Saturday, August 20, 2011

Nick's Lists: Top 10 Defensive Linemen in NFL History (10-6)

Bet you were expecting me to do wide receivers next, didn't you?  Don't worry, I do have a list of wideouts to yak about, but for the last couple of days, I have been fixated with the defensive line.  Don't ask me why, but I have been.  So the next installment of our preseason top 10s focuses on the big boys who have got their sights set on the quarterback. 

That actually is a misconception about defensive linemen.  Most people think that big guys who play these positions have one statistic on their minds: sacks.  While this may be true for some defensive ends, this is not the case, far from it.  There is a HUGE difference between how you play defensive end and defensive tackle.  In a very oversimplified sense, defensive linemen are supposed to be space eaters.  The best defensive linemen are able to shoot gaps and command double teams from the offensive line.  This is kind of a catch-22.  The best linemen are good enough that they get double-teamed every time the ball is snapped.  This means that they probably will not get a whole lot of sacks (or tackles for that matter).  On the other hand, if you single up these guys, they probably will get a ton of sacks and tackles.  When linemen battle in the trenches, you often hear commentators say that they are "controlling the line of scrimmage."  This is more true than you imagine.  It is a lot easier to dictate the flow of the game going forward than backward.  The best defensive lines are able to reestablish the line of scrimmage a yard or two in the backfield and put the offensive line on their heels.  On the other hand, the best offensive lines reestablish the line of scrimmage a yard or two forward.  The reestablishment of the line of scrimmage makes it much easier for playmakers (in the defense's case, linebackers) to knife into the backfield and make plays.  Linebackers are typically the best tacklers on the team. 

If sacks really to suit your fancy, you are more likely to get them out of defensive ends.  There has historically always been a debate to figure out what the ideal size and weight of a defensive (and offensive) lineman should be.  For many years, the answer has been bigger and heavier.  The logic quite simply is that bigger and heavier means stronger and more overpowering.  However, in recent seasons, teams have picked up that big and heavy also can translate into fat and slow.  What does that mean?  The best defensive ends are smaller and quicker.  Speed kills, and not just at wide receiver.  The best sack masters nowadays are those who look like they are small enough to play linebacker, but are quick enough to get a first step on an offensive tackle who has reaction time that is just that much slower.  Throw in a nifty swim or spin move, watch the sack numbers pile up. 

There is a big difference between ends and tackles in a 4-3 compared to a 3-4 set.  Most of the sack-generating defensive ends come from a 4-3 set, as they are in a position on the edge of the interior line where a good speed rush can get to the quarterback.  However, in a 3-4 set, the defensive ends act more like defensive tackles in a 4-3, allowing linebackers to get most of the sack totals.  However, the success and failure of a 3-4 depends on one position: the nose guard.  The nose guard lines up directly over the football, and is supposed to be the biggest guy on that side.  He dictates which direction the offensive line goes.  The best nose tackles not only command double teams, but also is able to move the offensive line side to side, allowing other defenders to make plays.  Nose guard is a very unrewarding position, especially when it comes to stats, but how well the nose guard plays is critical to the success of a 3-4 defensive scheme. 

Today's list will focus on both defensive ends and defensive tackles (and nose guards).  Let the debates begin as we examine the TOP 10 DEFENSIVE LINEMEN IN NFL HISTORY!

10) William Perry (Chicago Bears 1985-92; Philadelphia Eagles 1993-94)


From espn.com
 Mike Ditka once said that once William Perry became more of a fat guy than a football player, he had no more use for him.  You don't earn a nickname such as "the Refrigerator" without having a little girth.  Perry had more than just a little girth.  His peak playing weight was 382 pounds.  When you consider that the Hogs offensive line for the Redskins (one of the heaviest offensive lines of the day) averaged just around 280 pounds, Perry was clearly in a league of his own.  Early in his career, Perry used his size exceptionally well.  As a defensive tackle, he commanded double teams on every play, allowing sack masters Richard Dent and Mike Singletary to wreak havoc in opponents' backfields.  Buddy Ryan's 46 defense depended on linemen lining up in unorthodox positions, preventing offensive linemen from getting upfield to help the running game.  Perry moved offensive lines backwards by his shear size alone.  Ditka used Perry in multiple ways besides defensive line.  Perhaps his most notable contribution was as a fullback in short yardage situations.  Perry would act either as a lead blocker for Walter Payton, or would carry the ball himself, even scoring a touchdown in Super Bowl XX from the 1 yard line.  Later in his career, his skills as a football player diminished, leading to Ditka's quote and the Bears releasing Perry before the 1993 season.  He played 2 years with the Eagles before finally retiring. 

9) Fred Dean (San Diego Chargers 1975-80; San Francisco 49ers 1981-85)


From profootballhof.com
 I was fortunate to see Fred Dean enshrined in the Pro Football Hall of Fame in 2008.  While I was not there to see him personally (couple guys named Art and Darrell were on my wish list), Fred Dean's induction speech was by far the most entertaining.  Rhetoric aside, Dean was a dominant defensive presence.  He recorded nearly 100 sacks over his career.  We don't know exactly how many sacks he had since sacks were not an official statistic in th eearly days of Dean's career with the Chargers.  By the time he retired they were, but there was a certain lineback with initials LT that was sacking everything left and right.  Dean was disruptive in the backfield, moving offenses backwards and forcing fumbles.  When they did start recording sacks in 1982, Dean was in San Francisco and set a then-record with 6 sacks in one game.  He also led the NFC in 1983 with 17.5 sacks. 

8) Art Donovan (Baltimore Colts 1950, 1953-61)


From sportsblink.com
 Donovan was a key cog in the defensive line that shut down the potent New York Giants rushing attack in the 1958 NFL Championship game (the Greatest Game Ever Played).  Not only did Donovan command the double teams defensive linemen crave, he was able to break them, forcing offensive linemen to give even more attention to Donovan.  This allowed playmakers like Gino Marchetti and and Don Joyce to reap the benefits and rack up the sack totals.  Probably just as important as his presence on the defensive line was Donovan's sharp wit and humor.  While his football skill eventually diminished with age, his wit probably got stronger.  Donovan's face could be seen all around Baltimore well into his later years doing ads for everything from The Money Store, athletic apparell, to even pest control.  Donovan was a magnet for the camera, and he usually shined in front of it, making apperances on everything from late night TV to the Adventures of Pete and Pete on Nickelodeon.

7) Bruce Smith (Buffalo Bills 1985-99; Washington Redskins 2000-03)

While Jim Kelly, Thurman Thomas, and Andre Reed orchestrated the K-gun offense that dominated the AFC in the 90s, Bruce Smith anchored the defensive line that helped make the Buffalo Bills the best team in the conference for several years (they just couldn't quite pull it off in the Super Bowl...).  Smith finished his career in obscurity in Washington, but does hold the career record for all time sacks with 200, passing Lawrence Taylor.  What made Bruce Smith such an effective pass rusher was not only his speed on an outside rush, but when an offensive tackle least expected it, he would bullrush right over him and back into the quarterback.  Effective speed rushes usually mean that the bullrush is also effective because it can be used when the tackle least expects it.  Smith is also responsible for one of only 4 safeties to occur in the Super Bowl, when he sacked Jeff Hostetler in the end zone in the second quarter of Super Bowl XXV.  However, many analysts feel like that safety is one of the reasons why the Bills lost the game instead of won.  Smith made an effort to knock the ball out of Hostetler's hand, but Hostetler held on, and despite the safety, saved the Giants 5 points in a game that was ultimately decided by just 1.  Super Bowl XXV is also the #1 Super Bowl on Josh and Dustin's Super Bowl Countdown.


6) Dexter Manley (Washington Redskins 1981-89; Arizona Cardinals 1990, Tampa Bay Buccaneers 1991)

In a town where the military plays an active a role in society as any other, earning the nickname the Secretary of Defense is a high honor, but that's not what I remember Dexter the most fondly for.  It's this (fast forward to the 35 second mark).  Enjoy.


"I wanted to just put his lights out!"  Put Danny White's lights out Dexter certainly did in the 1982 NFC Championship.  White did not return to the game and Jeff Hogeboom took over, but Dexter wasn't done.  Fast forward to 1:05 of that same video and you'll see Dexter read screen, bat the ball in the air, and watch Darryl Grant pick it off and score the touchdown that put Dallas out of their misery.  That's what Dexter could do, he could go full steam ahead and put somebody's lights out, but he also had the field awareness to know when that might not be the most prudent move.  Unfortunately, later in his life, Dexter developed drug problems, but he recovered from those, and to this day, Dexter Manley is still one of the most beloved Redskins of the Super Bowl era. 

And that starts our countdown of the top 10 defensive linemen in NFL history.  Hope you enjoyed it.  I'll be back later with the top 5. 

1 comment:

  1. The Fridge was not even the best Defensive Tackle on his own team. Hall of Fame Defensive Tackle Dan Hampton was much better and Hampton played long before the Fridge arrived so Hampton's career didn't beneifit only because of the Fridge

    ReplyDelete