 tonight. A vote to start a lockout is surely to follow.
The more immediate concern for the owners is the players seeking an injunction in the court of David Doty in Minnesota. This is the same judge who ruled last week that the owners did not negotiate in "good faith" when they signed TV contracts guaranteeing payouts to the league amounting to $4 billion in the event of a lockout. An injunction would immediately stop any lockout proceedings. So, you would think the pendulum is in favor of the players, but not so fast. Injunctions are very hard to get. Essentially, in order to get an injunction to stop a lockout, the players have to prove to Doty that their entire livelihood will be negatively affected by being locked out. Since most of these guys are millionaires, I doubt they'll have an easy time proving that. We shall see.
In my next post, I will be posting an A-Z guide to help you navigate through the stormy waters that is the NFL collective bargaining mess.
Friday, March 4, 2011
Another extension
The union and the owners have now agreed to a 7 day extension to the CBA talks. What are we supposed to make of this? Are they actually making progress? If you believe Jeff Pash, the chief negotiator, not much. However, there is the other side of the coin that says if they are talking at all, it's a good thing. The bottom line is this, and we have made this point a number of times here on the blog. Nothing is going to get resolved until the two sides figure out how to divide up the $9 billion in revenues. As of right now, the two sides are still $800 million apart. I am on record as saying that at the end of the day this will come down to an 11th hour deal. That 11th hour just keeps getting delayed, but they can't do this forever. They have to come to some sort of resolution at some point, whether that be a new CBA or a lockout. If they can figure out the revenue sharing, the rest of it will take care of itself.
When (if?) the NFL locks out the union (the new deadline is 5PM next Friday), Caputo's Corner will have prepared for you a survival guide to the end of the NFL as we know it.
When (if?) the NFL locks out the union (the new deadline is 5PM next Friday), Caputo's Corner will have prepared for you a survival guide to the end of the NFL as we know it.
24 Hour CBA Extension
Last night was supposed to be the expiration of the CBA (at 11:59PM). However, thanks to mediation, a proposal by the owners, and a 24 hour request by the owners, the deadline was extentded to 11:59 tonight. Right now, federal mediator George Cohen is encouraging both sides to extend the deadline further (7-10 days).
The key thing to keep an eye on is the decertification of the union. Once the union decertifies, it's open season: lawsuits and litigation all over the place. The union has until 4PM today to decertify in time to initiate court proceedings against the league (barring another extension). When this thing is resolved one way or another, you know you will get coverage and analysis here on Caputo's Corner.
The key thing to keep an eye on is the decertification of the union. Once the union decertifies, it's open season: lawsuits and litigation all over the place. The union has until 4PM today to decertify in time to initiate court proceedings against the league (barring another extension). When this thing is resolved one way or another, you know you will get coverage and analysis here on Caputo's Corner.
Saturday, February 19, 2011
The NFL and Congress
As the wind howls outside my window, we learn more about the mediation going on between the NFL and the NFLPA. After talks broke down last week, and the March 4th deadline steadily nears, the two sides agreed to enter formal mediation to try and resolve their differences. As we have noted here at Caputo's Corner, there are several. The most imporant of which is how to split the $9 billion in revenues. Right now, the players like it as is with them receiver 60%, whereas the owners are asking them to take only 50%.
Gotta love it when millionaires are bickering with billionaires.
In a somewhat related note, the Federal Government is planning on shutting down on March 4th along with the NFL. OH NO, BIG BROTHER'S GONNA CLOSE!!!!!! Relax, you'll still get your mail. The House this morning passed (on a party-line vote) a budget containing $60 billion in cuts from what the President initally authorized. Of course, Obama's going to veto it, if it even gets that far. Nevertheless, since the GOP controls the purse strings now in the House, get ready for a long standoff very similar to when the government shut down in the 1995 with the Clinton White House and GOP Congress.
And yes, even if the government is closed, tax day is still April 15th.
Here is a very interesting piece from Time of all things chiding the union protesters in Wisconsin for doing the same things that they railed against Republicans for doing when the Democrats held majorities. As I said in my short take, Democrats lost. Despite what the protesters say, they are NOT the majority in Wisconsin anymore. The majority voted for something that they don't necessarily support. So instead of physically blocking this democracy they all crave, let it do what it's supposed to do...and tell your state senators not to run away to Illinois. Stay classy, Wisconsin. The only thing I disagree with is that the author says that both parties cow to union leadership for political points. Give me a break, it's just the Democrats who cow to unions and everyone knows it. Thanks again, to Josh for that link.
Gotta love it when millionaires are bickering with billionaires.
In a somewhat related note, the Federal Government is planning on shutting down on March 4th along with the NFL. OH NO, BIG BROTHER'S GONNA CLOSE!!!!!! Relax, you'll still get your mail. The House this morning passed (on a party-line vote) a budget containing $60 billion in cuts from what the President initally authorized. Of course, Obama's going to veto it, if it even gets that far. Nevertheless, since the GOP controls the purse strings now in the House, get ready for a long standoff very similar to when the government shut down in the 1995 with the Clinton White House and GOP Congress.
And yes, even if the government is closed, tax day is still April 15th.
Here is a very interesting piece from Time of all things chiding the union protesters in Wisconsin for doing the same things that they railed against Republicans for doing when the Democrats held majorities. As I said in my short take, Democrats lost. Despite what the protesters say, they are NOT the majority in Wisconsin anymore. The majority voted for something that they don't necessarily support. So instead of physically blocking this democracy they all crave, let it do what it's supposed to do...and tell your state senators not to run away to Illinois. Stay classy, Wisconsin. The only thing I disagree with is that the author says that both parties cow to union leadership for political points. Give me a break, it's just the Democrats who cow to unions and everyone knows it. Thanks again, to Josh for that link.
Monday, February 14, 2011
Monday Quick Hits
Some short takes today. Let's see what's going on.
-The Caps looked pretty bad from my perch in section 426 at Verizon Center on Saturday afternoon. After Ovechkin scored on the first shot of the game in the 2nd minute of the game, they didn't really provide much else in the way off offense for the rest of the game. The power play was punchless again. The defense and goaltending did pretty well, but when you cannot generate any offense, it's going to crack eventually. I saw very little in the way of hustle as the Kings scored a 2 on 1 goal late in the 3rd period to make the score 4-1 and essentially salt it away. They got a chance to get 2 points back against a good Phoenix team tonight. I wonder if DJ King will be in the lineup again.............. They better not look down in the standings. They are now tied with Montreal for 5th in the East, and they are only 8 points up on 9th place. If that doesn't give them a sense of urgency, I don't know what will.
-This posturing is getting ridiculous. Today we find out the NFL is taking the union to court over claims of "unfair labor practices." Their goal is to get a judge to order the union to bargain in good faith. Wait a second. I thought it was the union who was screaming that the owners wanted a lockout because they had already got their cut of the money from the TV contracts and didn't want to share it with the players. Now the owners are claming that the players want to avoid a CBA by the deadline? Something really doesn't add up. Perhaps this is just a lot of smoke and mirrors from the League to get the union to concede something, I don't kinow what. This is just getting comical. I have said before that I feel a deal will get struck, but it will not come until the 11th hour. I know that proposition looks less and less likely with each passing day, but I'm not backing down from that prediction...yet.
-Obama wants to spend $8 billion on a bullet train, a down payment for a project that will eventually cost around $58 billion. The proposed site in California is between a town on the map where nobody lives and a state penitentiary. Hmmm, me thinks that convicts will not be getting out of the big house to get on a choo choo train any time soon, no matter how fast it is. Who takes the train anymore anyway? Rail might be an enticing alternative to flying because of the patdowns, backscatter X-ray, and soon-to-be unionized TSA, but as it is right now, it is extremely inefficient. Schedules are not conducive to business travel and fares are outrageous. If you want to spend money on a rail project, reform Amtrak.
One final quick hit: I'm working on my next edition of Nick's Lists. I had so much fun doing my last post on road construction (with a little friendly nudge from Josh) that I decided my next list will be a little bit of science, engineering, and road tripping. We're going to take a look at the top 10 best bridges in America! I'm looking forward to posting it later this week. Stay tuned.
-The Caps looked pretty bad from my perch in section 426 at Verizon Center on Saturday afternoon. After Ovechkin scored on the first shot of the game in the 2nd minute of the game, they didn't really provide much else in the way off offense for the rest of the game. The power play was punchless again. The defense and goaltending did pretty well, but when you cannot generate any offense, it's going to crack eventually. I saw very little in the way of hustle as the Kings scored a 2 on 1 goal late in the 3rd period to make the score 4-1 and essentially salt it away. They got a chance to get 2 points back against a good Phoenix team tonight. I wonder if DJ King will be in the lineup again.............. They better not look down in the standings. They are now tied with Montreal for 5th in the East, and they are only 8 points up on 9th place. If that doesn't give them a sense of urgency, I don't know what will.
-This posturing is getting ridiculous. Today we find out the NFL is taking the union to court over claims of "unfair labor practices." Their goal is to get a judge to order the union to bargain in good faith. Wait a second. I thought it was the union who was screaming that the owners wanted a lockout because they had already got their cut of the money from the TV contracts and didn't want to share it with the players. Now the owners are claming that the players want to avoid a CBA by the deadline? Something really doesn't add up. Perhaps this is just a lot of smoke and mirrors from the League to get the union to concede something, I don't kinow what. This is just getting comical. I have said before that I feel a deal will get struck, but it will not come until the 11th hour. I know that proposition looks less and less likely with each passing day, but I'm not backing down from that prediction...yet.
-Obama wants to spend $8 billion on a bullet train, a down payment for a project that will eventually cost around $58 billion. The proposed site in California is between a town on the map where nobody lives and a state penitentiary. Hmmm, me thinks that convicts will not be getting out of the big house to get on a choo choo train any time soon, no matter how fast it is. Who takes the train anymore anyway? Rail might be an enticing alternative to flying because of the patdowns, backscatter X-ray, and soon-to-be unionized TSA, but as it is right now, it is extremely inefficient. Schedules are not conducive to business travel and fares are outrageous. If you want to spend money on a rail project, reform Amtrak.
One final quick hit: I'm working on my next edition of Nick's Lists. I had so much fun doing my last post on road construction (with a little friendly nudge from Josh) that I decided my next list will be a little bit of science, engineering, and road tripping. We're going to take a look at the top 10 best bridges in America! I'm looking forward to posting it later this week. Stay tuned.
Thursday, February 10, 2011
There Are More Important Things than Football...I think
As we really start to get into the abyss that is the NFL offseason, lots of questions still remain about the status of the CBA talks. An upcoming Thursday bargaining session between the league and the union was cancelled. However, both Roger Goodell and DeMaurice Smith called the past weekend's talks "beneficial," whatever that means. I have said that there needs to be pressure from the outside to force the two sides to talk and eventually agree to something. If people ignore what's going on, there will be no incentive for the two sides to talk, and a lockout is inevitable (if it wasn't already).
Josh over at Lattanzi Land, has a slightly different point of view, and I would be remiss if I did not say that it has merit. He accuses the sports media of what he calls "battered wife syndrome." In short (and please, Josh, correct me if my interpretation is off), BWS is when the media keeps going back to the NFL for scoops, as much of a quagmire as it is, because it is what gives them the best ratings. Therefore, as the NFL is soaking in all the media attention, they really don't have ANY incentive to want to wrap up the talks. Meanwhile, truly newsworth events like the transfer of power in Egypt, don't get quite the amount of coverage they deserve. Egypt is slightly more impactful to the rest of the world than what the NFL is doing, as the results of the protests could shape politics in the Middle East for some time to come.
If you want the NFL to speed up the process, leave them alone. Tell ESPN and all of its friends to stop having camera camping out at Park Avenue looking for the next sound bite. That way, when the NFL realizes that it's no longer the center of attention, then they might get a little motivation to speed up the process. Otherwise, they might not get the airtime they so desperately crave.
I've got to say, it might be worth a shot. The NFL needs to be pressured. I never really did think that the source of pressure would be...no pressure at all.
Josh, feel free to chide me for any incorrect interpretations of your point of view as you see fit.
Josh over at Lattanzi Land, has a slightly different point of view, and I would be remiss if I did not say that it has merit. He accuses the sports media of what he calls "battered wife syndrome." In short (and please, Josh, correct me if my interpretation is off), BWS is when the media keeps going back to the NFL for scoops, as much of a quagmire as it is, because it is what gives them the best ratings. Therefore, as the NFL is soaking in all the media attention, they really don't have ANY incentive to want to wrap up the talks. Meanwhile, truly newsworth events like the transfer of power in Egypt, don't get quite the amount of coverage they deserve. Egypt is slightly more impactful to the rest of the world than what the NFL is doing, as the results of the protests could shape politics in the Middle East for some time to come.
If you want the NFL to speed up the process, leave them alone. Tell ESPN and all of its friends to stop having camera camping out at Park Avenue looking for the next sound bite. That way, when the NFL realizes that it's no longer the center of attention, then they might get a little motivation to speed up the process. Otherwise, they might not get the airtime they so desperately crave.
I've got to say, it might be worth a shot. The NFL needs to be pressured. I never really did think that the source of pressure would be...no pressure at all.
Josh, feel free to chide me for any incorrect interpretations of your point of view as you see fit.
Wednesday, January 26, 2011
Roger Goodell is taking a pay cut
So The Roge' and chief NFL negotiator Jeff Pash have decided that until a new CBA is ratified, they are cutting their annual salary down to $1, Mike Florio at PFT reports. This could be an honest act of good faith on the league side to give themselves incentives to get to the bargaining table and see that a deal is done before the March 4th lockout. Now, will the union take the bait. Florio opines that the union could feel that this is nothing more than a cheap PR stunt and that Goodell will get his pay elsewhere, perhaps in the form of back pay when a new CBA is in fact signed. A fair point indeed, but at the very least the league is putting on the front that they are willing and eager to get to the negotiating table now. Goodell has been fairly consistent on this, but this just gets back to the on-camera posturing by both sides going all the way back to September with the players in that very first game putting their fingers in the air as an act of "solidarity" (I wonder if Jay Cutler feels that way right now).
This deal is going to get done out of sight of a camera lens. I feel like the money will take care of itself (after all, it is millioinaires bickering with billionaires), but I have said before that it will not get done unless each side makes some sort of compromise on the other secondary issues in play (18-game schedule, rookie wage scale, etc.). My previous post on this topic gives my take on these key issues and how they should resolve themselves. The bottom line is this, Goodell taking a pay cut may look like a sincere gesture, but at the end of the day he represents the owners negotiating against the players. Both sides need to get to the table NOW and start talking to each other and not the media. If they don't, perhaps Roger might want to start looking in the classifieds for another line of work......
This deal is going to get done out of sight of a camera lens. I feel like the money will take care of itself (after all, it is millioinaires bickering with billionaires), but I have said before that it will not get done unless each side makes some sort of compromise on the other secondary issues in play (18-game schedule, rookie wage scale, etc.). My previous post on this topic gives my take on these key issues and how they should resolve themselves. The bottom line is this, Goodell taking a pay cut may look like a sincere gesture, but at the end of the day he represents the owners negotiating against the players. Both sides need to get to the table NOW and start talking to each other and not the media. If they don't, perhaps Roger might want to start looking in the classifieds for another line of work......
Wednesday, January 12, 2011
State of the NFL
Usually, Roger Goodell takes care of this during Super Bowl week, but with the steady stream of headlines in the last few months about how both owners and players are posturing in advance of a potential lockout, now seems like a good time to address the state of the league.
Why is the NFL preparing to lock out the players union? This reeks eerily similar to the infamous NHL lockout and lost season of 2004-2005. During that entire ordeal, Gary Bettman preached "cost certainty." While the NFL is not using those exact words, if your read Greg Aiello's piece on ESPN.com, you certainly get the sense that cost certainty is what he is preaching. What the NHL was ultimately after was a salary cap. The players wouldn't budge, and the end result was not pretty for the sport of hockey. Now, thanks to the likes of Alex Ovechkin and even Sidney Crosby (gag me), that sport has enjoyed a very nice rebound. Events like the 2011 Winter Classic (take that Pittsburgh...HA!) will ensure that hockey has a strong future. Nevertheless, a lost season is a lost season, and the NFL...the golden goose of professional sports leagues...is staring straight down the barrel of one. My take on a couple key issues after the jump.
Why is the NFL preparing to lock out the players union? This reeks eerily similar to the infamous NHL lockout and lost season of 2004-2005. During that entire ordeal, Gary Bettman preached "cost certainty." While the NFL is not using those exact words, if your read Greg Aiello's piece on ESPN.com, you certainly get the sense that cost certainty is what he is preaching. What the NHL was ultimately after was a salary cap. The players wouldn't budge, and the end result was not pretty for the sport of hockey. Now, thanks to the likes of Alex Ovechkin and even Sidney Crosby (gag me), that sport has enjoyed a very nice rebound. Events like the 2011 Winter Classic (take that Pittsburgh...HA!) will ensure that hockey has a strong future. Nevertheless, a lost season is a lost season, and the NFL...the golden goose of professional sports leagues...is staring straight down the barrel of one. My take on a couple key issues after the jump.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)