Bet you were expecting me to do wide receivers next, didn't you? Don't worry, I do have a list of wideouts to yak about, but for the last couple of days, I have been fixated with the defensive line. Don't ask me why, but I have been. So the next installment of our preseason top 10s focuses on the big boys who have got their sights set on the quarterback.
That actually is a misconception about defensive linemen. Most people think that big guys who play these positions have one statistic on their minds: sacks. While this may be true for some defensive ends, this is not the case, far from it. There is a HUGE difference between how you play defensive end and defensive tackle. In a very oversimplified sense, defensive linemen are supposed to be space eaters. The best defensive linemen are able to shoot gaps and command double teams from the offensive line. This is kind of a catch-22. The best linemen are good enough that they get double-teamed every time the ball is snapped. This means that they probably will not get a whole lot of sacks (or tackles for that matter). On the other hand, if you single up these guys, they probably will get a ton of sacks and tackles. When linemen battle in the trenches, you often hear commentators say that they are "controlling the line of scrimmage." This is more true than you imagine. It is a lot easier to dictate the flow of the game going forward than backward. The best defensive lines are able to reestablish the line of scrimmage a yard or two in the backfield and put the offensive line on their heels. On the other hand, the best offensive lines reestablish the line of scrimmage a yard or two forward. The reestablishment of the line of scrimmage makes it much easier for playmakers (in the defense's case, linebackers) to knife into the backfield and make plays. Linebackers are typically the best tacklers on the team.
If sacks really to suit your fancy, you are more likely to get them out of defensive ends. There has historically always been a debate to figure out what the ideal size and weight of a defensive (and offensive) lineman should be. For many years, the answer has been bigger and heavier. The logic quite simply is that bigger and heavier means stronger and more overpowering. However, in recent seasons, teams have picked up that big and heavy also can translate into fat and slow. What does that mean? The best defensive ends are smaller and quicker. Speed kills, and not just at wide receiver. The best sack masters nowadays are those who look like they are small enough to play linebacker, but are quick enough to get a first step on an offensive tackle who has reaction time that is just that much slower. Throw in a nifty swim or spin move, watch the sack numbers pile up.
There is a big difference between ends and tackles in a 4-3 compared to a 3-4 set. Most of the sack-generating defensive ends come from a 4-3 set, as they are in a position on the edge of the interior line where a good speed rush can get to the quarterback. However, in a 3-4 set, the defensive ends act more like defensive tackles in a 4-3, allowing linebackers to get most of the sack totals. However, the success and failure of a 3-4 depends on one position: the nose guard. The nose guard lines up directly over the football, and is supposed to be the biggest guy on that side. He dictates which direction the offensive line goes. The best nose tackles not only command double teams, but also is able to move the offensive line side to side, allowing other defenders to make plays. Nose guard is a very unrewarding position, especially when it comes to stats, but how well the nose guard plays is critical to the success of a 3-4 defensive scheme.
Today's list will focus on both defensive ends and defensive tackles (and nose guards). Let the debates begin as we examine the TOP 10 DEFENSIVE LINEMEN IN NFL HISTORY!
Saturday, August 20, 2011
Redskins 16-Colts 3: Game Analysis
People may claim that John Beck "made a claim" to the starting quarterback job with his performance last night (14 for 17, 170 yards). There are a couple counters to that claim. First, it really was his job to lose even before this game. Second, the passes he threw were not exactly very tough. Most of his throws were across the middle to wide targets not very far downfield. I will admit that the throw to Gaffney on the goal line was a nice strike, and he did move in the pocket well (Trent Williams did not have a good game trying to block Freeney). However, he didn't do anything that would make me, a skeptic, say that he is going to be fine as the Redskins' #1 guy. The Colts don't care about the preseason. They just don't. They have enough confidence in their personnel that they feel like they're going to win 12 games if they had to start the season stone cold. Therefore, they put zero stock in preseason games other than to evaluate talent for the bottom of the depth chart. Sure, the Skins scored their one touchdown against the Colts' "starters," but how much effort did they really put into that first quarter?
That's another thing that is very concerning to me so far in the preseason. We have been in the red zone (inside the 20 yard line) 8 times this preseason from what I can remember from the two games. We have scored touchdowns only twice, and have attempted field goals every other time. The good news is that we have not turned the ball over (Rex's one interception last night was near midfield) and we have scored points, but when you get that close, you need 7 points, not 3. Red zone offense is something that we definitely need to work on in practice, because if the offense continues to move the ball as well as we have, we'll have plenty of opportunities in close.
Defensively, I don't really read anything into how we played. The fact is that we only gave up 3 points (and a total of 10 so far in the preseason). That's good. On the other hand, who has been our competition? Ben Roethlisberger (for one drive), Byron Leftwich, Charlie Batch, Dennis Dixon, Curtis Painter, and Dan Orlovski. It's good that we can beat second-rate competition, and the live action is definitely beneficial to a team that is still learning the offense, but at the end of the day, 2-0 in the preseason does not mean anything when then the New York Giants come to FedEx field on September 11th.
Our next game is against Baltimore, which traditionally has always been a solid test. I like the fact that we play them in the 3rd preseason game because this game is when the starters usually get their most work of the preseason. Beck will probably start again and play a half, but everybody else in the first unit should go well into the 3rd quarter. It will be interesting to see if we can move the ball as well against a team that will be putting a little more stock into this game than our two previous opponents. It would be nice if we could even punch it in the end zone a litte bit more.
That's another thing that is very concerning to me so far in the preseason. We have been in the red zone (inside the 20 yard line) 8 times this preseason from what I can remember from the two games. We have scored touchdowns only twice, and have attempted field goals every other time. The good news is that we have not turned the ball over (Rex's one interception last night was near midfield) and we have scored points, but when you get that close, you need 7 points, not 3. Red zone offense is something that we definitely need to work on in practice, because if the offense continues to move the ball as well as we have, we'll have plenty of opportunities in close.
Defensively, I don't really read anything into how we played. The fact is that we only gave up 3 points (and a total of 10 so far in the preseason). That's good. On the other hand, who has been our competition? Ben Roethlisberger (for one drive), Byron Leftwich, Charlie Batch, Dennis Dixon, Curtis Painter, and Dan Orlovski. It's good that we can beat second-rate competition, and the live action is definitely beneficial to a team that is still learning the offense, but at the end of the day, 2-0 in the preseason does not mean anything when then the New York Giants come to FedEx field on September 11th.
Our next game is against Baltimore, which traditionally has always been a solid test. I like the fact that we play them in the 3rd preseason game because this game is when the starters usually get their most work of the preseason. Beck will probably start again and play a half, but everybody else in the first unit should go well into the 3rd quarter. It will be interesting to see if we can move the ball as well against a team that will be putting a little more stock into this game than our two previous opponents. It would be nice if we could even punch it in the end zone a litte bit more.
Wednesday, August 17, 2011
Nick's Lists: Top 10 Running Backs in NFL History (5-1)
Had a little interruption as we examined the latest scandals brewing in college football this Fall. Now, we get back to our countdown of the top running backs in the NFL. We'll get to the top 5 in just a minute, but first some HM's
Marcus Allen (Oakland/Los Angeles Raiders 1982-1992; Kansas City Chiefs 1993-1997)-Marcus makes this list pretty much for just one play in one game against one team. If you're a Redskins fan, cover your eyes.
Franco Harris (Pittsburgh Steelers 1972-1983; Seattle Seahawks 1984)-Everybody remembers the Immaculate Reception, but Harris was a key cog in the offensive consistency (buoyed by defensive dominance) that helped the Steelers win 4 Super Bowls in the 70s. He's also Italian, which always is a plus
John Riggins (New York Jets 1971-75; Washington Redskins 1976-85)-Riggo technically was a fullback on the roster, so he really should not be on a running back list...but A) It's my list (and he's only an HM) and B) anybody who decides to take a bow in a playoff game after scoring 3 times and rushing for 185 yards makes a top running backs list. Oh yeah, there was also this (Skins fans, it's OK to watch this one :-))
Frank Gifford (New York Giants 1952-1964)-Alright, real quick, let's do some word association. I say Frank Gifford, you say...Kathie Lee? OK, now that we got that out of our system, we can talk about Frank Gifford the running back. Gifford was the prototypical halfback of the 1950s and early 1960s: versatile, durable, and can take plenty of hits. He won the NFL MVP in 1956, and led the Giants in the Greatest Game Ever Played (the 1958 NFL Championship against Baltimore). The Giants lost in overtime, but Gifford did his part rushing 12 times for 60 yards and catching 3 passes for 15 yards and scored once.
Adrian Peterson (Minnesota Vikings 2008-) I know that I haven't shown a whole lot of love to the modern guys, but if I had to pick one, I'd pick AP. Chris Johnson is a crybaby (he wants "playmaker" money), MJD is too inconsistent (and he gets hurt too much), and who else out there really is a standout back that should make a top 10 list?
And here we go! Time for the top 5 running backs in NFL history!
Marcus Allen (Oakland/Los Angeles Raiders 1982-1992; Kansas City Chiefs 1993-1997)-Marcus makes this list pretty much for just one play in one game against one team. If you're a Redskins fan, cover your eyes.
Franco Harris (Pittsburgh Steelers 1972-1983; Seattle Seahawks 1984)-Everybody remembers the Immaculate Reception, but Harris was a key cog in the offensive consistency (buoyed by defensive dominance) that helped the Steelers win 4 Super Bowls in the 70s. He's also Italian, which always is a plus
John Riggins (New York Jets 1971-75; Washington Redskins 1976-85)-Riggo technically was a fullback on the roster, so he really should not be on a running back list...but A) It's my list (and he's only an HM) and B) anybody who decides to take a bow in a playoff game after scoring 3 times and rushing for 185 yards makes a top running backs list. Oh yeah, there was also this (Skins fans, it's OK to watch this one :-))
Frank Gifford (New York Giants 1952-1964)-Alright, real quick, let's do some word association. I say Frank Gifford, you say...Kathie Lee? OK, now that we got that out of our system, we can talk about Frank Gifford the running back. Gifford was the prototypical halfback of the 1950s and early 1960s: versatile, durable, and can take plenty of hits. He won the NFL MVP in 1956, and led the Giants in the Greatest Game Ever Played (the 1958 NFL Championship against Baltimore). The Giants lost in overtime, but Gifford did his part rushing 12 times for 60 yards and catching 3 passes for 15 yards and scored once.
Adrian Peterson (Minnesota Vikings 2008-) I know that I haven't shown a whole lot of love to the modern guys, but if I had to pick one, I'd pick AP. Chris Johnson is a crybaby (he wants "playmaker" money), MJD is too inconsistent (and he gets hurt too much), and who else out there really is a standout back that should make a top 10 list?
And here we go! Time for the top 5 running backs in NFL history!
Scandals in College Football
There has been lots of news recently regarding scandals and improper behavior both at Ohio State and the University of Miami. The issue at Ohio State regards the status of former quarterback Terrell Pryor in regards to the NFL Supplemental Draft, which had originally be scheduled for today, but has been postponed. The postponement is most likely due to the NFL needing more time to consider Pryor's status. He declared himself ineligbile to play college football in June, well after the regular NFL Draft in April. According to NFL rules, a player is eligible for the supplemental draft if his collegiate eligibility changes between the regular draft and the time of the supplemental draft. A variety of reasons can allow a player to become eligible for the supplemental draft such as conduct and academics. However, there is debate as to whether or not Pryor's status actually changed.
This who scenario stems from a scandal at Ohio State which forced not only Pryor but former head coach Jim Tressel to resign becuase of players receiving improper benefits from boosters, and Tressel knowing about it. Originially, Pryor and seven other players were forced to sign a document promising that they would return for their senior seasons and serve a 5-game suspension at the start of the season. This was in return for being able to play in the Sugar Bowl on January 4th. This all occured before the January 15th deadline for underclassmen to declare themselves eligible for the NFL Draft. The argument against Pryor is that his status did not change, but rather he has been ineligible since he was suspended. Therefore, since there was not status change, Pryor declaring himself ineligible in June is meaningless.
Ultimately, I feel like Pryor will be allowed to enter the supplemental draft, but I feel like he would be better off just waiting until April. If he is drafted now in the supplemental draft, the best he probably would be able to do is a team spending a 6th or 7th round pick on him. This is becuase he will have had virtually no chances (mostly because of the lockout) to impress teams. He had scheduled a pro day for last Friday, with several teams planning on attending, but since there was no guarantee that he would be able to get into the supplemental draft, he cancelled that pro day. This means that even if he does get a chance to work out in front of teams, he will have had a grand total of one chance to impress somebody. If a team decides to take a chance on him, like I said, it would not be with anything higher than a late round pick. If he decides to wait until April, yes he will miss out on a year of salary, but the payoff will be much better in my opinion. He will have had an entire offseason to work out and impress coaches. He will (most likely) attend the scouting combine and maybe even impress somebody enough to get up into the first half of the draft. This rush to get drafted might send him the way of Mike Williams, who skipped school after his sophomore season at USC following Maurice Clarett (great role model...) into the NFL. Williams is still in the league, but he's nothing more than a journeyman. Pryor has a chance, especially at the quarterback position, to do some great things in pro football. Wait until April.
The other big news in college football today comes from the University of Miami, no stranger to the NCAA doghouse. This latest issue deals with allegations from former booster Nevin Shapiro, who claims to have given improper benefits (including cash, trips, cars, VIP access to clubs, prostitutes, bounties, and even time on Shapiro's private yacht) to over 70 Miami football and basketball players during the last decade. This includes several current NFL players who went to the U. Now, Shapiro is currently serving 20 years in federal-pound-me-in-the-[expletive deleted] prison (ever seen Office Space?) for running a nearly $1 billion ponzi scheme. I wonder where some of that $1 billion went... In any event, Shapiro is naming names and the big debate right now is (assuming the allegations to be true) whether or not Miami will get the so-called "death penalty."
For those of you who might not be totally familar with the NCAA "death penalty" concept, it has only been enforced one time in history: 1986 for SMU football. It involves taking away the right of a school to play a certain sport. In the 1980s, SMU was a football powerhouse, but for pretty much the entire decade of the 1980s, including after being banned from bowls and numerous probations, the NCAA cancelled their 1987 season after it had been revealed that several players had received improper benefits, including cash simply for signing a letter of intent with the school. The repeated violations forced the NCAA to strip the university of football for that season, and SMU has never been the same since. Several schools have come close to receiving the death penalty for numerous violations (including USC, Alabama, and even Maryland basketball in 1989), but SMU was the only confirmed instance when the death penalty was invoked.
Will Miami actually receive the death penalty for these allegations? Hard to say. It would be easier to say no if there were no current players implicated. Unfortunately for the U, current quarterback Jacory Harris and other players have been implicated in the scandal (and one of the names dropped by Shapiro). Since current players are involved, and since Miami is a repeat offender, the death penalty cannot be ruled out, especially considering the seriousness of the allegations. Now, at the same time, the individual making the accusations is a convicted felon serving hard time. How trustworthy is he? However, what does he have to lose? What incentive does he have to lie? Shapiro claims to have all kinds of evidence backing up his claims. All of this needs to be investigated thoroughly.
All of this nonsense ultimately comes back to one very important question the answer to which we should know, but really do not. What is the value of a college education. These athletes going to school are receiving over a quarter of a million dollars worth of free education over a 4-year period. There are kids who work their entire lives to pay off loans so that they can get the same education these kids are getting for absolutely free. Where is the equity? Now, we can talk about paying players all we want (that's another issue entirely), but the bottom line is that the kids who are receiving these athletic scholarships in the big money sports (football and basketball) are in essence abusing what they have been given. Are the players entirely at fault? They're not, bums like Nevin Shapiro and Ed Martin (from the fab 5 days at Michigan) are so bent out of shape to see "their team" win a national championship that they are not ashame of bending and breaking rules to make sure "their team" gets premier prep talent. A national championhip in football is more important than an education that will be valuable for the rest of a person's life. That's what this has come to, and it's a travesty. As a teacher, I am a bit more sensitive to these kinds of issues than others might be, and don't get me wrong, I love college and pro football and I want to see my team win. However, I understand that the vast majority of collegiate athletes on scholarship are aware that the eduation they are getting is really priceless, and I just wish that these so-called boosters would remind the players of that instead of giving them trips on a yacht.
I'll be back later with the conclusion of our latest countdown featuring the top 10 running backs in NFL history.
![]() |
| Pryor and Tressel (from thesportsbank.net) |
Ultimately, I feel like Pryor will be allowed to enter the supplemental draft, but I feel like he would be better off just waiting until April. If he is drafted now in the supplemental draft, the best he probably would be able to do is a team spending a 6th or 7th round pick on him. This is becuase he will have had virtually no chances (mostly because of the lockout) to impress teams. He had scheduled a pro day for last Friday, with several teams planning on attending, but since there was no guarantee that he would be able to get into the supplemental draft, he cancelled that pro day. This means that even if he does get a chance to work out in front of teams, he will have had a grand total of one chance to impress somebody. If a team decides to take a chance on him, like I said, it would not be with anything higher than a late round pick. If he decides to wait until April, yes he will miss out on a year of salary, but the payoff will be much better in my opinion. He will have had an entire offseason to work out and impress coaches. He will (most likely) attend the scouting combine and maybe even impress somebody enough to get up into the first half of the draft. This rush to get drafted might send him the way of Mike Williams, who skipped school after his sophomore season at USC following Maurice Clarett (great role model...) into the NFL. Williams is still in the league, but he's nothing more than a journeyman. Pryor has a chance, especially at the quarterback position, to do some great things in pro football. Wait until April.
The other big news in college football today comes from the University of Miami, no stranger to the NCAA doghouse. This latest issue deals with allegations from former booster Nevin Shapiro, who claims to have given improper benefits (including cash, trips, cars, VIP access to clubs, prostitutes, bounties, and even time on Shapiro's private yacht) to over 70 Miami football and basketball players during the last decade. This includes several current NFL players who went to the U. Now, Shapiro is currently serving 20 years in federal-pound-me-in-the-[expletive deleted] prison (ever seen Office Space?) for running a nearly $1 billion ponzi scheme. I wonder where some of that $1 billion went... In any event, Shapiro is naming names and the big debate right now is (assuming the allegations to be true) whether or not Miami will get the so-called "death penalty."
For those of you who might not be totally familar with the NCAA "death penalty" concept, it has only been enforced one time in history: 1986 for SMU football. It involves taking away the right of a school to play a certain sport. In the 1980s, SMU was a football powerhouse, but for pretty much the entire decade of the 1980s, including after being banned from bowls and numerous probations, the NCAA cancelled their 1987 season after it had been revealed that several players had received improper benefits, including cash simply for signing a letter of intent with the school. The repeated violations forced the NCAA to strip the university of football for that season, and SMU has never been the same since. Several schools have come close to receiving the death penalty for numerous violations (including USC, Alabama, and even Maryland basketball in 1989), but SMU was the only confirmed instance when the death penalty was invoked.
![]() |
| Jacory Harris has been implicated in the latest scandal at the University of Miami (from deadspin.com) |
All of this nonsense ultimately comes back to one very important question the answer to which we should know, but really do not. What is the value of a college education. These athletes going to school are receiving over a quarter of a million dollars worth of free education over a 4-year period. There are kids who work their entire lives to pay off loans so that they can get the same education these kids are getting for absolutely free. Where is the equity? Now, we can talk about paying players all we want (that's another issue entirely), but the bottom line is that the kids who are receiving these athletic scholarships in the big money sports (football and basketball) are in essence abusing what they have been given. Are the players entirely at fault? They're not, bums like Nevin Shapiro and Ed Martin (from the fab 5 days at Michigan) are so bent out of shape to see "their team" win a national championship that they are not ashame of bending and breaking rules to make sure "their team" gets premier prep talent. A national championhip in football is more important than an education that will be valuable for the rest of a person's life. That's what this has come to, and it's a travesty. As a teacher, I am a bit more sensitive to these kinds of issues than others might be, and don't get me wrong, I love college and pro football and I want to see my team win. However, I understand that the vast majority of collegiate athletes on scholarship are aware that the eduation they are getting is really priceless, and I just wish that these so-called boosters would remind the players of that instead of giving them trips on a yacht.
I'll be back later with the conclusion of our latest countdown featuring the top 10 running backs in NFL history.
Tuesday, August 16, 2011
Nick's Lists: Top 10 Running Backs in NFL History (10-6)
We started our primer for the 2011 NFL season by examining the top 10 quarterbacks in NFL history. We continue our Nick's Lists series taking a look today at the top running backs in history.
Quarterback is the most important position on the field because he's the one position that has to know where everybody is and what they are doing at all times. Running back is not quite as cerebral. Receive ball, carry ball, run forward, and try not to get tackled. As simple as the position sounds, the punishment even the top running backs get during their careers usually means that by the age of 30, you're over the hill and it's time to retire. If only all of us could retire at age 30..... It is an art form, hitting the hole hard and accelerating downfield with a burst of speed never seen before. All of the backs in our list not only have that burst, but can also shed that first tackle and rack up the YAC. YAC is yards after contact (or yards after catch if you're talking about receivers, but that's another subject for another blog post). These guys were so hard to bring down, but at the same time were not afraid to get hit. In fact, these guys craved contact. If they weren't toting the rock, they were blowing somebody up in pass protection, or hustling downfield to block somebody.
If one of these guys dotted the I in the I-formation, you almost had to know that there would be 8-guys in the proverbial "box," and not a single one of them would want to meet these guys head-on Oklahoma Drill style. These guys were bruisers, but at the same time had the right amount of quickness and speed to hit the hole and leave defenders in their dust. These guys are reliable not only to punch it in from the 1-yard line, but also bust off a 60-yarder at a moment's notice. I wouldn't want to meet these guys head-on in a pass rush either. If these guys are staying behind in pass protection, somebody's going to get blown up...just saying. Great backs take pride in their blocking and pass protection. They can also catch, making them viable 3rd and 4th down threats as well. Perhaps most importantly, they protected the football. There are not a whole lot of fumbles on this list (i.e. Tiki Barber is not even an HM). That's how you get to be an every down back, and not just a guy who comes in to run on 1st and 2nd down, and gets subbed out on 3rd down for the pass blocker and pass catcher. Great backs don't just have great rushing totals, but are legitimate all-purpose yards guys as well.
One thing you will notice on this list is that the longevity of these guys' careers is not very long, usually maxing out at 10 or 11 years. The punishment you get at this particular position truly makes the age of 30 "over the hill" as they say. Many backs are in the twilight of their careers by their late 20s as the punishment they take is far more than any other position. Every time the ball is snapped they get hit, whether it be by getting tackled or by blocking somebody on pass protection. It takes guts to play this position.
On that note, let's get onto the big list. We start with 10-6 as usual. I present to you Caputo's Corner's TOP 10 RUNNING BACKS IN NFL HISTORY!
Quarterback is the most important position on the field because he's the one position that has to know where everybody is and what they are doing at all times. Running back is not quite as cerebral. Receive ball, carry ball, run forward, and try not to get tackled. As simple as the position sounds, the punishment even the top running backs get during their careers usually means that by the age of 30, you're over the hill and it's time to retire. If only all of us could retire at age 30..... It is an art form, hitting the hole hard and accelerating downfield with a burst of speed never seen before. All of the backs in our list not only have that burst, but can also shed that first tackle and rack up the YAC. YAC is yards after contact (or yards after catch if you're talking about receivers, but that's another subject for another blog post). These guys were so hard to bring down, but at the same time were not afraid to get hit. In fact, these guys craved contact. If they weren't toting the rock, they were blowing somebody up in pass protection, or hustling downfield to block somebody.
If one of these guys dotted the I in the I-formation, you almost had to know that there would be 8-guys in the proverbial "box," and not a single one of them would want to meet these guys head-on Oklahoma Drill style. These guys were bruisers, but at the same time had the right amount of quickness and speed to hit the hole and leave defenders in their dust. These guys are reliable not only to punch it in from the 1-yard line, but also bust off a 60-yarder at a moment's notice. I wouldn't want to meet these guys head-on in a pass rush either. If these guys are staying behind in pass protection, somebody's going to get blown up...just saying. Great backs take pride in their blocking and pass protection. They can also catch, making them viable 3rd and 4th down threats as well. Perhaps most importantly, they protected the football. There are not a whole lot of fumbles on this list (i.e. Tiki Barber is not even an HM). That's how you get to be an every down back, and not just a guy who comes in to run on 1st and 2nd down, and gets subbed out on 3rd down for the pass blocker and pass catcher. Great backs don't just have great rushing totals, but are legitimate all-purpose yards guys as well.
One thing you will notice on this list is that the longevity of these guys' careers is not very long, usually maxing out at 10 or 11 years. The punishment you get at this particular position truly makes the age of 30 "over the hill" as they say. Many backs are in the twilight of their careers by their late 20s as the punishment they take is far more than any other position. Every time the ball is snapped they get hit, whether it be by getting tackled or by blocking somebody on pass protection. It takes guts to play this position.
On that note, let's get onto the big list. We start with 10-6 as usual. I present to you Caputo's Corner's TOP 10 RUNNING BACKS IN NFL HISTORY!
Was the Indiana Stage Collapse a Fluke?
By now, most of you have probably already seen this video, but just as a reminder, here is raw video from the Indiana State Fair last Saturday showing the temporary stage for a Sugarland concert collapse after a strong gust of wind from a severe thuderstorm.
By now you also probably have already heard the stories of people going into the wreckage trying to save lives and get wounded people quick medical attention. 5 people died in the collapse that Indiana governor Mitch Daniels called a "fluke." In all honesty though, was it really a fluke? For several days in advance of the concert (and the state fair), the National Weather Service had predicted a possible severe weather event with strong winds and hail for that Saturday night. On the day of the event, the Weather Service had issued a Severe Thunderstorm Watch, which indicates that conditions are favorable for severe thunderstorm development. At 8:39, the Weather Service issued a Severe Thuderstorm Warning, which indicates that severe weather conditions are imminent or are already occuring. The stage collapse occured at 8:49. However, in spite of the official warning, the show must go on. I'm sure those people in the stands paid a pretty penny to see Sugarland perform. They don't play concerts for free. Therefore, despite the warning, and the extremely ominous sky, event organizers decided that it was more important that people get their money's worth on their tickets and not take necessary safety precautions like finding shelter. 10 minutes after the warning, CRASH! The governor has called this a "fluke" event, but in reality, it wasn't. This was a well-predicted meteorological event the destructive nature of which cannot be overlooked. The number one priority should have been safety. Allow the storm to pass, then restart the concert. If you have to postpone it, you postpone it. People get rainchecks on baseball games all the time for the same reason. If the band's busy schedule will not allow a postponement, well, then sorry. Give everybody their refund.
When a severe thunderstorm warning is issued, the number one thing to do is find an interior room of the house AWAY FROM WINDOWS. Why do you get away from windows? Simply, strong gusts of wind can break the glass. Glass is fragile, just like a temporary stage that was going to be taken down not too long after the concert ended anyway. It was not designed to withstand 65 mph wind gusts. If the severe thunderstorm were to develop into a tornado (not uncommon in the midwest as many of you probably know), you move to the lowest interior room in the house. Does this mean that the very fact a warning was issued means your house will get blown away? No, it doesn't, but all it takes is one time for disaster to strike. A stage is just a stage. A house is just a house. They can be rebuilt. You don't take chances with people's lives. Let this be a lesson to future state fair organizers who choose to bring Sugarland (or any other band) to be their featured act.
By now you also probably have already heard the stories of people going into the wreckage trying to save lives and get wounded people quick medical attention. 5 people died in the collapse that Indiana governor Mitch Daniels called a "fluke." In all honesty though, was it really a fluke? For several days in advance of the concert (and the state fair), the National Weather Service had predicted a possible severe weather event with strong winds and hail for that Saturday night. On the day of the event, the Weather Service had issued a Severe Thunderstorm Watch, which indicates that conditions are favorable for severe thunderstorm development. At 8:39, the Weather Service issued a Severe Thuderstorm Warning, which indicates that severe weather conditions are imminent or are already occuring. The stage collapse occured at 8:49. However, in spite of the official warning, the show must go on. I'm sure those people in the stands paid a pretty penny to see Sugarland perform. They don't play concerts for free. Therefore, despite the warning, and the extremely ominous sky, event organizers decided that it was more important that people get their money's worth on their tickets and not take necessary safety precautions like finding shelter. 10 minutes after the warning, CRASH! The governor has called this a "fluke" event, but in reality, it wasn't. This was a well-predicted meteorological event the destructive nature of which cannot be overlooked. The number one priority should have been safety. Allow the storm to pass, then restart the concert. If you have to postpone it, you postpone it. People get rainchecks on baseball games all the time for the same reason. If the band's busy schedule will not allow a postponement, well, then sorry. Give everybody their refund.
When a severe thunderstorm warning is issued, the number one thing to do is find an interior room of the house AWAY FROM WINDOWS. Why do you get away from windows? Simply, strong gusts of wind can break the glass. Glass is fragile, just like a temporary stage that was going to be taken down not too long after the concert ended anyway. It was not designed to withstand 65 mph wind gusts. If the severe thunderstorm were to develop into a tornado (not uncommon in the midwest as many of you probably know), you move to the lowest interior room in the house. Does this mean that the very fact a warning was issued means your house will get blown away? No, it doesn't, but all it takes is one time for disaster to strike. A stage is just a stage. A house is just a house. They can be rebuilt. You don't take chances with people's lives. Let this be a lesson to future state fair organizers who choose to bring Sugarland (or any other band) to be their featured act.
Beck, Grossman, and Andrew Luck
Interesting piece on Dan Graziano's NFC East Blog today. He talks about the quarterback "competition" between John Beck and Rex Grossman. However, some might even wonder if Mike Shanahan is just conceding on the season by A) not making a serious attempt at keeping Donovan McNabb or B) not making a serious play on another veteran quarterback who can contribute right away. Why would we he want to "tank" the season with either Beck or Grossman under center? The answer is quite simple. Andrew Luck (barring injury or other disaster) is going to be the undisputed #1 overall draft pick in the 2012 NFL Draft. He would have been the #1 pick this year had he not decided to go back to Stanford for his senior season (the distinction this year went to Cam Newton, who looked pretty good in his first preseason game, but did not make one attempt to tuck it and run like he did so well at Auburn). That being said, Andrew Luck is they type of quarterback talent that teams salivate over. Since he's pretty much guaranteed the #1 pick next year (again, barring disaster scenarios), the formula for getting him is pretty simple. Play as bad as you possibly can: 2 wins max, 0-16 just to be safe. Many look at what the Redskins are doing as just our way of making sure we are as bad as possible so that we get the #1 pick and therefore Andrew Luck.
As bad as the Redskins have been since we last won the Super Bowl following the 1991 season, we have never been so bad as to have the #1 pick. In fact, the Redskins have NEVER had the #1 pick in our entire team history (78 years worth). There has always been at least a couple teams worse than us. My question to Shanahan (and by proxy Daniel Snyder) is this. Season ticket sales and waitlist sales are already dropping precipitously as it is. What possible good will it do for the team and the organization by tanking a season so that we get an outside chance at a kid who could be the next Peyton Manning...or the next Ryan Leaf? It's not worth it. Snyder's ultimate fear is blackouts (which has not been a problem in the last 30 years since we have sold out every game since 1980). That could very well happen if we put a product on the field this year that wins at most 2 games.
If you believe the Shanahan duo (Mike and Kyle), they would have you believe that they really like what they see in Grossman and Beck in particular. Grossman led the Chicago Bears to the Super Bowl in 2006 (on a team that was led mostly by defense and Devin Hester returning kicks...wonder how much HE likes the new kickoff rule...). Beck has a lot of so-called "upside," but the one shot he had at starting was in 2007 after Trent Green got hurt with Miami. He went 0-5 on the way to a 1-15 season (the one win being earned by Cleo Lemmon). So on the surface, it appears as if neither Beck nor Grossman have the kind of pedigree to lead this team to anything more than a mediocre season. Now, Beck has been talking some serious smack since it became clear that McNabb was not in the team's plans this year. Beck has said from the get go that he would be the starter. Grossman has even gone so far as to say that the Redskins would even win the NFC East. I like the enthusiasm, but even still they need to know that they are not superstars, and other than Moss and Cooley, they don't have superstar talent around them. However, if they play as well as they did against Pittsburgh in the preseason game last weekend, who knows? There are 3 more preseason games to go...
As bad as the Redskins have been since we last won the Super Bowl following the 1991 season, we have never been so bad as to have the #1 pick. In fact, the Redskins have NEVER had the #1 pick in our entire team history (78 years worth). There has always been at least a couple teams worse than us. My question to Shanahan (and by proxy Daniel Snyder) is this. Season ticket sales and waitlist sales are already dropping precipitously as it is. What possible good will it do for the team and the organization by tanking a season so that we get an outside chance at a kid who could be the next Peyton Manning...or the next Ryan Leaf? It's not worth it. Snyder's ultimate fear is blackouts (which has not been a problem in the last 30 years since we have sold out every game since 1980). That could very well happen if we put a product on the field this year that wins at most 2 games.
If you believe the Shanahan duo (Mike and Kyle), they would have you believe that they really like what they see in Grossman and Beck in particular. Grossman led the Chicago Bears to the Super Bowl in 2006 (on a team that was led mostly by defense and Devin Hester returning kicks...wonder how much HE likes the new kickoff rule...). Beck has a lot of so-called "upside," but the one shot he had at starting was in 2007 after Trent Green got hurt with Miami. He went 0-5 on the way to a 1-15 season (the one win being earned by Cleo Lemmon). So on the surface, it appears as if neither Beck nor Grossman have the kind of pedigree to lead this team to anything more than a mediocre season. Now, Beck has been talking some serious smack since it became clear that McNabb was not in the team's plans this year. Beck has said from the get go that he would be the starter. Grossman has even gone so far as to say that the Redskins would even win the NFC East. I like the enthusiasm, but even still they need to know that they are not superstars, and other than Moss and Cooley, they don't have superstar talent around them. However, if they play as well as they did against Pittsburgh in the preseason game last weekend, who knows? There are 3 more preseason games to go...
Friday, August 12, 2011
Redskins 16-Steelers7: Game Analysis
All things considered, the Redskins played very well tonight. Now, I understand that last season in the first preseason game, we blasted Buffalo 42-13 or something like that. I will be the first one to tell you that at the end of the day, nobody remembers what you did in the preseason, especially the first game (I say immediately after quoting a score from the first preseason game last year...keep the jokes to a minimum). The bottom line is that when the games start to count, this will mean nothing at all. Nevertheless, I have to say I am happy with what I saw. We only got in the end zone once (a Grossman pass to Santana Moss), but we had several drives longer than 80 yards. Our first drive of the night started at the 1 yard line, and Sexy Rexy marched them all the way to the Pittsburgh 10, only to see the drive stall there and watch Shayne Graham absolutely shank a 27-yarder.
The starters played pretty much the whole first half. Grossman took all of the snaps as John Beck is still trying to push his groin (since he already pulled it). By and large, Grossman's passes were on target, if not perfectly accurate, and Tim Hightower ran the ball effectively. In fact, our running game all night looked pretty good, which is saying something considering how we avoided contact in practice at all costs. Now, I don't know how well-conditioned the Steelers' defensive front was, so let's put it all in perspective. Defensively we looked pretty sharp as well, albeit somewhat lucky. Ben Roethlisberger played only one series, but had Mike Wallace wide open on a 9-route down the left sideline. Somebody blew a coverage on that side of the field, but Big Ben overthrew his man by about 5 yards. Byron Leftwich had several overthrows during his time in the first half as well. On special teams, Shayne Graham was 0-2 missing from 27 and 49 (missing from 27 badly). Graham Gano was 3-3. Two of his makes were in the 30-yard range, and his last kick was 45. Kickers need to be perfect inside of 40 yards if you ask me, so I'm slightly impressed. So in the early going Gano is in the lead in the kicking competition. Brandon Banks had a good night returning kicks, including one kickoff he took 7 yards deep in the end zone and ran it out past midfield. The last guy tackled him saving a touchdown. I'll talk more about kickoffs shortly.
The new guys made some impressions, both good and bad. Leonard Hankerson had his dropsies return, just like I saw at practice on Wednesday. Now, none of the drops came from perfect passes, but if it hits you in the hands (or the numbers) you have to catch it, period. I think he is scared to come across the middle...alligator arms. The new guys at running back were impressive. Roy Helu showed some good quickness in the second half, and ran through a few tackles. Evan Royster showed some good burst as well, especially going around the edge.
I have a few things to say about the new kickoff rule. This past offseason, the competition committee voted to move kickoffs from the 30 to the 35 yard line, only allowing the coverage team a 5-yard run up as well. Naturally, this would mean the number of touchbacks would increase significantly, and every kickoff in this game was a touchback (with the exception of Brandon Banks' runout as I mentioned before). The rule was put in place ostensibly for player "safety." Reducing the number of kickoff returns reduces the chance at injury. Well, it's pretty easy to make kickoff returns safe when you take them out of the game all together. Just put the ball at the 20 and cut out the formality, why don't you? One of the most exciting plays in football is the kickoff return for a touchdown. Now, the likelihood of that happening this season is virtually zero. What you are going to see is players like Brandon Banks and Devin Hester running kicks back that they field 7, 8, 9 yards deep in the end zone, just to give them a shot at a runback, even when judgement may be the better part of valor. You watch, in 2012, the kickoff will be back at the 30, but the rules will not be the same as they are now.
Overall, I can't really complain with what I saw tonight. All things considered, we looked pretty good. We didn't turn the ball over once (but we didn't take it away either), and we were only flagged for I think 3 or 4 penalties: pretty good considering how sloppy I was expecting the game to go tonight. I'm not booking my flight to Indy yet by any means, although I'm sure Kevin Sheehan is. We have 3 more preseason games to examine, and the starters will have a little more time to work. We will see our fair share of mistakes. We are sure to make many. We still need to see what John Beck can do as well. At the very least, they gave me a reason to watch the next game next week.
The starters played pretty much the whole first half. Grossman took all of the snaps as John Beck is still trying to push his groin (since he already pulled it). By and large, Grossman's passes were on target, if not perfectly accurate, and Tim Hightower ran the ball effectively. In fact, our running game all night looked pretty good, which is saying something considering how we avoided contact in practice at all costs. Now, I don't know how well-conditioned the Steelers' defensive front was, so let's put it all in perspective. Defensively we looked pretty sharp as well, albeit somewhat lucky. Ben Roethlisberger played only one series, but had Mike Wallace wide open on a 9-route down the left sideline. Somebody blew a coverage on that side of the field, but Big Ben overthrew his man by about 5 yards. Byron Leftwich had several overthrows during his time in the first half as well. On special teams, Shayne Graham was 0-2 missing from 27 and 49 (missing from 27 badly). Graham Gano was 3-3. Two of his makes were in the 30-yard range, and his last kick was 45. Kickers need to be perfect inside of 40 yards if you ask me, so I'm slightly impressed. So in the early going Gano is in the lead in the kicking competition. Brandon Banks had a good night returning kicks, including one kickoff he took 7 yards deep in the end zone and ran it out past midfield. The last guy tackled him saving a touchdown. I'll talk more about kickoffs shortly.
The new guys made some impressions, both good and bad. Leonard Hankerson had his dropsies return, just like I saw at practice on Wednesday. Now, none of the drops came from perfect passes, but if it hits you in the hands (or the numbers) you have to catch it, period. I think he is scared to come across the middle...alligator arms. The new guys at running back were impressive. Roy Helu showed some good quickness in the second half, and ran through a few tackles. Evan Royster showed some good burst as well, especially going around the edge.
I have a few things to say about the new kickoff rule. This past offseason, the competition committee voted to move kickoffs from the 30 to the 35 yard line, only allowing the coverage team a 5-yard run up as well. Naturally, this would mean the number of touchbacks would increase significantly, and every kickoff in this game was a touchback (with the exception of Brandon Banks' runout as I mentioned before). The rule was put in place ostensibly for player "safety." Reducing the number of kickoff returns reduces the chance at injury. Well, it's pretty easy to make kickoff returns safe when you take them out of the game all together. Just put the ball at the 20 and cut out the formality, why don't you? One of the most exciting plays in football is the kickoff return for a touchdown. Now, the likelihood of that happening this season is virtually zero. What you are going to see is players like Brandon Banks and Devin Hester running kicks back that they field 7, 8, 9 yards deep in the end zone, just to give them a shot at a runback, even when judgement may be the better part of valor. You watch, in 2012, the kickoff will be back at the 30, but the rules will not be the same as they are now.
Overall, I can't really complain with what I saw tonight. All things considered, we looked pretty good. We didn't turn the ball over once (but we didn't take it away either), and we were only flagged for I think 3 or 4 penalties: pretty good considering how sloppy I was expecting the game to go tonight. I'm not booking my flight to Indy yet by any means, although I'm sure Kevin Sheehan is. We have 3 more preseason games to examine, and the starters will have a little more time to work. We will see our fair share of mistakes. We are sure to make many. We still need to see what John Beck can do as well. At the very least, they gave me a reason to watch the next game next week.
Nick's Lists: Top 10 Quarterbacks in NFL History (5-1)
Great start to our quarterbacks countdown yesterday. I know that this is just one man's list, but you will see that many of the same names appear, just not in the same order. It always makes for fun discussion, and hopefully that will continue today as we move into our top 5. Let's start as always with our honorable mention list:
Troy Aikman (Dallas Cowboys 1989-2001)-Sure he was a good QB, he had weapons in Emmitt Smith and Michael Irvin, but the signature moment of his career as far as I'm concerned is this. Enjoy :-)
Terry Bradshaw (Pittsburgh Steelers 1970-1983)-While I said in my intro yesterday that Bradshaw doesn't make the official list because of his help, it doesn't take away from the fact that he was a pretty good quarterback. Somebody had to feed it to Swann and Stallworth, but on the other hand, he was credited with a 60 yard TD pass to Franco Harris in the playoffs against Oakland that quite frankly should have never happened.
Kurt Warner (St. Louis Rams 1999-2003; New York Giants 2004; Arizona Cardinals 2005-2010)-One of the best feel good stories around, Kurt Warner made a living bagging groceries in Iowa and toiling in obscurity in the Arena League. Perhaps it was fate when Trent Green got injured in the preseason and he had to step in. All he did was lead the greatest show on turf to a win in Super Bowl XXXIV. Perhaps his biggest accomplishment was leading the Cardinals to the Super Bowl, period!
Steve Young (San Francisco 49ers 1987-1999)-This one will probably be a bit controversial as many view Young as a quarterback who never really had a chance to show off as much as he could have. Being Joe Montana's backup can do that to you. Nevertheless, he did do enough to win a Super Bowl for himself (XXIX) and make the Hall of Fame on the first ballot, so somebody noticed him. Young made a name for himself in a way that Montana never could have imagined, with his legs. Young made the running quarterback an en vouge thing to be.
Brett Favre (Atlanta Falcons 1992-1993; Green Bay Packers 1994-2007; New York Jets 2008; Minnesota Vikings 2009-2010...Who knows where else?)-Favre is a sure-fire Hall of Famer. Nobody is doubting that. However, his diva-ish antics of the last few years retiring and unretiring and trying to get back at Ted Thompson in Green Bay had made him just look downright foolish. Behavior aside, Favre is a pretty good QB (notice the word is...I'm not convinced he's done done). Kind of in the mold of a Steve Young, he led the Packers to the Super Bowl 2 years in a row, winning Super Bowl XXXI. Oh yea, he also had a cannon (emphasis on the had...)
Alright, enough HM bashing...let's move into the main course of the day. Let's take a look at Caputo's Corner's TOP 5 QUARTERBACKS IN NFL HISTORY!
Troy Aikman (Dallas Cowboys 1989-2001)-Sure he was a good QB, he had weapons in Emmitt Smith and Michael Irvin, but the signature moment of his career as far as I'm concerned is this. Enjoy :-)
Terry Bradshaw (Pittsburgh Steelers 1970-1983)-While I said in my intro yesterday that Bradshaw doesn't make the official list because of his help, it doesn't take away from the fact that he was a pretty good quarterback. Somebody had to feed it to Swann and Stallworth, but on the other hand, he was credited with a 60 yard TD pass to Franco Harris in the playoffs against Oakland that quite frankly should have never happened.
Kurt Warner (St. Louis Rams 1999-2003; New York Giants 2004; Arizona Cardinals 2005-2010)-One of the best feel good stories around, Kurt Warner made a living bagging groceries in Iowa and toiling in obscurity in the Arena League. Perhaps it was fate when Trent Green got injured in the preseason and he had to step in. All he did was lead the greatest show on turf to a win in Super Bowl XXXIV. Perhaps his biggest accomplishment was leading the Cardinals to the Super Bowl, period!
Steve Young (San Francisco 49ers 1987-1999)-This one will probably be a bit controversial as many view Young as a quarterback who never really had a chance to show off as much as he could have. Being Joe Montana's backup can do that to you. Nevertheless, he did do enough to win a Super Bowl for himself (XXIX) and make the Hall of Fame on the first ballot, so somebody noticed him. Young made a name for himself in a way that Montana never could have imagined, with his legs. Young made the running quarterback an en vouge thing to be.
Brett Favre (Atlanta Falcons 1992-1993; Green Bay Packers 1994-2007; New York Jets 2008; Minnesota Vikings 2009-2010...Who knows where else?)-Favre is a sure-fire Hall of Famer. Nobody is doubting that. However, his diva-ish antics of the last few years retiring and unretiring and trying to get back at Ted Thompson in Green Bay had made him just look downright foolish. Behavior aside, Favre is a pretty good QB (notice the word is...I'm not convinced he's done done). Kind of in the mold of a Steve Young, he led the Packers to the Super Bowl 2 years in a row, winning Super Bowl XXXI. Oh yea, he also had a cannon (emphasis on the had...)
Alright, enough HM bashing...let's move into the main course of the day. Let's take a look at Caputo's Corner's TOP 5 QUARTERBACKS IN NFL HISTORY!
Nick's Lists: Top 10 Quarterbacks in NFL History (10-6)
So as I sit here...ill...on Thursday evening, I have had a little more time to think about things. One of the things I've had time to contemplate is FOOTBALL! Tonight was the first round of preseason games, starting with the Philadelphia Eagles and the Baltimore Ravens and then we have the Seattle Seahawks and San Diego Chargers over on ESPN. I know the games don't count, but it looks good to watch overgrown men knock heads on a gridiron again. The Redskins open their preseason tomorrow against Pittsburgh.
In the meantime, I know I am long since due for another top 10 list. So I'm gonna get started on one right now. I'll try to do a few of these in the lead up to the regular season sort of as as 2011 season primer. I'm not going to do like player rankings or things like that because I don't want to give any insider fantasy advice to my opponents in MIISFFL (you know who you are...). I am fascinated by the history of football, so I am going to do a positional top 10 of the best at each position in history. Tonight I start with the field generals: the quarterbacks.
I've always said that I don't like the play the quarterback position, but I'll do it if people want me to. Quarterback is a very cerebral position. I can handle the mental aspects of the position (kind of like an on-field coach), but I don't really have the arm strength. The best quarterbacks have an uncanny combination of both. In today's game, there are not really a lot of quarterbacks that fit that description, although a couple do make this list as you'll see. Quaterbacks on this list you will see are not just masters of the deep ball. They are masterful game-day tacticians. They don't have to win Super Bowls to make the list either. There is so much that goes into winning a Super Bowl that the quarterback does NOT have control over (i.e. defense) that I don't put Super Bowl winnings very high on the list. Terry Bradshaw won 4 Super Bowls with Pittsburgh, but he's NOT on my list, quite frankly, because I don't view him as an elite gameday tactician. He's a great TV commentator, but those Pittsburgh teams were so loaded, Bradshaw really just had to make sure he didn't fumble the snap and they would win. So, enough introduction...let's examine Caputo's Corner's TOP 10 QUARTERBACKS OF ALL TIME!!
In the meantime, I know I am long since due for another top 10 list. So I'm gonna get started on one right now. I'll try to do a few of these in the lead up to the regular season sort of as as 2011 season primer. I'm not going to do like player rankings or things like that because I don't want to give any insider fantasy advice to my opponents in MIISFFL (you know who you are...). I am fascinated by the history of football, so I am going to do a positional top 10 of the best at each position in history. Tonight I start with the field generals: the quarterbacks.
I've always said that I don't like the play the quarterback position, but I'll do it if people want me to. Quarterback is a very cerebral position. I can handle the mental aspects of the position (kind of like an on-field coach), but I don't really have the arm strength. The best quarterbacks have an uncanny combination of both. In today's game, there are not really a lot of quarterbacks that fit that description, although a couple do make this list as you'll see. Quaterbacks on this list you will see are not just masters of the deep ball. They are masterful game-day tacticians. They don't have to win Super Bowls to make the list either. There is so much that goes into winning a Super Bowl that the quarterback does NOT have control over (i.e. defense) that I don't put Super Bowl winnings very high on the list. Terry Bradshaw won 4 Super Bowls with Pittsburgh, but he's NOT on my list, quite frankly, because I don't view him as an elite gameday tactician. He's a great TV commentator, but those Pittsburgh teams were so loaded, Bradshaw really just had to make sure he didn't fumble the snap and they would win. So, enough introduction...let's examine Caputo's Corner's TOP 10 QUARTERBACKS OF ALL TIME!!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)

